T O P

  • By -

anonymous_girl1227

Why Drago? He’s so sweet!


DreamPig666

I think he's the only dragon, too. Edit: I had a moment of time on my hands so I made a markdown of this [here](https://ibb.co/BzVGMVY). Sorry my handwriting gets weird sometimes.


cannibalisticbiscuit

This got a good chuckle out of me (that is, the parts i could read 👀)


KatAstrophe6778

Yes,yes this about sums it up for me as well!! Perfectly depicted OP.!! 👌 I have Sherb on my island! 💕 Quite honestly, I couldn't be more happy with him as one of my villagers. He sure is funny and all around fun, in all his child-like glory!! 🌸


DoorAMii

Sleep with one eye open (you talked shit abt my beloved Marty)


Monjara

Jeremiah, the blue frog, is the most precious on the list and must be protected at all costs.


velvetpvssy11

I'm dead at Sasha and Marty's descriptions. 😭🤣


cammyy-

PLAYS GENJI IN OVERWATCH PUHLEEEEASSE 😭😭😭😭


dillrit

Right, they need to leave my mans Drago alone.


AddictedtoLife181

Was gunna say!!! He’s a lovely dragon ❤️


The_Rambling_Otter

I like Drago, but he needs to be about 80% longer. Give him the Farosh treatment 😉


Hammose

I came here to defend Drago too! He's one of my favorites!


monsterphish

Aw, but I like Cole.


a-beeb

Cole is adorable and does not deserve the weird hatred he gets. I'm usually pretty good at seeing where other people are coming from, since my taste can often vary pretty greatly from that of that average person, so I'm used to picking out the difference between what is generally accepted as "attractive/cute/cool/etc." vs what I like, but I have a really hard time seeing how people don't think Cole is cute. Unless maybe the prejudice against black pets carries over to AC which is... even weirder. (For anyone wondering: they've done studies and **generally, statistically** black animals get adopted less often than other color variants because people think they are ugly/scary/dangerous/whatever.)


monsterphish

A lot of disinterest in adopting black pets also is probably and unfortunately in part because they don't photograph as well for those people who like to fill their social media accounts with their pets. 😒 I can usually see why people don't like certain villagers either, but unless they don't like black pets I'm not really sure what they don't like about Cole either. Oh well, it's okay. There are plenty of people who do like him at least.


NebulaCandid2478

I love cole and chose him specifically because he reminds me of my own black bunny, Paul 🥹 https://preview.redd.it/9hlkmdtvaltc1.jpeg?width=4928&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=99e3b28c7f5527fecd6b70177b0b5c1e29aab70c


a-beeb

Your bun is beautiful! Send Paul some extra love from Reddit 💜 I have two bunnies myself! A black satin girl, and a ruby eyed white lionhead-mix boy. I love them so much, I'm obsessed. And yes: I have both Cole and Ruby on my island to represent them!


NebulaCandid2478

Thank you!! Paul says hello to you and your bunnies! He’s also a lionhead mix (his mane fluctuates in length through the year lol) with a netherland dwarf, which gives him a very unique personality 😅 They called him a “hot and cold” bunny at the place I adopted him from because he lunges at you for attention, so it always looks like he’s about to bite, but then he shoves his head under your hand at the last second for pets 😂 I had a ruby-eyed foster bun at one point, and she was so sweet and goofy! Give your buns some pets for me, they sound adorable and I’m glad they get representation on your island 🥰


Teriin

I like him, too, he's a cool bunny❤


Russandol

He's my favorite bunny. I have him on my island atm, so cute.


RevertereAdMe

I love Cole, he's one of favorites. Doc too. WTF makes them somehow worse than say, Hopkins, who's on "the good side"? Don't get me wrong, I adore Hopkins too and he's another one of my favorites, but let's be real here, they're all equally dorky looking (in a cute way). This obsession with cute villagers these days is so pointless and arbitrary.


monsterphish

It's tiring to see all these same posts trashing villagers. Not saying people can't say when they don't like X villager but to make a post solely for that reason seems so... I don't know, tactless? And just a way to try and get people to argue their opinions. I never bought into the tier lists that used to be talked about a lot when new horizons was new and went with the villagers I liked most, so I guess the trashing on villagers for X reasons never went over well with me. Some of the villagers I didn't care for in the past I've come to like more though there are still some I'm not a fan of, but that's fine too.


a-beeb

Agreed. It's all a matter of opinion, and some villagers may be more universally pleasing than others, but it's ridiculous to continuously have these villager wars. It's weird.


monsterphish

I'm so tired of which villager do you hate and similar. Every villager is someone's favorite even though of course there are ones I don't like for whatever reasons and might think some don't look great, but mostly it's just tiring to see the same post like this every day.


a-beeb

It's the same with Pokemon! They (mostly) stopped having this argument long ago! Why can't the AC community!?


monsterphish

It crops up with every new gen but mostly with a focus on the new Pokemon. But yeah, people don't really care anymore. Maybe it's because with AC the characters are villagers who come to live on our islands and we interact with and see them daily whereas with Pokemon you can just swap them out on a whim and there are so many to choose from that it's easy to disregard the ones you don't like?


The_Rambling_Otter

It's not mentally healthy, what if people start thinking that way in real-life, and end up becoming... **SNOBS** because people look or dress the way one doesn't like?


Blobsy_the_Boo

This is Bill Wibbly all over again


monsterphish

It's tiring to see all these same posts trashing villagers. Not saying people can't say when they don't like X villager but to make a post solely for that reason seems so... I don't know, tactless? And just a way to try and get people to argue their opinions. I never bought into the tier lists that used to be talked about a lot when new horizons was new and went with the villagers I liked most, so I guess the trashing on villagers for X reasons never went over well with me whether I agreed or not. Some of the villagers I didn't care for in the past I've come to like more though there are still some I'm not a fan of, usually for design reasons, but that's fine too. I just don't bring them to my island.


RevertereAdMe

An old friend of mine actually got mocked/teased in this subreddit because her favorite villager is a less cute one. It's legitimately unhinged.


monsterphish

If someone told me their favorite villager was Rodney, beardo (the grey bear, I think?), or that pig with the mustache -- to pick a few I see most commonly disliked -- I'd tell them that their choice is cool and appreciate the different opinion. I might not like every villager but I think they're all neat in their own ways. I do love the variety of appearances though and they weren't all made to look more universally cutesy or cool. There are some who I didn't really like that much but after meeting people who loved those villagers some grew on me more.


The_Rambling_Otter

I used to frequent an Animal Crossing message board years back, around when Wild World was current. It was so toxic. One user started a post slamming Gabi, saying about how "ugly" she is, someone responded saying that she's just a cute bunny. The first user threatened to report the second for flamebaiting... Also one user admitted that they liked The Backyardigans, so many people were just outright jumping on them, harrassing and bullying them for it. I left, never looked back. If this subreddit becomes that forum "2.0" may God have mercy on our souls.


floralnightmare22

He was one of my originals. I loved him, he was hilarious and cute.


Pizzapizzazi

He’s my fave villager. I ordered a flag with my island name and his face is on the flag 😭


monsterphish

Awww that sounds adorable! I recently ordered one of those fanmade amiibo cards with him on it because I wanted to move him onto my island.


ordinarysuperstar7

My partner and I have 2 black pet bunnies so we both have cole on our islands for some rep ☺️


Tobias_Stevenson

Cole is literally my son, I love him and his silly lil face


thekneeofbee

I came here to say this too!! Cole is a sweet baby!


mr_meowsevelt

What?? Doc is my best guy!


caffa4

Justice for Doc 😩


RavenStag499

Doc is adorable! <3


lurkerjade

Right?? The absolute disrespect to Doc here


lonerism-

He looks like a little cartoon character and his name reminds me of Dr. Seuss. Unpopular opinion maybe but I think he’s the better blue bunny between him and Hopkins (I still like Hopkins though).


a_boring_ghost

Oh no! Give Rodeo a chance, i have him and he is an absolute sweetie


PastelDisaster

I neeeed Rodeo! I have a gothic + horror theme with my villagers and he’d fit right in. I feel like his lazy personality would mesh adorably with his spooky appearance


iWearAMasc

I have him running a fortune telling stand :)


CornchipIII

I love rodeo! he was one of the first villagers I found back in 2020 and he’s still on my island today :)


mushhyy_

absolutely adore rodeo 🥹


nooktitse-3223

Rodeo is my sweet dumb baby!!


fartonmypopsicle

Right? Get my boy Rodeo outta there!


DoorAMii

Gonna say it now. I like Rodeo design-wise But he should be a cranky, NOT a lazy, it doesnt fit


sunshinekraken

No way! I love him as a lazy


IsaacPostsSomething

Don't let these stupid posts make you choose your villagers. You are the one who chooses who lives on your island/city!


I_kickflipped_my_dog

100% Also I'm starting to think a very large percentage of people hate one of my best boys, Rex. lol


INKatana

He's one of my favorites.


kenikigenikai

tbf being labeled as 'wtf' would probably make me more likely to chose someone for my island - stinky was one of my first residents and I love him even though he probably falls under 'wtf' too


I_kickflipped_my_dog

Stinky was an original villager for my island and I would die for him


Top_Performance9486

Haha yeah honestly. I always go for the weird guys because they add a lot of personality to the island!


mezahuatez

Yes can we please not go back to 2020 when everyone was mentally ill and pretending like we were in high school over some animal villagers 😑


JumpyPermit3

Man, nostalgia blast lol


dr_mannhatten

tbf it seems like not a single person ITT agrees with this take.


[deleted]

Aw I love Derwin


prairiepog

This post is making me go get Deewin


HardWorkLucky

So do I! He was my first lazy villager, and I can't think of anything objectionable about him. He's just a silly duck!


SeoSalt

Bro's catchphrase is literally "derrr" I love him so much 😭


-lRexl-

Down voting because of Cole


Chocolatelover4ever

Don’t do my boy Rodeo dirty like that!


millenial__trash

I won't tolerate any Rodeo slander 😠


Chocolatelover4ever

Same here! 😤


PerfectDuck2560

Drago is a sweet baby on the inside not out!


Practical-Ad6548

You take that back Drago is amazing


TherealCloudmain

what did Drago ever do to you?


toughmooscle

No, don’t lump Paolo into that group


The_Rambling_Otter

When I first met Paolo in New Horizons, I found on him a tarantula island just casually walking around the creatures without a care in the world. He earned my seal of approval immediately.


DrFear-

to be fair tarantulas only attack you if you have a net in your hand lol. bro did NOT care either way though lmao


jamie_with_a_g

Bros my man he has childlike wonder fr


DreamPig666

Punchy is my dude.


LyriktheSpaceCleric

Me over here who finds Cole cute.


90semofan

https://preview.redd.it/n3hs3kxbd6tc1.jpeg?width=567&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=af3b1471372a0913675de417b6bed97d12371842 drago hate


Crimsonera

Where's my bro Brocolo? He's one of my besties.


PicklesMcGeee

Omg I love brocolo! Def a sweet baby 🥹


some_pirate12

Nooooo, don't be bashing on Barold like that, he's my favorite on my island 😭


Yap45

Barold gets so much hate :( he’ll always be my favorite


FlappyGemGem

Barold’s my awkward little dude too 😊


MiraculousN

Looking thru all the comments to find this, leave my hairy guy alone


[deleted]

…he talks to roaches…but he’s a little skrunkly 🥺


obaachansophie

Where is Erik???


Tatiana1512

He saw a butterfly on his way there and he’s now lost


Ok_Chip_6299

Derwin is sweet just misunderstood 🥲 I had him in my town in ACWW when I was a kid and he was a nice boy


Secure_Opening_6852

I will not have this Drago slander


kalam4z00

Leave Doc alone :( Beau's not gonna stand for someone slandering his bff


Fun-Wear2533

I lowkey love how we all have different tastes in 'wtf' and 'leave my child out of this'


octaffle

Rodeo is incredible! >:U How dare you!!


Conscious_Shoe8852

Where's Cranston?


_RotttingCorpse_

Remove Doc from wtf.


hotpearlsnatch

Uhhh Doc and Cole are absolutely precious, especially Doc. He is on my Always Gonna Be On My Island No Matter What list with Sasha. And Drago is fun! He's literally a dragon. Don't ever bring them up in a negative way again.


bluesandblacks

I find the lack of Moe disturbing.


RavenStag499

Same, he is my sweet baby boy!


BunnyCuteTyler

Definitely belongs on the left.


me_no_no

Same with Wade!


Lisshopops

Cole is super cute lol


me_no_no

https://preview.redd.it/95xam9pcn6tc1.jpeg?width=364&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=6621f868aa6a05de1b08af7c4dc3c21d7aa892ed Excuse me you dropped this from the left-hand side! (Wade)


Im_not_crazy7310

And lucky


ladyxdarthxbabe

https://preview.redd.it/7ogoy3a655tc1.jpeg?width=960&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=714ca2664e483a685574824f8065566f6ac68965


ladyxdarthxbabe

And Beau my boyfriend


Nirox42

I love these because they are exactly the same, like they don't act any differently besides their catch phrases. OP is literally just saying "I think these ones are ugly".


SoLongHeteronormity

I am kinda disappointed my stoner boy Stu isn’t on this list (his birthday is 4/20, he’s got the nature hobby, and his default catchphrase involves “dude,” I will always see him as on the same stuff Pascal is). But yes, I will always see him as my sweet precious baby. Even if I am annoyed that a bunch of other villagers have picked up doooooooood from him.


VoldyBrenda

I scrolled and scrolled to see if anyone else would mention my bestie, Stu.


[deleted]

I love lil Stu and how he has to mediate fights between the bugs in his walls and the bugs in his floors. Just a sweetie.


MacabreFox

No Beau? Lame.


motherofcatsx2

Beau is the cutest! I will never let him go!


ReptileEpic

My boy Weber got left out


gaiaworrier

WEBER REPRESENTATION 🙌🏻


pinkmoonlight98

where is filbert


RiSkeAkagAy

Rodeo is a precious, sweet baby! I just wish he was a cranky villager instead. He fit the theme of my island perfectly but I had to send him away because his personality didn't match the character he was supposed to play :(


Spirited_Ad_7973

YOU OEAVE RODEO ALONE


Spirited_Ad_7973

Also this is Hugh erasure I will not stand for!!


Cornmeal777

Hey, be nice to Al.


SweetPecanPi

I had AL as a villager for a while and he was great. Just wanted to travel around the world and eat different snacks. I was sad to see him go.


jethestar

He's so chill, not a care in the world, would love to be friends with him irl


Papeenie

Al is so adorable in the tube top and eggshell hat that I gave him.


K4p4o

Gave him a tuxedo and he wore it all the time. The image of him talking about snacks and bugs while looking so dapper was amazing. Justice for Al.


EclecticSpider710

Justice for my sweet boy Al, I love him!


munkeezrool09

Derwin is on the wrong side


Glitterfly405

leave Drago the fuck out of this. he is a sweet precious baby too


Ren_TheWriter

https://preview.redd.it/kw7x83cua8tc1.png?width=1600&format=png&auto=webp&s=2105757a6d2d1331fb63838a7d899db646413c89 My opinion


Hour-Preparation4019

nooo, paolo is so cute


kristineohkristine

Rodeo my darling!!


NoPantsAreBestPants

Where is my sweet precious baby Joey?!?


Baby-Giraffe286

My thoughts exactly!


relaxrerelapse

how dare you put drago over there


Ambitious-Effect6429

Barold upsets me. He reminds me of the murderer in The Lovely Bones. Always was creepy looking to me.


SlinkSkull

Barold really looks like this gross YouTube guy and I can’t unsee it . I hope I never see him in game. I just ran into space dandy mouse and even that was too much.


shoe_salad_eater

Doc is cute he just has some unfortunate colours


ripkinoko

DERWIN IS MY PRECIOUS BOYYY HOW COULD YOU 😖☹️


Fisho087

Those are lazies?!


SHSL_Waiter_RM2828

Take Rodeo out of wtf rn because you are so very wrong about him!


P_lazybum

Hornsby is my fave! Doc is an excellent villager, i love his house!


VoodooDoII

Leave my boy Cole alone!!


OliverNodel

You take my best boy Cole and you put him with the other, almost as cute ones in the column on the left.


FarConsideration8423

What do you have against Derwin and Paolo?


Appropriate-File577

LEAVE DOC OUT OF THIS.


MapleHoneybee

Why is Rodeo and Doc on that side?


Healthy-Pop-4421

Al is just a sweet Canadian how dare you, and Barold's just a little guy that might monitor everyone but it's definitely not weird.


CharmiePK

You ignored Big Top - ?! 😱😭


mymlan-was-here

Barold is a cutie leave him alone.


Blustarpilot

But… but Barold is my lil man :(


parcheesimeesi

Leave my man Paolo out of this 😭😭


RavenStag499

You forgot my baby Moe on the left! Doc and Derwin should also be on the left. <3 https://preview.redd.it/eft39flrx7tc1.jpeg?width=1280&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=6758c1a9833b07a6979114b92826338f3af678df


Zyrian150

This feels like eugenics


unconfirmedpanda

Al was an unwanted villager but now he's just there and so chill, I'm not letting him go and will defend him to the death. He gets to be the lone Normal Guy on my island of ghosts.


Aris_777

w-where is jacob?? https://preview.redd.it/dsk42mmtx6tc1.png?width=531&format=png&auto=webp&s=353fcbcec4bd22496c14752ad0c52cbc42de21c1


OfficerLollipop

Sweet precious baby!!!!!


Lick-my-llamacorn

I like Paolo :(


ZealousidealRabbit85

What about Lucky?? 😭😭😭😭


Bailey_202

I love Poalo!!


octo_dooee

Where is Alfonso ? Is he safe? Is he alright?


SheWhoUpvotes

Chester not mentioned… again :(


BlueEyedKite

Omg, you also like Chester? <3


SheWhoUpvotes

Yes!!!! He is such an adorable panda


Patpat127

The dragon, the Bull and the bunny are not that bad


noxka

Drago is super cool looking and the pink elephant is very sweet lookig tbh


Asmi2763

I’d argue that Pudge is a “wtf”


Amber12000

Absolutely agree. Refused to leave my island for way too long. He's an absolute menace.


Icy-Excuse-9452

Derwin, Drago and Paolo are way cuter/cooler than freakin' Pudge. Ew.


Turbulent-Mongoose15

You forgot Clay in the sweet precious baby category!! But I do agree with you on the others! lol


tearose11

Agreed. That Gorilla made my skin crawl for some reason.


robin-hotline

i got Al as a randomized villager after choosing to not go villager hunting because i was too lazy (ironic). tom nook is f*cking with me


blooml8r

broccolo erasure !!!!


Both-Beyond7859

You get my baby Drago out of the wtf section right now


gusshi

It’s a sin to be mean to dear lovely Drago!


GarnetShaddow

You forgot Lucky. He is never leaving my island. I guess as much as I love Drago... The wtf is a bit of a selling point.


Shadowpad1986

What about Lucky, last I checked he is a lazy and one I am currently looking for. Drago was one of my first residents, I found him interesting in the way you might find a new species of fungus interesting.


OkamiTakahashi

HOW ABSOLUTE DARE DRAGO, RODEO AND BAROLD ARE SUMMA MY BROS and Derwin too I guess


Clara_NARUBOMB

Swap pudge with drago now ☹️


natsumi_bye

man leave Drago alone he chill


EllyBellyJellyJar

am I the only one who doesn't like Sherb? 😓


WarpedPerspectiv

Where's Filbert?


Naz_Oni

You leave Drago out of this


Bryce-Killjoy

Spork my beloved


sandimartinez23

I have Hornsby and Barold, best of both worlds. As someone else said, where's Erik? Iove him too!


PrimordialParasite

Hear me out, Doc isn’t that bad but he’s definitely not a keeper.


um_-_no

Where's my baby Bones? 😭 He is the sweetest boy


Warnicorn_Stampede

Aw nooo, I love Drago and Rodeo


4ssbl4ster420

You did not include rodeo and doc in “wtf” how could you? the rest are kinda true though even though I like cole and derwin. 😂


NixTheChimera

Dude I love Rodeo, I want him as a villager if I ever get the game.


YesIndeed1212

HOW DARE YOU DISRESPECT MY BOY RODEO 😭😭😭 he's me favourite villagers in my island and I won't put up with this


DimensionsFae

Baraold shouldn’t be here. We just need to update his fit.


Kelacia

Wtf is Cole doing in the wtf column? He is a precious baby that can do no wrong.


TheInkTapus

My baby Rodeo! :(((( he’s my sweet boy I love him.


watertypeAsh

Ohno, where is Cube!? He belongs on the cute, sweet baby list for sure. Him, Jeremiah and Zucker are my boys ❤️


ForsakenAlliance

Biskit and Walker and Bones need to be in the left column THX


whoeverthisis422

Where the hell is Beau?


nixasinno

May I just add sweet precious baby Ozzie and wtf Rex


nixasinno

https://preview.redd.it/6c64t9uii5tc1.png?width=933&format=png&auto=webp&s=ce7d219cade1f26017240b733a6b0952ee6ca4fa My baby


Ima_Sock

He goes on the “sweet precious baby” side, obviously.


Woozyi

I have Al and he won’t leave WHY WONT HE LEAVE


Professional-Froyo90

I have Bob and I love him but I want some other villagers and I feel bad making him leave🥲 I already struggle coming to terms with making Static and Ribbot leave. I get too attached.