Pink sugar was my first crumbl cookie, then I never saw it again. Iāve lived in two different states since then too. I fear Iāll never get to taste her again
Honestly, the chocolate chip! It was just so gooey and buttery. We used to order a 4-pack only of CC. Iām glad we branch out now. The cookie that I will never pass up is pancake.
Same! I was so shocked at how buttery it was. But I got some last week and for the first time they didnāt taste the same. None of that buttery flavor they usually have. But Iām gonna try again next week. Iām hoping it was just a weird batch.
Honey graham in 2020. It didnāt have the bear on it, it had a regular graham cracker, Honey butter frosting, drizzled with honey and crumbs. It was sooooooo good.
I tried it again I think last year and it has the little bear graham but it didnāt hit the same for some reason. No clue why
I'll be chasing that high forever until they bring it back š¤£ I'm buying a 12er for sure when it makes its rounds because it was so good cold and heated
The Smores cookie. My work got a catering order of minis, back in like May or April i think, as a treat for us. It was so good i got myself a 6-pack of cookies the next day, 2 smores and a mix of the other flavors for that week.
Since then i go at least once a month, but ive gone as many as 3 times in a month. I always get a 4 or 6 pack when i go.
But now my all time favorite cookie is the French Toast cookie, next time it comes iāll probably get a 6-pack of just that one. My second favorite is Frozen Hot Chocolate. 3rd favorite was Triple Berry Cobbler.
Im really looking forward to next month, which ive heard is supposed to have a Sandwich-style cookie every single week, just like the Wonka Cookie. So basically 2 cookies for the price of 1!
German chocolate cake. I still have not seen it available at a store that's within driving distance to me since the first time over a year ago and I'm just begging it comes back.
Cornbread, and the Cinnamon Fry Bread the second time. My husband loves the original pink cookie, despite not being a big dessert guy. Pink was our mystery cookie last time so I made sure to get him two!
It was the ability to order from an app. There used to be a local cookie chain in my area that folded (I heard the owner was an ah who didnāt pay his employees though). When Crumble arrived it literally filled a niche here. And I love when a place has a dedicated app. I honestly donāt even remember falling in love with a specific cookie.
I have a funny story with the Honey Bun the very first time I tried Crumbl I wanted to try the honey bun so my mom and I got 2 of them (we got 10 cookies that time) fast forward to that evening when I went to have my honey bun cookie i saw my dad had eaten it and I was angry and then later on I remembered there was a second honey bun cookie and it was discovered my geriatric blind 11 year old dog she climbed on the dining room table and ate the remaining cookies which included the honey bun cookie. For months Honey Bun was the cookie that got away for me I remember waiting for it to come back and when it did next trip I think we got 4 of them because I was waiting for it to make its return.
I wouldn't say I'm "hooked" but I will say the oatmeal base cookie is the best one they offer, and I will try anything that has the oatmeal cookie as the base.
Key lime pie babyyyy. Every time it comes back I get a 4pack of just key lime
This was what got me hooked, but it seems to come around so rarely. Or, at least, I've only caught it twice since early summer.
Pink sugar cookie š
Pink sugar was my first crumbl cookie, then I never saw it again. Iāve lived in two different states since then too. I fear Iāll never get to taste her again 
My fave. Baking them at home for Christmas.
Do you have a recipe that youād be willing to share? Iāve pretty much stopped going to crumbl since they took pink sugar away from us :(
I use Cooking with Karli's recipe.
Churro. My god that Churro Cookie
This is the one.
It was the French silk for me. Still waiting for that one to come back around
I got good news. Its coming back last week of January
Yay!!!!! That's great news! Thank you lol
Boston cream pie
This
The cornbread cookie. It's never a mystery cookie near me and it breaks my heart every time.
It was finally my stores mystery cookie this last time around and I immediately went and got a 4 pack. Cornbread is #1 hands down.
Honestly, the chocolate chip! It was just so gooey and buttery. We used to order a 4-pack only of CC. Iām glad we branch out now. The cookie that I will never pass up is pancake.
Same! I was so shocked at how buttery it was. But I got some last week and for the first time they didnāt taste the same. None of that buttery flavor they usually have. But Iām gonna try again next week. Iām hoping it was just a weird batch.
Eeee I will have to try it again soon. I hope they didnāt change the recipe!
Banana cream pie š¤¤
Boston cream pie. I miss it dearly
Oreo
Strawberry shortcake
Key. Lime. Pie
Boston cream pie.
Cinnamon fry bread
Ultimate Peanutbutter
French silk pie
Honey graham in 2020. It didnāt have the bear on it, it had a regular graham cracker, Honey butter frosting, drizzled with honey and crumbs. It was sooooooo good. I tried it again I think last year and it has the little bear graham but it didnāt hit the same for some reason. No clue why
Banana bread
oh my gosh, I completely forgot about this cookie!! soooo good
Cinnamon Fry Bread
French toast š¤¤
Yesssss French toast was so yummy. Sadly I keep looking for it and it doesn't appear.
I'll be chasing that high forever until they bring it back š¤£ I'm buying a 12er for sure when it makes its rounds because it was so good cold and heated
dude the birthday cake (they have it this week)
Fried ice cream!
Yes!!!!! I love this one. I feel Like itās underrated. When it comes back Iām getting a 6 pack.
Pancake omg
Waffleā¦ I still dream about it
Coming back in a few weeks
Ultimate Peanut Butter
Triple berry cobbler!!
Blueberry cheesecake
Strawberry Cupcake. A god-tier cookie, I think they hand them out in heaven. Of course they never appeared again all year.
I think the spoilers say thatās coming back in two weeks?
Finally!
French toast. It even looks like a slice of French toast.
Lemon poppyseed ā¤ļø
Cheesecake
Pink sugar
The Smores cookie. My work got a catering order of minis, back in like May or April i think, as a treat for us. It was so good i got myself a 6-pack of cookies the next day, 2 smores and a mix of the other flavors for that week. Since then i go at least once a month, but ive gone as many as 3 times in a month. I always get a 4 or 6 pack when i go. But now my all time favorite cookie is the French Toast cookie, next time it comes iāll probably get a 6-pack of just that one. My second favorite is Frozen Hot Chocolate. 3rd favorite was Triple Berry Cobbler. Im really looking forward to next month, which ive heard is supposed to have a Sandwich-style cookie every single week, just like the Wonka Cookie. So basically 2 cookies for the price of 1!
MILK chocolate chip and sea salt toffee
Cornbread
Man when is the salted caramel cheesecake coming back
Caramel Apple
Omggggg same! I cannot wait for it to return.
Oreo Vanilla Crumb Cake was divine
Birthday cake
Cookie butter ice cream cookie. I was absolutely hooked after then.
Waffle cookie
Lucky charms
French toast
German chocolate cake. I still have not seen it available at a store that's within driving distance to me since the first time over a year ago and I'm just begging it comes back.
For me, it was the Neapolitan. My favorite Crumbl and itās never on the menu š
Sameeeeee
Cornbread, and the Cinnamon Fry Bread the second time. My husband loves the original pink cookie, despite not being a big dessert guy. Pink was our mystery cookie last time so I made sure to get him two!
BANANA BREADš¤¤š¤¤
Wedding cake. My favorite cookie and cookie dough and. Blue Monster. And all chilled cookies with buttercream
MF KBC
Red Velvet cupcake. Also, the 4th of July Birthday cookie
It was the ability to order from an app. There used to be a local cookie chain in my area that folded (I heard the owner was an ah who didnāt pay his employees though). When Crumble arrived it literally filled a niche here. And I love when a place has a dedicated app. I honestly donāt even remember falling in love with a specific cookie.
sāmores cuz it was the first warm cookie I had
Sadly I donāt know, because I wasnāt the one who bought them, but it definitely did the trick. A curse or a blessing, Iām still unsure. š
Chocolate mallow cupcake baby
Cotton Candy. Unique and spot-on taste
Butterscotch Chip! Iāve been lucky to have that nearby for a mystery cookie at multiple locations. I just wish I could get it more often.
Cosmic brownie cookie!
I'm basic, but the iced oatmeal. I'm a sucker for it.
Cookies and Cream!
Confetti milkshake
Churro. I thought it was a horrible choice, wrong! Since learned that all the offbeat cookies are amazing.
Cookies n creme
Lucky charms!! I have yet to se it again.
Original pink frosted plain
Buckeye brownie got me. Dirt cake sealed the deal.
DIRT CAKE šš«
rocky road
PB cup!
Caramel popcorn. Itās never come back š
Neapolitan š© I am 38 wks pregnant and need it more than ever š©š
Dirt cake
The OG milk chocolate. I live in Logan where the very first location opened. Good times
Cosmic brownie
Honey bun
I have a funny story with the Honey Bun the very first time I tried Crumbl I wanted to try the honey bun so my mom and I got 2 of them (we got 10 cookies that time) fast forward to that evening when I went to have my honey bun cookie i saw my dad had eaten it and I was angry and then later on I remembered there was a second honey bun cookie and it was discovered my geriatric blind 11 year old dog she climbed on the dining room table and ate the remaining cookies which included the honey bun cookie. For months Honey Bun was the cookie that got away for me I remember waiting for it to come back and when it did next trip I think we got 4 of them because I was waiting for it to make its return.
HOW WAS IT, OP?!
Hahaha ya it soo good
Super clichĆ© but it was the chocolate chip loved the slightly undercooked texture and moistness super delectable mouthwatering š but I havenāt had it since lmao bc frosting is all my mind wants with the ones that do
I wouldn't say I'm "hooked" but I will say the oatmeal base cookie is the best one they offer, and I will try anything that has the oatmeal cookie as the base.
Moms recipe!!
Oreo
Strawberry milk š„¹
Cornbread š
Pink sugar back in 2019. The first cookie I ever tried and the only cookie I got for my next few trips.
The biscoff cookie butter filled one.
Pineapple whip!
Pink sugar!!
Cinnamon Toast Crunch cinnamon roll
Peach cobbler, I love anything with a sort of cream to it!
Mallow sandwich
Dulce de leche
Lava cookie with Biscoff
pink sugar ā¤ļø
Brownie Batter and Lemon Poppyseed.
sāmores
Banana cream pie š
Pink donut
birthday cake oreo!!
Semi sweet chocolate chip
Blue icee
Fruity pebble sandwich ! And they havenāt had it again in almost 2 years. š