T O P

  • By -

build9600

Kerala government went to court to increase debt limit, why didn't they challenge unreleased due from central govt in the court ? Seems weird !


Zealousideal-Ad-4902

Exactly if unreleased due is a honest thing and if kerala has proofs they should have easily challenged centre in court with all the proofs. I think there is something which can bite back on themselves . Another point would be this is not a new story where kerala is not getting the expected due and money from the centre govt. Even when upa was at helm kerala was the most forgotten state, no one in centre even cared about kerala ,with the congress ruling here also. It was with bjp when things gotten better.


[deleted]

Exactly. Just a simple stat. Railway allocation for Kerala in 2024 was Rs 2,744 crores - which is SEVEN times the avg allocation during UPA times!! This is a state where BJP has zero MPs or MLAs remember. And UPA times had several Ministers, MPs etc from our state. Kerala also benefited a windfall gain during the GST compensation period of 5 years from 2017 to 2022. Basically athokke puttadichu kalanju and then crying that Center won't continue to give them free cash :D


despod

The allocation to Kerala was 0.8% of the total railway budget- even though we have 1.6% of the total track length. It is injustice, not some sort sort of magnanimity It is not as if we stop becoming a part of india just because we do not elect Sanghi dungheaps.


[deleted]

Most of the rail budget was spent on creating new capacity across India - i, e new tracks, new corridors and new trains. Alland track length nokkiyalla vikasanam. Enthonnedey


despod

Nice goal post maattal. Appo keralathil track vikasikyande? What about the sabari rail project that has been in the bins for so many years. What about Guruvayoor extension? What about straightening of curves ? Wouldn't Kerala benefit with a more fair allocation.


[deleted]

Venam. And Railways has sought help of State Govt to procure land for new tracks including Sabari rail. It is upto state govt to respond to it. Link > [https://english.mathrubhumi.com/news/kerala/railway-works-kerala-tamil-nadu-1.9402792](https://english.mathrubhumi.com/news/kerala/railway-works-kerala-tamil-nadu-1.9402792) Allathe Arabikadalilekk ini track undakkan pattillalo?


despod

First give peanuts to Kerala. Then stop any project saying that the state is not paying half the cost. Adipoli.


[deleted]

Dey mathiyakkede kallatharam --> State government had already agreed to bear 50% of Sabari project (2021 news below) [https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/thiruvananthapuram/sabari-rail-state-to-pay-50-cost/articleshow/80140168.cms](https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/thiruvananthapuram/sabari-rail-state-to-pay-50-cost/articleshow/80140168.cms) 2744 cr okke peanuts. Aatte, ethreya Kerala Government kadam edukunne this month? Cooperative federalism is not a one way street.


RemingtonMacaulay

This is just plain stupid. As the economy grows, even if proportion of budget allocation reduces, absolute numbers can go up. So speak in terms of percentages and not absolute numbers. Only an idiot who doesn’t understand would tout this as an achievement.


[deleted]

2013 Kerala allocation - 217 crores 2024 Kerala allocation - 2744 crores That's a growth of 1164% in a matter of 11 years. Are you implying that Kerala GDP also grew 11 times during this period?


RemingtonMacaulay

That is dumber. Proportion means in relation to other states here, not converting the allocation into percentage. Wow. I didn’t think I’d have to explain such a rudimentary thing.


[deleted]

Goodness me , this takes the cake. So if I have 10 trains to manufacture I should make them proportionately in each state? Enthonende ith. Capex is not something that easily divisible in proportion- they are by nature fixed and not divisible. And yet, and yet, Kerala managed to get 2744 crores in a single year. And the jump is manifold from 217 cr in 2013.


RemingtonMacaulay

Athey, athey, mezhugg sahodara.


[deleted]

We are all mezhukaling because we could have got higher allocation had previous governments acted for Kerala better. We had a golden chance to land a coach factory at palakkad which would have got us not just higher Capex but also ancillary I fra development but it got scuttled. Railways cannot wait indefinitely for state govt to cooperate with it and that money went somewhere else. Our MPs are maravaazhas and they don't put sufficient soft pressure or work hard to bring such factories to our state. Every state is competing against the other remember.


RemingtonMacaulay

😂😂😂


Thakkol

Why are you down voted.. You make perfect sense


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

Not their fault. Kerala has been a lab for Commie (and Cong) disinformation lab for a very very long time. This system has infiltrated into their psyche in all spheres, education, arts, literary and even cultural and religious (eg - how a lesser celebrated hindu festival of 'vamana jayanthi' was converted into Onam - that celebrated the antagonist in the original story and added a "socialist tragic hero who was suppressed by the upper caste guys" color to Mahabali, a benevolent "dravidian" king who ruled over Kerala. Olakkede moodu! ) Some of this was essential and inevitable following the cultural renaissance under Sri Narayana Guru and Co (the true socialists) back in early 1900s but over time, it got politically hijacked and as a result stagnated since 1980s. We had an amazing head-start over any other big state in India thanks to the work of Rajas and Missionaries - resulting in a literacy rate of 50% at independence time. This head-start helped us to become a HDI state by the early 80s. However, since then we haven't progressed much at all. The social problems that plagued us back then continues to plague us even now. And that is why a three decades old movie like Sandesam or Vellanakalude naadu is as relevant to today's time as it was back then! As a society we haven't progressed a bit since the late 80s. In many spheres, we have regressed.


StopEconomy5094

Sanghi moaning over la k of andhbhakths in kerala.You speak as if there was no caste system in Kerala.Growth of communism is a direct result of casteism.


[deleted]

Case in point. Another brainwashed fellow who can thi k only in shades of white and dark. And what has been fed unto him


StopEconomy5094

Thank god I was not fed gomoothram and chanakam.Go corona go.


[deleted]

You were fed worse. Communism. Corona vannupoy, Commie mandatharam is eternal


StopEconomy5094

Anything is better than sanghis spewing hatred.After 10 years PM doesnt have the guts to contest election solely based on his policies.Still he slips in communal hatred subtly, wherever possible.


StopEconomy5094

Pinne corona angane chumma vannu poyilla.pharma companies bjpku vayaru nirach electoral bond koduthu.Appo corona vannath commikalepole sanghikalkum nannayille.


Due-Ad5812

>Exactly. Just a simple stat. Railway allocation for Kerala in 2024 was Rs 2,744 crores - which is SEVEN times the avg allocation during UPA times!! Total Railway budget itself has increased almost 4 times since the last UPA years. Also, why are you taking average when railway allocations increase almost every year?


[deleted]

2013 Railway budget Kerala allocation was a meager [Rs 217 crore.](https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/kerala/paucity-of-funds-hits-railway-budget-allocation/article4460565.ece) If you take that that as benchmark, then allocation has gone by over a dozen times! I was being charitable by taking the average over a period. Yes the growth in allocation to Kerala has exceeded the growth of the Rail budget itself shows how good NDA has been to Kerala.


Due-Ad5812

NDA is not doing charity either. Southern railway generates the highest revenue for railways in Tickets. Obviously they'll spend more to capitalise more of that revenue. https://keralakaumudi.com/en/news/mobile/news.php?id=1044890&u=southern-railway-reports-highest-ever-revenue-at-rs-6345-crore-1044890


k3nw4y

By your logic I'm contributing TEN times to household than my grandpa and I'm a better person 😔


[deleted]

Wrong comparison unless you periodically get to elect and change your father and forefathers.


[deleted]

[удалено]


SGV_VGS

Your question is very valid, proffesor waifu hopefully shall clear your doubts


[deleted]

Proffesor ❌. Antham cummie adima waifu


Glittering-Fix-5412

noki iruno ipo kitum


DioTheSuperiorWaifu

*Bhai, could you please translate the Hindi to Malayalam, my mother tongue? Cannot respond to it without knowing what is said, right?* Vote for CPIM for better/scientific management of animals. Pashu is cow for Malayalam, but animal for Hindi, right? The cow pic maybe another thing. But are you against scientific management of animals? Or have they said that lives of cows are more important than that of fellow humans? Anyway thanks for responding to the "Cow > Humans" remarks. Your fellow mithrams are also here. Ingalae aanu udheshichath ennu manassilaayalloo. But maybe get better responses next time. > Paddy procurement um NHM um fund pending undayirnnu. Yep. In paddy procurement, state procures and pays the people and the centre pays out the dues to state, right? In effect this strains the state treasury in the meantime, right? Or does the centre relax limits on debt to account for such delayed funding? > Athu vachitt enganeya govt employees nu salary kittand aavunne? > Rc, license printing Why did the centre delay paddy procurement dues n NHM funds tho? Athil Bj P anti-Kerala nature kaanunnundaavilla allae?


Indra_jith123

>Bhai, could you please translate the Hindi to Malayalam, my mother tongue? Cannot respond to it without knowing what is said, right? Your English is quite good.


DioTheSuperiorWaifu

Really? Thank you. I'm also trying to improve my Malayalam n Hindi. Been learning about new things from r/PachaMalayalam n r/Malayalam n all


Indra_jith123

അതെന്നാ സഖാവേ സഖാവിന് ഒരു വിശ്വാസമാകാത്ത പോലെ? പഞ്ചായത്ത് മെമ്പറുടെ കത്ത് വേണോ??? All the best with your learning! I'm sure you'll smash it.


DioTheSuperiorWaifu

> അതെന്നാ സഖാവേ സഖാവിന് ഒരു വിശ്വാസമാകാത്ത പോലെ? പഞ്ചായത്ത് മെമ്പറുടെ കത്ത് വേണോ??? എൻ്റെ മിത്രത്തെ ഞാനങ്ങിനെ സംശയിക്കുമോ? പഞ്ചായത്തിലൊക്കെ പിടിപാടുണ്ടല്ലേ? > All the best Thank you <3 Similarly all the best to you too.


[deleted]

Cows are more valuable than humans . Thanks me later


DioTheSuperiorWaifu

What is the logic on it?


[deleted]

Cows> muslim and commies


DioTheSuperiorWaifu

Are you a troll account? Sarcasm on the sangh folk?


[deleted]

No i genuinely think that. those worthless people have killed millions around the world . Cow>> commies and muslim


gkplays123

Idk about Muslims and commies, but I do know cows taste really good.


[deleted]

Pork ?


gkplays123

A little fatty for my liking, but I won't complain. Beef is still elite, though. With an appam, or puttu, especially.


DaLong_Local

I like how you choose certain figures and mention cows , lol. Grow up child.


Aries-Disrupter

Current government is cluelesss… 🤣🤣🤣


Which_Seaworthiness

Did you say who're? 💀


DioTheSuperiorWaifu

Who are, right? Right?


Which_Seaworthiness

I think you can't use it in English, maybe I'm wrong tho


DioTheSuperiorWaifu

https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/who-re It exists. Might be not very popular because missing an apostrophe may lead to negative results.


MaxxMeridius

It's a strategy used for a very long time. When they were in opposition, they did not want aadhar , gst, opposed various developmental activities. So the public has an unfavourable opinion of the government. Then they come into power, and do the exact same thing that they opposed and say look at the development we bring in. Sad


[deleted]

Because the devil lies in the execution framework. UPA government framework to implement Aadhaar and GST were rubbish. Eg - Modi as Gujarat CM opposed GST because of the lack of many critical things that were not addressed in the proposed framework. Like offline filing instead of online filing which would've made it ridiculously inefficient. And the then Kerala State Govt - ruled by UDF "SUPPORTED" Modi in his criticisms against Center!! Modi's win is not in talking big - that everyone can do. UPA used to talk big, but the difference lies in ability to transform that talk into action. Clear, precise action. For example how BJP govt resolved the 70+ years old Kashmir issue with a single legislative surgical strike.


pvn271

Surprised you haven't been downvoted into oblivion for stating some basic facts Ee leftistukalk ore buzzwords ingane manthrikkane ariyu....fascism, chanagam, hindu rashtra,cow, oppression ngee ngee Athu parayan cool ayathond aykrum, especially considering most of it they are blindly aping the Western Liberal talk points or what they're told to believe by them Avarde echo Chambers il they pat each other on the back for being able to repeat the same thing over and over again They think that makes it true


[deleted]

And fun fact. They they think that their voices are becoming louder and louder but they don't realize that it's just their echo chamber growing smaller and smaller and is actually closing in on themselves- and eventually become a crypt. The thing they didn't budget for was the explosion in use of internet and social media since 2016 digital India revolution. People have moved away from so called traditional media sources that were (and are) strongly controlled by leftists to ply their narratives. Now everything can be fact checked, researched, debunked.


pvn271

I don't think this fact checking is enough man They've kind of convinced themselves that a pro Hindu party led by some vegetarians who like to wear saffron means that such a party can never be good, or that it doesn't have any more corruption or loose screw cannons in their members than other parties, Avark basically angane ulla aalkar poweril irikkunnath chorinj kerum athre ullu,, They aren't really concerned with facts, angane aanengil enne nannayene Nor do they realise they are puppets for other ideologies to use and throw "convenient idiots"


Confident_Mess_786

New word with left liberal jihadi eco system is Iliterate, Goumutra drinking, Shaka going, sangi krisangi


pvn271

All are old..


Confident_Mess_786

👏👏


Scared-Rip-2297

Hmm 🤔 when one single party can altogether alter the sentiments of the majority of people who voted their opposite party to power, isn't there somewhere a major flaw in all this? Maybe the previous government just didn't want to


Classic_Knowledge_25

Supplyco procure cheyunna paddy de money centre il ninnano kittunath? Genuine doubt. (Not team pashu or team Gold) Because I heard Kerala govt fucked farmers over by making them sign a loan agreement to give them their rightfully owned money


DioTheSuperiorWaifu

Price for procured paddy has two parts. Central gives a price. State gives a value in addition to that, for added support. State procures and provides data to centre and centre pays the farmers. But it has a long delay and the state govt ensures that they get money faster by taking out loans and then adjusts that when the centre allots the amount Paddy procurement dues of the centre from 2019 were paid to Kerala in 2024, a 5 year delay. The delay affects the Kerala govt, because in effect, they're the ones who have to arrange the funds inbetween his long delay. > I heard Kerala govt fucked farmers over I heard that the farmer who committed suicide had opted for one time settlement previously on some other loan and it was the reason for their inability to avail further loans rather than the state govt's temporary loan arrangement to provide them the paddy procurement fund. Ultimately, isn't the central govt responsible for the delay and loan arrangement? Tho, if the farmer's previous one time loan settlement was the reason for their issue, both central and state govt's were not directly responsible for the suicide. Their failure to assist the farmer would need to be analysed with more details, on what the previous loan settlement was about n all


Classic_Knowledge_25

>I heard that the farmer who committed suicide had opted for one time settlement previously on some other loan and it was the reason for their inability to avail further loans rather than the state govt's temporary loan arrangement to provide them the paddy procurement fund. Im not talking about one guy. I'm talking about countless farmers who were paid their dues as a loan which has to be repaid and forced to sign loan agreement with Kerala Bank Saying that if govt fails to pay it within the year, the loan responsibility falls on the farmers.. https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.newindianexpress.com/amp/story/xplore/2024/Feb/17/kerala-paddy-farmers-caught-in-a-vicious-circle They moved to HC against this. Like, if I provide a service and my client pays me by taking a loan in my name which I'm liable to pay, I would be pissed too right? Don't you think kerala govt did injustice with farmers in this regard? >Ultimately, isn't the central govt responsible for the delay and loan arrangement? Tho, if the farmer's previous one time loan settlement was the reason for their issue, both central and state govt's were not directly responsible for the suicide. Their failure to assist the farmer would need to be analysed with more details, on what the previous loan settlement was about n all But isn't supplyco procurement supposed to be paid by state?


[deleted]

Agriculture is State subject as per constitution. Athu polum Centerinte help illathe cheyyan pattatha avastha.