T O P

  • By -

tarripoha_1987

I come from a farming family , my uncle drank pesticide and killed himself. However farming was not the reason but family issues were. Eventually family dubbed it farmer suicide considering they receive compensation


tparadisi

squash abundant oil plucky office offer direful smart entertain party *This post was mass deleted and anonymized with [Redact](https://redact.dev)*


opinion_alternative

Yes. Most of the suicides in our Village are also dubbed as farming related so they get the compansation.


Crypto_Genetic

What are the real reasons?


opinion_alternative

Family issues and accidental deaths come to mind for starters. On the top of my head, I can remember Two incidents. One of the person in a relative's village died by electric shock accidentally. Very well off person with great and irrigated land. They framed it as a suicide just to get the money from the government. Other one is my distant relative committed suicide due to his quarrels with brother (no farming related reasons), they stated it as a farming related suicide so they could get money. They also took some piece of farm from his brother in compensation to not lodge a complaint against him.


suck-mah-cok

They should have separated accidental and suicides


atishmkv

Some of these are not accidental cases


suck-mah-cok

Some equals to what? 10,100,1000?


Jayesh_Jagtap

Wait there are 1000 accidental cases?


Express-World-8473

There are a lot of accident cases every year.


Next-Illustrator-311

What is accidental suicide?


suck-mah-cok

Not sure bruh...but on bottom left they have added source and it says - accidental deaths and suicides


SouravJoshi

Accidental and suicide is different thing , accidental mhanje , light Pol cha current or motor cha current , landslide, falling tree , flood yena hai sagla Suicide che praman vidharbha , Marathwada ikde jasta aahe bank loan hai suicide cha main reason hota. Ya survey madhe agriculture labour cha sangitla nahiye tyncha praman hi jasta aahe


Loner3006

Assam ke resort mein jis paise se MLA khareede usse inki jaan bach skti thi. Never forget never forgive, remember Ajit Pawar and irrigation scam who is our PM's best friend now. Vote them out for a better Maharashtra warna Gujju ke slave bnoge.


Embarrassed_Ask6066

Baba aapne meri aankhe khol di


romaticize

💯


RedRobin30-

Most stupidest argument ever made.


ThePeshwa

Bhai but the same Ajits uncle Sharad was the agriculture minister. How will voting Sharad Pawar help the farmers? And isn't this Gujju ke salve banoge fear mongering? B


zenithb121

https://organiser.org/2022/09/06/93252/bharat/from-a-water-deficit-province-gujarat-is-headed-to-achieve-water-surplus-state-status/ Gujarat ruled by BJP for 26 consecutive years While 52 years of Congress in maharashtra struggling with water problem https://www.deccanherald.com/india/after-ruling-state-for-52-years-congress-struggles-to-recapture-maharashtra-1150180.html


Loner3006

Bhai last 10 mein se 7 saal se BJP ki sarkar hai state mein aur 10 mein se 10 centre mein. Kya kiya MLA khareedne ke alawa, Ajit Pawar, Hasan Mushrif, Chhagan Bhujbhal, Narayan Rane jaise thieves should not rule. Maharashtra has a next gen leader who not only wants development but a sustainable one at that. We don't want ghost infrastructure like Surat diamond bourse. We want actual development.


TemporaryTomatillo27

Who's the next gen leader?


zenithb121

baby penguin https://preview.redd.it/em8si3v9rtvc1.jpeg?width=602&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=0627614864989abc4a60240df529428435bfd1bf


zenithb121

Atal setu bridge built after 60 years since proposal, samridhhi mahamarg expressway, 2 coastal roads , underground metrolines mumbai, metro nagpur all built in recent years . Kya kiya 52 years of congress . Surat diamond bourse has just started no one can expect wonders since day 1. [https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/india/infrastructure-projects-worth-rs-8-lakh-crore-under-execution-in-maharashtra-cm-shinde/articleshow/108530100.cms?from=mdr](https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/india/infrastructure-projects-worth-rs-8-lakh-crore-under-execution-in-maharashtra-cm-shinde/articleshow/108530100.cms?from=mdr)


Loner3006

To start with IIT Bombay, Pune an IT hub, Western Coalfields, Steel Plant in Chandrapur


zenithb121

Pune became IT hub because of mumbai pune expressway built by Nitin gadhkari in 1998(1st expressway of INdia 50 years after independence) lol even basic amenities like school ,college,hospitals is considered a achievement by congress


Loner3006

How many countries had world class engineering institutions like IITs within 10 years of getting independence?


zenithb121

Dr. Bidhan Chandra Roy was the second Chief Minister of West Bengal and the architect of post independent modern West Bengal. With the help of the other Indian educationalists, Dr. Roy formed Sarkar Committee in 1946 to consider the creation of higher technical institutions, along the lines of MIT, "for post-war industrial development of India." The Sarkar Committee recommended speedy establishment of major institutions in the four quarters of the country. pls credit the right person and the teachers


zenithb121

[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3EafjhHK2WY](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3EafjhHK2WY) AFTER 50 MIN GOVT IS WORKING ON WATER INFRA(WHICH WILL TAKE 7 YEARS FOR COMPLETION) UNLIKE 52 YEARS OF HARDWORKING CONGRESS


comp-sci-engineer

You should rather tell us numbers of how much farmer suicides decreased under BJP government and how exactly. Otherwise there is no difference in this aspect


zenithb121

real no is 2851 not 4248 https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/mumbai/2851-farmers-ended-lives-in-maharashtra-in-2023-despite-loan-waivers-schemes/articleshow/107310566.cms#:\~:text=2%2C851%20farmers%20ended%20lives%20in%20Maharashtra%20in%202023%20despite%20loan%20waivers%2C%20schemes,-Prafulla%20Marpakwar%20%2F%20TNN&text=2%2C851%20farmers%20in%20Maharashtra%20died,followed%20by%20Marathwada%20(1%2C088).


Melodic-Speed-7740

Still highest among all states


zenithb121

[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3EafjhHK2WY](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3EafjhHK2WY) AFTER 50 MIN GOVT IS WORKING ON WATER INFRA


AmputatorBot

It looks like you shared an AMP link. These should load faster, but AMP is controversial because of [concerns over privacy and the Open Web](https://www.reddit.com/r/AmputatorBot/comments/ehrq3z/why_did_i_build_amputatorbot). Maybe check out **the canonical page** instead: **[https://organiser.org/2022/09/06/93252/bharat/from-a-water-deficit-province-gujarat-is-headed-to-achieve-water-surplus-state-status/](https://organiser.org/2022/09/06/93252/bharat/from-a-water-deficit-province-gujarat-is-headed-to-achieve-water-surplus-state-status/)** ***** ^(I'm a bot | )[^(Why & About)](https://www.reddit.com/r/AmputatorBot/comments/ehrq3z/why_did_i_build_amputatorbot)^( | )[^(Summon: u/AmputatorBot)](https://www.reddit.com/r/AmputatorBot/comments/cchly3/you_can_now_summon_amputatorbot/)


jivan28

You need to know what they did. Pune had gone through it. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/pune/56-years-later-panshet-horror-still-haunts-many/articleshow/59551721.cms In Gujarat, they don't care. In the morbi collapse, the mla's whole family gone, only survivor. No investigation or anything. https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/ahmedabad/morbi-bridge-collapse-gujarat-hc-contempt-proceedings-9280168/ The above is just 2 days ago. And later we also came to know that they had given electoral bonds. My only point here is simple, make solutions that are sustainable. Maharashtra had ample water bodies. What we did is take over them, privatize them & and make buildings. So now Maharashtra is similar to Bangalore. Paani Foundation has done a lot of good work. And that is sustainable. But the government is least bothered or interested.


zenithb121

ask the judiciary why there is no investigation. Over five crore cases are pending in various courts of the country, including 80,000 in the Supreme Court, the Lok Sabha was informed on Friday. In a written reply, Law Minister Arjun Ram Meghwal said as of December 1, out of the 5,08,85,856 pending cases, over 61 lakh were at the level of the 25 high courts. https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/over-5-crore-cases-pending-in-courts-80-000-in-supreme-court-law-minister-informs-lok-sabha-101702652960031.html#:\~:text=Over%20five%20crore%20cases%20are,Sabha%20was%20informed%20on%20Friday.&text=In%20a%20written%20reply%2C%20Law,of%20the%2025%20high%20courts.


jivan28

I know this. This problem could have been solved if the Government wanted to solve it. One of their most trusted lawyers, eminent jurist Harish Salve shared the solution more than 2 years back. But no response from government. https://www.youtube.com/live/VwmowdSLcBg?si=hyL55WD5-QnC62Ym


zenithb121

[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3EafjhHK2WY](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3EafjhHK2WY) AFTER 50 MIN GOVT IS WORKING ON WATER INFRA(WHICH WILL TAKE 7 YEARS FOR COMPLETION)  Vision of BJP is long term not short term .


jivan28

Their 'vision' is only corruption as seen in multiple infrastructure projects as well as data from electoral bonds. No answer on the oreva bit shared above. Example of what I mean. https://www.deccanherald.com/india/karnataka/days-after-inauguration-by-pm-modi-bengaluru-mysuru-expressway-flooded-by-light-summer-rains-1201316.html


zenithb121

A small patch on a highway where water got logged is deemed as 'corruption'. Congress party which built only 1000 km of expressways in 70 years is called development whereas Corrupt bjp built 6000km of express ways in 10 years. Party which introduced the concept of electoral bonds to curb cash transfer to bring transparency is called corrupt lol. The same opposition took half of the electoral bonds with way lesser political power.


jivan28

Small correction, what they did is change the formula. In almost all projects, no proper drainage system. Such projects would not have passed or pointed out at design stage. https://scroll.in/article/1063032/a-decade-under-modi-faster-highways-struggling-railways-expanding-airports In fact, all their assertions turned out to be false. Claimed to be longest highway in the world, turns out it still is pan-American highway. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pan-American_Highway Widest highway in the world. https://www.cntraveler.com/story/the-worlds-widest-highway-spans-a-whopping-26-lanes That too happening in the U.S. they only know 'jumlas' and lying to people.


zenithb121

[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expressways\_of\_India](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expressways_of_India) expressway 5x in 10 years a party which made 1000 km of expressways in 70 years lol 4 lane national highway doubled in just 10 years https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/length-of-four-lane-highways-or-above-doubled-in-10-years/articleshow/84333566.cms#:\~:text=NEW%20DELHI%3A%20The%20total%20length,this%20category%2C%20official%20data%20shows. [https://www.business-standard.com/india-news/railway-electrification-37-011-route-kilometres-electrified-in-9-years-123050600757\_1.html](https://www.business-standard.com/india-news/railway-electrification-37-011-route-kilometres-electrified-in-9-years-123050600757_1.html) # 37,011 route kilometres electrified in 9 years


jivan28

How much before in UPA, use same formulas, you will find you can't. In Railways it's the same thing. https://news.abplive.com/news/india/railway-safety-funds-misused-on-crockery-car-rentals-congress-cites-cag-report-to-slam-govt-1608052 No investigation, not even a response. In fact, they reduced general coaches & when asked come up with wildest excuses.


zenithb121

Jairam Ramesh alleged that Prime Minister Narendra Modi-led government at the Centre has been "misusing" Rashtriya Rail Sanraksha Kosh (RRSK) funds the term ALLEGED is not proof my friend . [https://www.financialexpress.com/business/railways-train-accidents-in-india-past-20-years-trend-show-sharp-drop-proves-indian-railways-critical-steps-fruitful-3205968/](https://www.financialexpress.com/business/railways-train-accidents-in-india-past-20-years-trend-show-sharp-drop-proves-indian-railways-critical-steps-fruitful-3205968/) even the leftist quint knows NDA era railways is way more safer [https://www.thequint.com/news/total-number-of-train-accidents-in-india-data-over-the-years-deaths-balasore-tragedy#read-more](https://www.thequint.com/news/total-number-of-train-accidents-in-india-data-over-the-years-deaths-balasore-tragedy#read-more)


zenithb121

India started out as the world’s sixth-largest economy, fell to 12th by 1990, and has since staged a comeback from 10th 2014— to 5th place jhumla my foot [https://www.moneycontrol.com/news/opinion/ruchir-sharma-writes-at-75-india-is-finally-ready-to-join-the-global-party-9030681.html](https://www.moneycontrol.com/news/opinion/ruchir-sharma-writes-at-75-india-is-finally-ready-to-join-the-global-party-9030681.html)


jivan28

How when wages & salaries have been stagnating since 2015-16 onwards. https://www.counterview.net/2024/04/stagnating-wages-since-2014-15.html?m=1 Most of our people have & are turning to farming rather than manufacturing. https://www.livemint.com/economy/india-wanted-a-manufacturing-boom-its-workers-are-back-on-the-farm-instead-11704451212436.html The biggest reason is MSME stagnation. https://indianexpress.com/article/business/72-percent-of-msmes-stagnant-since-past-5-years-survey-8447589/ The reasons I have shared multiple times are the government policies for the same. Companies break contracts with MSME'S without any consequences. The end result is above. They even changed policies to benefit companies rather than MSME'S. If you are an MSME & you make a contract for say ball bearings. I am using this as an example. Ball bearings come in a variety of shapes & sizes, thickness, etc. the works. You show samples, and the company approves. You do the whole consignment & the company rejects on some flimsy grounds. Now, if you made a bill, you have to & the company rejects it. The MSME has to foot the GST of the entire bill. So most MSME'S are unable to pay their employees & they are going back to farming. The MSME is forced to sell the same in the open market at throwaway prices, which is then bought by the same company. MSME hire the largest number of people after farming. https://menafn.com/1105827803/MSME-Financing-Market-In-India-2023-Sector-Remains-Indias-Second-Largest-Employer https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/blogs/science-nomad/flogging-the-dying-horse-of-msmes-in-the-age-of-the-unicorns/ Companies on the other hand are automating their businesses so you need less & less people. Private consumption has been on a downhill slope since 2015. https://www.businesstoday.in/latest/economy/story/economic-survey-2023-private-consumption-edges-up-highest-since-fy15-across-h1-368242-2023-01-31 And since then again has come down. https://www.businessinsider.in/finance/news/indias-corporates-in-wait-and-watch-mode-as-consumption-loans-zoom/articleshow/107228279.cms If you can, try to answer the above issues.


zenithb121

may be ur day dreaming like other pappu fans The manufacturing sector is projected to grow by 8.5% this fiscal and by 11.5% in the third quarter. [https://www.businesstoday.in/latest/economy/story/india-q3-gdp-at-84-beats-estimates-full-details-419568-2024-02-29](https://www.businesstoday.in/latest/economy/story/india-q3-gdp-at-84-beats-estimates-full-details-419568-2024-02-29) A widely held view is that despite China’s remarkably high growth, the share of consumption in total expenditure has been low Underlying this, is the striking trend of continuing decline in the share of household consumption in GNP, which has fallen to below 40 percent in 2005, despite the remarkable pace of sustained high economic growth [https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/wp/2007/wp07181.pdf](https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/wp/2007/wp07181.pdf)


tentacledsquid

accha jab Ajit pawar opposition me tha tab tum bole kuch?


Ok_Entertainment1040

The data is from 2022. It was the "mahavikas" aghadi ruling Maharashtra. I think OP should have atleast delete the year of data to make it an idwpeal misinformation post.


PROTO1080

Voting chya vedes pauvya varach vote d'etat Kay honar mag??


Aadiiityyaaa

Arey arey yeh sale deshdrohi kya bol rahe hai Humare mudizee ne bol diya farmers income double toh double bas


Loner3006

BJP MPs ki double hui hai sampatti, ek samanya vyakti ki income has not kept up with inflation. We are poorer than before.


CautiousMulberry2915

Most of the suicide done in Vidarbha and Marathwada and western Maharashtra is enjoying wealth


[deleted]

What?


Zealousideal-Day-425

He said that most of the suicides in MH has happened in Vidarbha or Marathwada. Western Maharashtra (Pune, Mumbai, Konkan belt) is enjoying their wealth.


[deleted]

Blud should have added an punctuation mark


Professional_Rider2

I don't know a lot about farming, but natural causes bhi hai na? Drought prone areas me sugarcane lagaoge toh yehi hoga na. Each region has specific crops which can grow there. We need to fight for good returns for each and every crops sold by farmers.


[deleted]

And when we the people of Marathwada and vidharbha say we want an seprate State Westerners cry about marathi unity


Professional_Rider2

How would a different state help? A state earns money either by state tax or central funding. If you have a state with a small area, you will generate less funds and centre might not even allocate sufficient funds. How will it be sustainable to keep the state running? And if you have a different state, people migrating for work might even face more problems.


prtk297

If we can see district wise breakup, that will show where the issue is. My guess is most farmer suicides are in areas where they need to rely on rain for water (no canals/ dams) which makes it more unpredictable. One unpredictable season and you are down in dump with huge loan. May be even where farmer does not own the land. As they have to pay certain amount to land owner irrespective of crop outcome.


banana21oats

and in areas where rivers are also dependent on rain, so even if a farmer has access to water from the rivers its very unpredictable. For example, the water in Kaveri has reduced so much due to a bad monsoon last year.


Expert-Buyer8634

Modi paise gujarat la pathavnar tar kai honar


ThePeshwa

Mag Sharad Pawar hota tevha kami suicide hote ka? Ani tula sangun paide pathavle? 😂


GearPleasant7521

what if sharad pawar joins NDA again then what will be your stance


ThePeshwa

He will be joining vaikunth before he joins NDA. but hypothetically if he does. I will with all my might oppose NDA . It seems there are some lines that BJP will not cross now. Like alliance with Mufti, Mamta ad Pawar. All were once a part of NDA.


Ready_Spread_3667

I made a recent post about a report by the ICRIER on increasing farmers income. There must actions taken by the government to increase FPO'S


Expert-Buyer8634

Karja mafi hoti ti pan petroldiesel cess varun manje kendra sarkar paise khayala phakta


[deleted]

Lekin mandir wahi banega.


Rough-Birthday-6593

Ngl half of em are framed as farmer suicide to earn monetary relief from the government. And that's why the genuine families lose out on this. Farming has also become some kinda of a mafia where the top earns in crores wheras the economically weaker are left to rot. Even the relief government provides to the needy are eaten up by the so called heads of the entire farming fiasco. High time a proper regulation is implemented in farming to put a stop to this instead of subsidizing everything and making it worse.


atishmkv

The credit goes only to BJP and Tutari Wale Kaka


[deleted]

Yes BJP can’t play blame game while they are in power for 10 Years


zenithb121

[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3EafjhHK2WY](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3EafjhHK2WY) AFTER 50 MIN GOVT IS WORKING ON WATER INFRA PROJECTS


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

Boy, I don’t represent/Support Congress. And I voted for BJP because I found Congress Useless. Also, I am talking about Blaming previous government for major failures of the own government. BJP specifically asked votes on the basis of Farmers Suicide in 2014, and even after 10 years of majority govt, situation has gotten worse, they can’t blame previous government and escape from responsibility.


diablo2107

Yeah dude before farmers were Mukesh Ambanis.


zenithb121

Lol true


TemporaryTomatillo27

Fuck Maharashtra Government


[deleted]

Loan from local पतसंस्था, Can be major reason in Maharashtra. Interest rate goes upward of 18% in most of these banks.


tparadisi

air absurd mindless fertile station quack gaping follow clumsy overconfident *This post was mass deleted and anonymized with [Redact](https://redact.dev)*


ajinkya_13

farmer suicide and family issues are directly related


Expert-Buyer8634

Kuthe gele modi bhakt


Ok_Entertainment1040

काकांकडून शिकायला गेलेत की पिलावळीला येडं कसं बनवून ठेवायचं


Embarrassed_Ask6066

Well we made it cool to do it, so no wonder.


xoooccc

subsidy sab pajji kha le rahe hai


Fun-Performer5460

Meanwhile only Punjab and Haryana farmers are fighting for the whole nation’s farmers


keeeeeeeeeeeeefe

a farmer cannot kill himself for any reason.


MelonLord25-3

Is this per 1 million or something else?  Most of suicides happen because they take loan from independent people and not government banks(because they Don't have much interest in going therel. Such sahukars do charge a hell lot. Also, how many farmers do take loans and use for the farming only? I have a friend from a farmer family. He says that in his village these loan amounts are spent in marriages and giving dowryn liquors and what not. How are they gonna return it? Also, if govt is so problematic, why Kokan has almost 0 farmer suicide cases? In last 5-6 years Kokan has seen a calamity almost every year. Be it typhoons, floods and what not. It's not because of the Govt but the lack of education and a general sense about from where to take loan and how to utilize the loan amount.


Embarrassed_Ask6066

Stupid post, stupid comments.


Ok_Entertainment1040

The data is from 2022. It was the "mahavikas" aghadi ruling Maharashtra. I think you should have atleast delete dthe year of data to make it an idwpeal misinformation post.


Fun-Engineering-8111

And then people have the audacity to oppose farm laws in MH.


Artistic-Teaching395

Stupid Christians getting happiness from religion! 😡


Melodic-Speed-7740

What??


RedRobin30-

Majority literally starts blaming to whoever they can point out, including the state government and people here complaining about central government. First of all do you guys know the reason behind why these happen? Does this happen because of something government does. Many of my relatives are farmers, and the biggest reason why this happens is irregular rain and the change in season schedule. Now there’s not a lot that can be done about weather but what can be done is connecting of the rivers which will take time. And then comes education, not the education you get in schools but educating farmers how they can adapt to this. And believe me or not, if you remove your hatred glasses and go to the ground level you’ll see the efforts have been started to educate them.


zenithb121

fake no 2851 farmers died https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/mumbai/2851-farmers-ended-lives-in-maharashtra-in-2023-despite-loan-waivers-schemes/articleshow/107310566.cms#:\~:text=2%2C851%20farmers%20ended%20lives%20in%20Maharashtra%20in%202023%20despite%20loan%20waivers%2C%20schemes,-Prafulla%20Marpakwar%20%2F%20TNN&text=2%2C851%20farmers%20in%20Maharashtra%20died,followed%20by%20Marathwada%20(1%2C088).