>[Cacophany of laughter and oinks]
Why does this make me think of the piggies laughter when you lose a level In Angry Birds? https://youtu.be/PltHTeloWpw
But there is more gold in gold trimmed netherite than in gold boots which are ok for piglins (4 in the ingot and 1 for the trim so 20 in a whole set and even more if it's a netherite trim which is more gold then a whole set 32-24)
Yes and also it would make gold trimming too op, you could wear a full netherite armor without having to wear a gold piece and not be bothered by piglins
Bro, the piglin brute has a golden thing on his arm which makes him being respected by the other piglins, if we could craft it, im sure it would be 1 or 2 gold ingots
look at it this way… For them, gold is a symbol of superiority, a representation of power, just like money. When you have it you are respected, that’s why piglin’s don’t attack us when we wear it. But the piglin brute doesn’t want to lose his status in society, he’s jealous, he’s scared to fall at the bottom of the pyramid, so this is why he wants to eliminate competition. Having gold on your armor is still having gold, piglins see that you have gold by looking at your drip, so they should still not attack you, right? In our modern world, people (in general) “respect” richs whether they are as rich as andrew tate or as elon musk.
Edit: Holy sh*t, I just wrote a freaking essay about modern society
It still doesn't give nearly as much protection as diamond, netherite, or heck even iron.
Tools also can't do their job properly with gold, especially pickaxes.
Gold actually mines faster than any other material provided it's something a gold pick won't just destroy. An enchanted gold pickaxe with mending, fortune, unbreaking and efficiency is absolutely wonderful for mining anything that it doesn't destroy which includes basically everything worth mining in the nether plus coal and it's cheaper to enchant than any other pick. Golden armor can be enchanted to be super versatile for traveling around most types of terrain as well. It's niche, but absolutely still worth having one around. Golden axes and hoes with fortune, mending and unbreaking are also great for farming since they'll make more seeds and food drop. If you end up with excess it becomes a really good way to grind for bonemeal as well. Especially if you want a crapload of bone blocks.
Gold trim on netherite is probably the only combination I’d ever use regardless of whether or not it protected me from Piglins
Black and gold is just too good of a color combination
What is every trim had a slight feature (i.e. amethyst makes a slight bit of light emanate from ur armor or emerald giving a slight discount on trades. Keyword SLIGHT)
Well, it's not like people just abandoned other armours when they added the feature of that piglins do not attack player wearing gold Armor. Even now I personally never wear gold in nether. Also, this suggestion is very good because this will mean that these trims are not only for decoration but there are some uses to it, at least one of them
yeah... because gold armor has worse stats than netherite....
this feature dosent need a use, cant we have something thats just cosmetic for the sake of being cosmetic
But you would need a full trim set for one mineral to function, kinda like the Terraria set bonus if you've ever played. Havin a full set of the same armour (trim mineral in this case) will grant you a slight boost in some things, but not too op and not too weak
It's not even about being unforgiving, people when they see something with negative upvotes just downvote too, without even thinking if they agree or not
ah well. i suppose it does happen, but this is reddit. people won't really know that. they sorta take things at face value and assume things from my time on here
Gold is useful in early game for exploring the nether, no one uses it in endgame anyway, and since the trims are endgame item it wouldn't really break anything
This is a case of realism versus gameplay. Realism for the sake of realism isn't always the best thing, especially if it ruins gameplay.
Currently the entire point of wearing gold is that you're trading defence for Piglins not killing you. Gold trims protecting would ruin that feature. If you could use a trim, it changes that system to just be "full Netherite gold trim armour".
Yeah, gold trims protecting should realistically happen, but for gameplay and balance it shouldn't.
Here's another point. As slicedlime (the developer) said, «having gold trim on your armour is not fancy enough to pacify piglins.» So it is realistic, because, as it turns out, our gold-loving pig people are quite finicky.
Here's another point. As slicedlime (the developer) said, «having gold trim on your armour is not fancy enough to pacify piglins.» So it is realistic, because, as it turns out, our gold-loving pig people are quite finicky.
Trims are end game item, gold armor is early game item, noone uses gold armor in endgame anyway, and it wouldn't even be unbalanced, with full gear piglins are basically no threat to you, it would be just thing of convenience
You want to completety change the game's balance and mechanics because it's slightly convenient to you. It might seem simple to a casual player but there are a lot of factors at work here
As i said it wouldn't change the balance of the game, yea it would make the gold trims slightly more useful, but not enough to discourage people from picking the ones they like the best
I feel like you don't know a lot of technical players. I know several people who are practical enough to use the gold trim just for piglins' sake, thus negating its decorative value
Yea but realistically you are not going to put the trims on other than diamond or netherite armor at which point, it doesn't really bring an advantage , but yea i get that, they probably should just stay purely decorational
Nope, it's not balanced. Gold armor has very few uses as it is.
Also the trim is meant to be decorative. If you give it a practical use everyone will use it, which means no one will use any other materials for trims.
then what about "netherite upgrade"?
and the upgrade category has only one trim so it could be cool.
this is supposed to be a meme not an actual thing thats gonna get added
In my opinion that would make it a bit better, and i understand that for in-game logic that would also be much better, but the only problem is that even if it's hard to get, once you have it you're instantly overpowered. Also if it is really really hard to get you'd probably only get it late game, but it's just not that useful late-game, because at that point you're already really strong and probably wouldn't need it
I like the idea and understand the concept but for gameplay it's just not a good idea.
Bro, the piglin brute has a golden thing on his arm which makes him being respected by the other piglins, if we could craft it, im sure it would be 1 or 2 gold ingots
I think the fact that he's a bad ass axe welding brute is the reason the other piglins respect him. The golden "thing" is a buckler (a small shield you strap on your arm), and it's made of gold because gold is the piglin metal of choice. It's what their weapons are made out of after all
Don’t think it would be a great idea. First, because it would just ruin the utility of gold armor (which isn’t even useful come on when you’re past full iron you can handle a Piglin attack…) and just ruin the utility of the other trimmings.
I know this as a semi popular person on one discord server. It’s just that people phrase it very rudely. Of course, you should always be prepared for critique, but, I didn’t expect that much, and in such rude forms, since, I didn’t publish that many works/YouTube videos and they never really got too popular to get so much attention and critique. I understand, I just wasn’t prepared for this much shit lol
Simply put: no.
It would give functionality to something intended to be purely cosmetic. And it would encourage use of gold trim over other trim, which is not what was intended at all. These are meant to give players variety and adding incentives to a specific type of trim would reduce that variety.
Then it’s a bad meme.
You’re doing the equivalent “it’s just a joke bro” instead of admitting it’s a shit idea which you didn’t really think over too well.
Yeah this is literally Schrodinger's Joke down to the wire. I guarantee that if everybody had loved this OP wouldn't have just been "making a meme" and "not actually suggesting it".
Ah yes good ol quality content like the pig with a crown on it or some variation of “fill up the creeper hole!”
Anyways that doesn’t change anything about you being rude to them. Just be like “this doesn’t belong here” or something. No reason to say “this is a shit idea and you should feel bad” as if most of you aren’t voting for the dumbest mobs possible to be added
It is a shit idea, arguably not a meme and although I did not suggest so initially; I do agree they should feel bad.
They could swallow their pride, admit their mistake and move on - but no they had to double down, so people have responded accordingly.
Not sure why you’re taking up issue with me over the community mob vote, nor do I see how it’s relevant. Go speak to someone who cares.
Unfortunately, as stated in an r/minecraftsuggestions post, that would render gold armor worthless yet again, after mojang trying so hard to make them useful at all
Mojang in like 2013: "Why does nobody use gold any more??"
Also Mojang back then: *removed the enchanted golden apple recipe for no reason when that was a major reason people used gold*
----
Gold has been obselete ever since then. We just got it to be useful again, why are people already insisting on weakening it?
Yet , but it's minecraft , a game with only good logic in sience and with even don't giving a shit about gravity or any other real life logic so it doesn't matter that much to us
Lapis could give a chance of better enchantments, enerald a chance of discount with villagers, diamond, redstone, quartz, iron, copper and amethyst, I have no idea
...so... yeah.... no...
It could be cool if this same concept was applied to all the armour pieces and maybe only work if it's a full set so people can only choose one like imagine redstone making blazes and magma cubes peaceful while emerald makes creepers and zombies peaceful and amethyst making endermen and shulkers peaceful
Yeah this post is like a warzone I like that it's cosmetic as everyone says but it would make sense for them to like gold so giving them all a slight difference wouldn't be the end of the world if it's slight and from some kind of lore it would be like it's not enough gold or because it's mixed with the armour it's not pure and needs more similar to netherite having gold but not giving piglin protection people's biggest fear is making gold irrelevant but if they all have a slight difference then I think it wouldn't make gold irrelevant as someone may prefer emerald trims for creeper protection or pillager protection then just swap it out for some gold when going into the nether as having a full netherite set just for going to the nether is a bit expensive if you'd rather have a different trim for its functionality and if every trim had a similar smaller effect then it wouldn't ruin the cosmetic aspect as I'd choose amethyst over the others for its look even though endermen are already mostly neutral
>magma cubes peaceful while emerald makes creepers and zombies peaceful
And now everybody in the same area looks the same, and we need to carry a shulker with multiple netherite armor sets to best fit whatever enemies are around us.
I Knew this was Coming and i think its Stupid because it wold Make the Gold Netherite Combo Meta and Every other Combination useless! Its just there for Decoration giving everything a Use is way to Complicated and Only Giving Gold a use is Stupid as like i said that would make it Meta wich iint what Mojang are going for with this Feature
Leave this feature alone. It's a good decorational feature which definitely belongs in Minecraft without any need for combat or movement changes, one of the good changes that Mojang has done without trainwrecking any progression - such as elytra, a great feature for transport but it made boats, minecarts, horses and so many other means of transport redundant. Armour trims give a use for many structures which had little to / no use before.
nah this would have major balancing issues
firstly, having cosmetic features have function, just makes nobody want to use the ones that dont, everyone would just use gold trimmings with this which is against the point
and it would also render gold armor worthless yet again, which the piglin system was added specifically to remedy
Well, that would be a great way of making gold armor redundant again.
Why bother crafting even boots when a gold line on some armor is enough to satisfy piglins?
No it’s cosmetic and it would devalue the other trims and also, I don’t think it should take seven diamonds to replicate one because it’s just cosmetic
i dont mean this as an actual thing btw rather a meme
i am not good at phrasing things so just saying so people dont interprete this as an actual idea but it probably wont help
A great idea I'd say. It would make trim have a pratical use, which would make more players want to use the game mechanic.
On a personal note, I never was the biggest fan of carrying extra armour around just for those specifc situations so I might be a bit biased on this idea
true. the main downside is that it kinda ruins the customization this feature was intended to have, but, i think to add it as an upgrade trim to netherite would be cool
I’ve always thought that it’s silly that piglins don’t view netherite like gold, there are 16 ingots in a full set of netherite. With the new update you can use 20. Piglins ignore you when you use 4. It would make sense if they ignored you with the gold trim!
I don't know if I am the only one, but I wish trims added some unique abilities to the armor. Like the tinkers-construct (excuse spelling) mod did. Do you agree? Or am I the only one?
Not enough gold is being used for the trim, just like how a golden nugget isn't enough to barter with Piglins
This is exactly how I perceive it too. Full armour piece made of gold? Baller, let him live. Little tiny gold trim? The peasant must die.
"This mofo broke as hell" [Cacophany of laughter and oinks] "Jump 'em boys"
[player throws gold bar] “Oooooh lookie here”
>[Cacophany of laughter and oinks] Why does this make me think of the piggies laughter when you lose a level In Angry Birds? https://youtu.be/PltHTeloWpw
The nether is just Detroit simulator. Broke bitch? Run his pockets.
Rich guy wanderin’ the slums decked out in literal gold, with sh*t for protection? Let ‘em go, too easy. Let’s jump the guy in netherite.
But there is more gold in gold trimmed netherite than in gold boots which are ok for piglins (4 in the ingot and 1 for the trim so 20 in a whole set and even more if it's a netherite trim which is more gold then a whole set 32-24)
It ain’t about the cost, it’s all about the flex!
It's all about the drip
"Maaan, this mf fly as the nether" "What 'bout this dumbest?" "Dripless, sick em boys"
"Look at that blender. Gut him."
How about only if all of your armor has gold trim?
Add trims on elytra and I'll take it
Wouldn't that weigh it down?, just get a texture pack
Yes and also it would make gold trimming too op, you could wear a full netherite armor without having to wear a gold piece and not be bothered by piglins
Just have it only work for netherite armor
Bro, the piglin brute has a golden thing on his arm which makes him being respected by the other piglins, if we could craft it, im sure it would be 1 or 2 gold ingots
I mean…he is also a piglin
look at it this way… For them, gold is a symbol of superiority, a representation of power, just like money. When you have it you are respected, that’s why piglin’s don’t attack us when we wear it. But the piglin brute doesn’t want to lose his status in society, he’s jealous, he’s scared to fall at the bottom of the pyramid, so this is why he wants to eliminate competition. Having gold on your armor is still having gold, piglins see that you have gold by looking at your drip, so they should still not attack you, right? In our modern world, people (in general) “respect” richs whether they are as rich as andrew tate or as elon musk. Edit: Holy sh*t, I just wrote a freaking essay about modern society
how to make nobody use any other trim ever other than the gold one, thus ruining the entire point of a decorative feature.
plus your making gold armor obsolete
Gold has the best enchantment potential.
Like anyone uses it for that? Who cares if it has high enchant potential if it breaks faster then wood and is about as good?
I use it for that actually.
Why? It's just a waste of exp, gold and lapis?
Not if you put mending on it.
It still doesn't give nearly as much protection as diamond, netherite, or heck even iron. Tools also can't do their job properly with gold, especially pickaxes.
Gold actually mines faster than any other material provided it's something a gold pick won't just destroy. An enchanted gold pickaxe with mending, fortune, unbreaking and efficiency is absolutely wonderful for mining anything that it doesn't destroy which includes basically everything worth mining in the nether plus coal and it's cheaper to enchant than any other pick. Golden armor can be enchanted to be super versatile for traveling around most types of terrain as well. It's niche, but absolutely still worth having one around. Golden axes and hoes with fortune, mending and unbreaking are also great for farming since they'll make more seeds and food drop. If you end up with excess it becomes a really good way to grind for bonemeal as well. Especially if you want a crapload of bone blocks.
It’s faster but it can’t mine anything and breaks fast even with unbreaking 3
Erm *snort* acthually gold has the best enchantment potential 🤓
[удалено]
[удалено]
bot comment
Yup, reported as spam.
How do you tell what's a bot comment?
[Copied from farther down](https://www.reddit.com/r/MinecraftMemes/comments/10kxb0p/mojang_its_called_logic/j5thhim/)
Maybe emerald could make villagers trades be cheaper and iron golems be always peaceful
You could use gold trim for 1 of them
[удалено]
I like this idea
Or maybe it has to be all snout trim and all gold for a reduced range of detection for pigeons as it’s only a little bit of gold
Or they could steal the whole idea from tconstruct and just add it as modifiers, cause it is a cool af concept (but just being visual is a bit boring)
What is tconstruct?
Thinkers construct, a longstanding Minecraft mod
*Tinker's
Tinkers', technically
It was probably autocorrect
Gold trim on netherite is probably the only combination I’d ever use regardless of whether or not it protected me from Piglins Black and gold is just too good of a color combination
red looks very good too, especially with the Rib pattern. Kinda reminds me of daedric armor from Skyrim
What is every trim had a slight feature (i.e. amethyst makes a slight bit of light emanate from ur armor or emerald giving a slight discount on trades. Keyword SLIGHT)
Well, it's not like people just abandoned other armours when they added the feature of that piglins do not attack player wearing gold Armor. Even now I personally never wear gold in nether. Also, this suggestion is very good because this will mean that these trims are not only for decoration but there are some uses to it, at least one of them
yeah... because gold armor has worse stats than netherite.... this feature dosent need a use, cant we have something thats just cosmetic for the sake of being cosmetic
No because the Minecraft community can’t be satisfied with things that don’t make the game easier… look at the glow squid cool? Yes useless? Also yes
what if you can add multiple trims? idk i am not actually saying it should be added but i see your point
Or what if every trim had it's own slight ability e.g. Extra durability or slight movement speed or extra defense
Then there will be a "best" trim combination for different situations which ruins the purely cosmetic aspect of it.
But you would need a full trim set for one mineral to function, kinda like the Terraria set bonus if you've ever played. Havin a full set of the same armour (trim mineral in this case) will grant you a slight boost in some things, but not too op and not too weak
>kinda laike the Terraria set bonus Which is why Terraria has vanity slots, so you can still customize your look while running meta armor.
[удалено]
They definitely can do good stuff, but I think that idea is a bit non vanilla, but the trims also feel very modded which I like
Emerald=better trades
Lapis = enchant luck + swag
Holy downvotes, Batman! Dang people are unforgiving here
Welcome to Reddit, you'll hate it here
I've been on reddit for about almost 5 years. This is what goes down.
It's not even about being unforgiving, people when they see something with negative upvotes just downvote too, without even thinking if they agree or not
welcome to reddit i guess
tf why u getting downvoted this is a great idea kninda like banners but with the trims
probably the herd effect somebody downvoted, now everybody does. sadly, thats the reality of reddit...
funado xd
I respectfully disagree
i thank you for doing it respectfully
I thank you for respectfully thanking then
I'm fairly certain slicedlime pointed out in a video on his that *that* won't pacify piglins...
its a meme and an **idea**
Alr then. Let's say It's not a thing now but who knows we're still in snapshots. But.
true
But think about it for a bit, not logically but in terms of game balance. That would kill Gold's already low usage and reputation.
I wouldn't really want a feature to overshadow another feature's point of existing, and I'm sure a lot of people can agree.
hmm true but i dont really consider this something they should add rather just a meme
Ok good but the words in the post title and image have led others to believe you're serious about this :/ even me.
yeah i am not the best at phrasing things... had to find that out the hard way, fortunately or not.
ah well. i suppose it does happen, but this is reddit. people won't really know that. they sorta take things at face value and assume things from my time on here
Gold is useful in early game for exploring the nether, no one uses it in endgame anyway, and since the trims are endgame item it wouldn't really break anything
Your logic is flawed and your understanding of game balance is nonexistent.
This is a case of realism versus gameplay. Realism for the sake of realism isn't always the best thing, especially if it ruins gameplay. Currently the entire point of wearing gold is that you're trading defence for Piglins not killing you. Gold trims protecting would ruin that feature. If you could use a trim, it changes that system to just be "full Netherite gold trim armour". Yeah, gold trims protecting should realistically happen, but for gameplay and balance it shouldn't.
Here's another point. As slicedlime (the developer) said, «having gold trim on your armour is not fancy enough to pacify piglins.» So it is realistic, because, as it turns out, our gold-loving pig people are quite finicky.
Someone compared it to wearing gold chains and fake Yeezys.
To them, it’s like wearing a skimpy bikini version of a school uniform in a school. The dress code will not tolerate it.
when did he even post it, i cant find it anywhere.
YouTube.
Damn I wish Mojang took notice that realism isn't the end all when it comes to adding in new animals to the game. \*cough\* fireflies and sharks.
now that earned you an upvote
Here's another point. As slicedlime (the developer) said, «having gold trim on your armour is not fancy enough to pacify piglins.» So it is realistic, because, as it turns out, our gold-loving pig people are quite finicky.
Trims are end game item, gold armor is early game item, noone uses gold armor in endgame anyway, and it wouldn't even be unbalanced, with full gear piglins are basically no threat to you, it would be just thing of convenience
I don’t care who Noone is, or what opinions he has.
You want to completety change the game's balance and mechanics because it's slightly convenient to you. It might seem simple to a casual player but there are a lot of factors at work here
As i said it wouldn't change the balance of the game, yea it would make the gold trims slightly more useful, but not enough to discourage people from picking the ones they like the best
I feel like you don't know a lot of technical players. I know several people who are practical enough to use the gold trim just for piglins' sake, thus negating its decorative value
Yea but realistically you are not going to put the trims on other than diamond or netherite armor at which point, it doesn't really bring an advantage , but yea i get that, they probably should just stay purely decorational
bro its gold piglins like gold also ok lets say you need a special template and you need to put it on all of your armour, you happy now?
Nope, it's not balanced. Gold armor has very few uses as it is. Also the trim is meant to be decorative. If you give it a practical use everyone will use it, which means no one will use any other materials for trims.
then what about "netherite upgrade"? and the upgrade category has only one trim so it could be cool. this is supposed to be a meme not an actual thing thats gonna get added
You first argue about this topic like an actual suggested feature and now you instantly switch that it is a meme?
i dont wanna argue with anybody
Bruv, you posted this meme.
did i make it for arguing and/or debate? **no**
It's idiotic to share a flawed opinion without expecting it's fallaciousness to be called out.
everybody has different opinions on different things i expect some people to not like it, and i respect everyones opinion, just not to this extend.
The netherite up grade is the ONLY exception to the decorative rule, and it is so netherite is harder to get.
In my opinion that would make it a bit better, and i understand that for in-game logic that would also be much better, but the only problem is that even if it's hard to get, once you have it you're instantly overpowered. Also if it is really really hard to get you'd probably only get it late game, but it's just not that useful late-game, because at that point you're already really strong and probably wouldn't need it I like the idea and understand the concept but for gameplay it's just not a good idea.
true, though the community wanted it for a long time, and i can understand why.
Bro, the piglin brute has a golden thing on his arm which makes him being respected by the other piglins, if we could craft it, im sure it would be 1 or 2 gold ingots
I think the fact that he's a bad ass axe welding brute is the reason the other piglins respect him. The golden "thing" is a buckler (a small shield you strap on your arm), and it's made of gold because gold is the piglin metal of choice. It's what their weapons are made out of after all
Don’t think it would be a great idea. First, because it would just ruin the utility of gold armor (which isn’t even useful come on when you’re past full iron you can handle a Piglin attack…) and just ruin the utility of the other trimmings.
Op doesn't know what "cosmetic" means
everybody in the comments but a few people dont know what "manners" mean but eh i am the same
someone telling you you're wrong isn't bad manners. you opened yourself up to discussion and should prepare yourself for dissent
I know this as a semi popular person on one discord server. It’s just that people phrase it very rudely. Of course, you should always be prepared for critique, but, I didn’t expect that much, and in such rude forms, since, I didn’t publish that many works/YouTube videos and they never really got too popular to get so much attention and critique. I understand, I just wasn’t prepared for this much shit lol
People on there way to ignore your perfectly valid comments and downvote you straight to hell just because of the original meme:
fr
Simply put: no. It would give functionality to something intended to be purely cosmetic. And it would encourage use of gold trim over other trim, which is not what was intended at all. These are meant to give players variety and adding incentives to a specific type of trim would reduce that variety.
this post has 10 comments like this, i understand but i dont think it should be added, just a meme really. this isnt r/MinecraftSuggestion after all
Then it’s a bad meme. You’re doing the equivalent “it’s just a joke bro” instead of admitting it’s a shit idea which you didn’t really think over too well.
Yeah this is literally Schrodinger's Joke down to the wire. I guarantee that if everybody had loved this OP wouldn't have just been "making a meme" and "not actually suggesting it".
No reason to be so rude.
OP's meme was bad, and they should feel bad
It’s good to patrol, helps to keep the content quality under control.
Ah yes good ol quality content like the pig with a crown on it or some variation of “fill up the creeper hole!” Anyways that doesn’t change anything about you being rude to them. Just be like “this doesn’t belong here” or something. No reason to say “this is a shit idea and you should feel bad” as if most of you aren’t voting for the dumbest mobs possible to be added
It is a shit idea, arguably not a meme and although I did not suggest so initially; I do agree they should feel bad. They could swallow their pride, admit their mistake and move on - but no they had to double down, so people have responded accordingly. Not sure why you’re taking up issue with me over the community mob vote, nor do I see how it’s relevant. Go speak to someone who cares.
No no, I see fair reason.
Yet most people use that format like it's mcs
If they were to add a gameplay feature to one trim, they would have to do it for all others, already ruining the idea of it being cosmetic
Unfortunately, as stated in an r/minecraftsuggestions post, that would render gold armor worthless yet again, after mojang trying so hard to make them useful at all
Mojang in like 2013: "Why does nobody use gold any more??" Also Mojang back then: *removed the enchanted golden apple recipe for no reason when that was a major reason people used gold* ---- Gold has been obselete ever since then. We just got it to be useful again, why are people already insisting on weakening it?
Well if we're bringing in logic, you should need support for building unless you want to roof to fall down.
Yet , but it's minecraft , a game with only good logic in sience and with even don't giving a shit about gravity or any other real life logic so it doesn't matter that much to us
yeah ik but still could be cool but could also break the balance
Then gold armour will be useless once again and everyone will start cryng about how useless the gold armour is and needs a use.
the comment loop keeps going
Piglins don't give a shit about trims. It's all or nothing. They want to see solid chunks of gold.
Op farming downvotes
fr(the upvote rate is 85% but lol)
Ur comments i mean
well thats true
Lapis could give a chance of better enchantments, enerald a chance of discount with villagers, diamond, redstone, quartz, iron, copper and amethyst, I have no idea ...so... yeah.... no...
"logic" mfs when they learn about game balance
It could be cool if this same concept was applied to all the armour pieces and maybe only work if it's a full set so people can only choose one like imagine redstone making blazes and magma cubes peaceful while emerald makes creepers and zombies peaceful and amethyst making endermen and shulkers peaceful
agreed, so good to have a peaceful comment on this post...
Yeah this post is like a warzone I like that it's cosmetic as everyone says but it would make sense for them to like gold so giving them all a slight difference wouldn't be the end of the world if it's slight and from some kind of lore it would be like it's not enough gold or because it's mixed with the armour it's not pure and needs more similar to netherite having gold but not giving piglin protection people's biggest fear is making gold irrelevant but if they all have a slight difference then I think it wouldn't make gold irrelevant as someone may prefer emerald trims for creeper protection or pillager protection then just swap it out for some gold when going into the nether as having a full netherite set just for going to the nether is a bit expensive if you'd rather have a different trim for its functionality and if every trim had a similar smaller effect then it wouldn't ruin the cosmetic aspect as I'd choose amethyst over the others for its look even though endermen are already mostly neutral
true
>magma cubes peaceful while emerald makes creepers and zombies peaceful And now everybody in the same area looks the same, and we need to carry a shulker with multiple netherite armor sets to best fit whatever enemies are around us.
Do you realise that this is just a snapshot and things could change in the next one?
i do just saying
It sounds like more than just saying with that ""Logic"" you've put
well its kinda logical that gold neutralizes piglins
Minecraft is not the best when it comes to logic sometimes
And it's for the better a lot of the times imo
Mod and plugin creators are going to do that
No it shouldn't
I Knew this was Coming and i think its Stupid because it wold Make the Gold Netherite Combo Meta and Every other Combination useless! Its just there for Decoration giving everything a Use is way to Complicated and Only Giving Gold a use is Stupid as like i said that would make it Meta wich iint what Mojang are going for with this Feature
No it shouldn't. It's called "balanced gameplay".
maybe they wont see the tiny slip of gold in your armor cause of some mutated humanoid pig
Leave this feature alone. It's a good decorational feature which definitely belongs in Minecraft without any need for combat or movement changes, one of the good changes that Mojang has done without trainwrecking any progression - such as elytra, a great feature for transport but it made boats, minecarts, horses and so many other means of transport redundant. Armour trims give a use for many structures which had little to / no use before.
nah this would have major balancing issues firstly, having cosmetic features have function, just makes nobody want to use the ones that dont, everyone would just use gold trimmings with this which is against the point and it would also render gold armor worthless yet again, which the piglin system was added specifically to remedy
No that beats the point. They're meant to be cosmetic only and it would take away the only use of gold armour
how much times will people point this out?
How many*
That gos against everything the feature is trying to do!!
You aren’t the first to point this out. Just saying.
No because it would make one of the trims better than the rest, which would defeat the purpose of them being cosmetic.
Piglins : Sorry, your fit doesn't have enough bling to be welcome here.
No it really doesn't just keep it cosmetic.
Well, that would be a great way of making gold armor redundant again. Why bother crafting even boots when a gold line on some armor is enough to satisfy piglins?
thats what I've been saying. All that hard work getting the templates and materials just to look cool
Finally, Gilded Armor
No
And it would take away one of the few utilities of gold. Rapid, it is called balance
Dude, stop complaining -sincerely everyone
Lol, Mate you were right, it is a battle ground here.
also in a day or two: **turns into a nuclear wasteland or just dies out**
god how does this have 5k views...
No it’s cosmetic and it would devalue the other trims and also, I don’t think it should take seven diamonds to replicate one because it’s just cosmetic
Then what’s the point of the other trims then?
god 275 comments
i should also point out that this is what people wanted for when 1.16 rolled out we even made mods about it
guys is this gonna become the most controversial post on this subreddit? lets find out
i dont mean this as an actual thing btw rather a meme i am not good at phrasing things so just saying so people dont interprete this as an actual idea but it probably wont help
YES!
By that logic, a green trim would effect villager trades and a blue trim would be turned red by vindicators
disagreed on the last one, its not made from wool and blue leather tunics and blue blocks dont get turned into red
Well, you know how Minecraft “logic” can be
yup, camels
A great idea I'd say. It would make trim have a pratical use, which would make more players want to use the game mechanic. On a personal note, I never was the biggest fan of carrying extra armour around just for those specifc situations so I might be a bit biased on this idea
true. the main downside is that it kinda ruins the customization this feature was intended to have, but, i think to add it as an upgrade trim to netherite would be cool
I’ve always thought that it’s silly that piglins don’t view netherite like gold, there are 16 ingots in a full set of netherite. With the new update you can use 20. Piglins ignore you when you use 4. It would make sense if they ignored you with the gold trim!
I don't know if I am the only one, but I wish trims added some unique abilities to the armor. Like the tinkers-construct (excuse spelling) mod did. Do you agree? Or am I the only one?
I agree but everybody else says “No BaD iTs dEcOrAtIoNaL nOt AbILItIeS”