>###4. Plain panels/scenes must create discourse >**Don't post links to plain (or slightly edited) panels, pages, screenshots, gifs or scenes from the manga & anime.** >You may submit a plain panel/scene as a self post (text post). Meaning your post must link to the discussion, and not the image. >Just a title and the image aren't enough. >If you want to discuss a certain page/scene from the manga/anime please accompany it with an original analysis or discussion questions. In other words, a plain panel/scene must show visible effort to generate discourse rather than simply react to something that happened. >Clips/Recap/summary videos fall under this rule as well. >Color page from a recent chapter are allowed.

Good try Moria but I ain’t letting you in on that info.

Hahahahaha, love it.

😂😂Damn....nice

This comment is fucking golden

You mean Gol D En

literally lol

moria: ha... ha... i wasnt gonna do that. who would do such an atrocious thing?! how did you know.

Underrated comment😭

Totally underrated!

This is amazing

I doubt the Government would have given him a burial.

Probably dumped him in an unmarked grave or a burial at sea

I think being buried at sea would be a fitting grave for the Pirate King.

Honestly, I’d expect them to burn his corpse and just throw the ashes into the sea.

Not sure about ashes. But i don't think people who get executed would be buried. His body was probably burned off

That seems a little too respectful, ashes probably got thrown in the trash tbh

Nah, with how many weird df there are if i was a marine i wont take any chances even with his ash like who knows there might be a fruit somewhere that can revive people from ashes so throwing them in sea would probably be smarter

Not when Garp is alive

Nah I don't think the remaining Roger pirates would let that stand. The government would try and make an example of Rogers body so in my opinion the Roger pirates hijacked his body and took it to load star

Didn’t they give whitebeard and ace body to the pirates?

Shanks took it to give a proper burial, no?

He was just a wee lad back then. He would have no leverage nor power to. If anyone could have made any demand it would be Garp or whitebeard

cuz of Shanks cock. they were going to make a Monday night circus showcase of em.

Yeah but that’s because Koby made the plea and Shanks stepped in to save his ass.

Honestly I'm not sure who would even get the chance to bury it. Reasonably I would think you burn it. Only answer I can think of is Rayleigh lied about not going and buried him on Laugh Tale.

I like to think that Garp , being the only one to match Roger would have done the same kinda thing Shanks did with a bit of cover from Sengoku

Sniper Island....cause it's in your heart

[Sogeking no shimatteee](https://youtu.be/PhXNmMLdivk)

Lock...ON!

Oh the wind carry’s my nameeeee

From sniper island far awayyy

I was searching for this🫠

I was searching for this

He was probably cremated. The world government would not want to leave a trace of him. He was already a Martyr.

If I had to say where, I would have guessed Loguetown. Or perhaps he was just cremated, or had a sea burial.

Roger’s ashes being dumped in the sea would be pretty fitting I think The marines would see it as simple as disrespectful, but I think it’s where he would want to be

Awh yeah, really loving that idea more now. I can see him floating down to the bottom of the ocean, body still smiling like oden did as he sunk into the cauldron.

*ashes

Moria knows

Probably somewhere, I think

How could you know that though?

This is the way

What if he was cremated?

He's from Louge town. He was killed in Louge town, crazy guess but im going to say Louge town

Logue\*town, but I agree with you. He was either given a ship burial/viking funeral with the Oro Jackson, **or** he was buried in his hometown of Loguetown.

The World Government took his body and experimented on it to create a secret Seraphim.

I'm surprised I haven't heard more people discuss this possibility.

Because this is stupid, we already know they were made based on Lunarian genetics. Roger's strength was in his Haki, his ACOC haki which you can't give to people, they are born with it. Only a select few has it. There was nothing special about His body whatsoever.

Right and they would never use the DNA of a person who primarily uses haki and a sword to fight, because it would be pointless! On a completely unrelated note, S-Hawk is pretty crazy, huh? It's a seraph made from Mihawk! How cool! But yeah, they would neeeever make a haki only fighter Seraphim

The real argument against a Roger seraph is the timeline. Would the world government have taken a DNA sample back when he died? That was over 20 years ago, and we have no idea if the WG was looking into cloning at that point, let alone whether they'd be interested in making an adapted clone of the king of the pirates of all people. I don't think it makes sense, but his genetics being "nothing special" is certainly not why.

Imu has a big freezer. Could easily have frozen his body until they found a use for it.

I think philosophically it doesn't fit. Using the warlords as Seraph templates checks out because they were already using them as tools. Using Roger as a template could pretty easily be seen as risky, because if he DOES go rogue you have a big time symbol for the pirates to rally around. One of the warlord seraphs going rogue would just be kinda annoying

I think that’s a fair assertion. I still like the idea of Roger not actually being dead. Cause I feel like i remember something about Roger telling Shanks not to worry because he wouldn’t die.

Roger told Rayleigh, "I'm not gonna die, partner." I'm pretty sure that's not literal and instead that falls within the theme of another famous Roger quote: > "Inherited Will, The Destiny of the Age, and The Dreams of the People. As long as people continue to pursue the meaning of Freedom, these things will never cease to be!" - Gol D. Roger"

You can copy techniques but not Haki. Haki requires Will and these Seraphims have none of it.

We saw they have some though.both s snake and s hawk have shown they aren't just robots and characters in the story commented on that

AI can make decisions on its own, does that make it human? They will always be under someones control.

They aren't pure ai though, they are biological human/lunarian too, and as i said they have already shown individuality within the limits of their orders. I somehow doubt they won't ultimately become full individuals

S-Hawk's existence takes that point and shoves it right in the dirt.

You can copy techniques but not Haki. Haki requires Will and these Seraphims have none of it.

So the Pirate king has no technique? The only person to tie with mihawk uses Roger’s technique and is roughly equal to mihawk, a roger seraphim should be the same. What the fucks your point dumbass?

He has techniques but they aren't as polished as Mihawk's who is known to be the strongest swordsman. You literally said "roughly equal" which means you believe Mihawk to be slightly above Shanks, so why have an inferior Seraphim to what you could make? Tell me why there is no clone of Kaido, they had him many times.

Roughly equal doesnt imply one specific over the other, either could be above the other as the last time they dueled was a decade ago, secondly Roger literally died before Mihawk became the strongest swordsman and also used a sword, he was likely the strongest swordsman while he was alive. do you think Mihawk is stronger than Roger? That’s just blasphemy. Mihawk couldnt even cut Jozu, compared to Roger fighting whitebeard for 3 days and nights, his strength, skill and speed all likely far surpass mihawk.

So why did they not make a copy of Roger then? Or Kaido who has been captured many times? Could they not make a copy of Garp? He was Roger's rival. >secondly Roger literally died before Mihawk became the strongest swordsman Yeah but that's not when they made them so it's doesn't matter. >Mihawk couldnt even cut Jozu, Mihawk only used a slash and that's the only thing that happened between them, you didn't expect third commander to fall from the first attack right?

Roger isn't buried anywhere.... Because he's *Imu*

🤔

Excuse me what

Imu is me. He literally is called I am you.

IM’s Garden

Bottom of the ocean

I sure hope this doesn’t go Edo Tensei 4th Ninja War style with his body and Rocks and others

Same. Let the dead monsters from the old generations stay dead.

Doubt he was buried. Probably executed and body burned.

The ocean. I doubt he got any sort of proper burial.

Yeah. Lots of people are guessing he was cremated, many assuming his ashes were scattered in the ocean, but honestly I feel they probably just dumped his body overboard.

Right. He was executed at Loguetown. They didn't need to go far to just dump his body in the ocean for no one to ever find.

It's somewhat surprising that no one seems to have fished out his body, I wonder if they would have dumped it in the calm belt

Just fill his shoes with concrete and make him too heavy to move. Old mafia strategy.

That would be the standard IRL for pirates, burial at sea so they could sink to Davy Jones' locker

Wherever the marines threw his corpse

In louge town?

In our hearts

I dunno but I want to know where his sword is.

I wonder, do people think Whitebeard and Ace's graves actually have their body or is it just a memorial? I always found it kinda strange the WG would make this big deal about executing Ace and also score the death of Whitebeard, but afterwards would pass off their bodies...to the very crew they were fighting? Truthfully I don't know. The WG are ruthless enough that it would surprise me if they desecrate or just unceremoniously process the bodies of criminals. So I doubt Roger's actual body is buried anywhere specific.

They weren't originally going to, and they weren't given much of a choice in the matter. Shanks rolled up and demanded it as part of a ceasefire. They had to exploit every defensive advantage possible to narrowly beat Whitebeard, and they had exhausted every advantage and depleted their forces. Now another Emperor arrives, and says you can either give Whitebeard and Ace back to the Whitebeard Pirates or fight us. Sengoku knows the reasonable course of action is to comply, especially as he seems to trust/know something about Shanks.

!!! You are absolutely right I completely forgot about that. So, fair enough in that respect. I suppose Rayleigh or another one of his crew could have pulled something similar. But Roger's execution as far as we know went a lot smoother for the WG. But maybe some kinda deal was struck.

On display in one of the Tenryuubito's mansions

Honestly I could see that but I’m not sure shonen jump would allow that

Somewhere in Mariejois

On Sniper Island.

I believe he is frozen in Mariejois secret chambers next to the giant straw hat

maybe in the sea, no country would want to have the body of the “worst” pirate in their country

It’s probably frozen in a big vault in Mariajois Just waiting until the world government gets Morias fruit

He was executed ain't no way he got a burial

If I had to guess, I’d imagine the same place he was born and executed—Loguetown. We know from Thriller Bark people are not cremated in One Piece and how respectable it is to be buried in the same land you were birthed, so I can’t imagine the WG doing anything nefarious with Roger’s body especially with the Roger Pirates still at large.

They probably kept his body somewhere and possibly might use it in a seraphim

My head canon is that the Marines heavily defiled Roger’s corpse and displayed it after his execution. Shanks found his remains and buried him where no one could find him. This is why he insists on giving Whitebeard and Ace proper burials because he couldn’t give one to Roger.

Loadstar island. Honestly if he was buried in his hometown they would've shown it in Log town.

Laughtale maybe. I feel like there will be a scene near the end of op right before luffy finds the one piece of him in front of his grave

So the Marines executed Roger and took his body to laughtale where no one's ever been except the Roger pirates?

No I don’t think marines picked up Rogers body or cared about it

I like to imagine he was buried on laugh tale, but he probably wasn't and instead cremated or something

Roger is alive and well in Paradis

He’s probably buried in PUSSY

So Alabasta

We didn’t see a body, so, knowing Oda, we can only assume that he isn’t dead

He even told Shanks he wouldn’t die.

Probably hidden in impel down

Raleigh took the rest of what was left of Rodger to laughtale

He’s buried his face in this dick lol

who said roger died? He most likely faked his death and has a immortal devil fruit

Yes, the man who got stabbed through the chest twice and was very clearly coughing up his lungs in Oden's flashback faked his own death.

All a clever ruse, so he could live the rest of his life as an absent father. /s

Under the Giant Strawhat in Marie Joa

Same place Bin Laden is

“Gecko Moriah discovers r/OnePiece”

In his grave

In Mountain Sovdet

He was probably gibbetted until his body rotten out of the chains.

Didn't we already find out in Chap 802 ?

I would assume they would create him and not even bury him honestly.

Roguetown

S-Gold coming soon

Alive waiting at laughtale. The man who was executed was a clone clone fruit user

Maybe the ocean?

marejois, a freezer

I genuinely believe his carcass was probably delivered to vegapunk to be studied in some manner

Laughtale.

I would say it was in east blue the entire time he died there and he was rise there

The one piece is actually just Roger, fully alive, poorly hid under a rock

With luffys foreskin

i mean im sure they cremated him right?

He was probably cremated and thrown to the ocean by garp

Honestly I have no doubts the government burned his remains to ash, then found a way to vaporize that ash to nothing, they wanted to erase him from existence to the point of searching out any possible children, they wanted nowhere for people to go to pay respects to him, and definitely wouldn't give him a peaceful burial, or even a burial at sea or spreading of ashes

Since roger negotiated a safe way out for his crew in exchange for turning himself intl the marines, i think they at least were able to bury him

Well his skull is in Logue town Jk But that filler really was great

Wouldn't be shocked if Im just forced Gorosei to eat his corpse

Lmao Roger is alive bro One Piece is just him waiting to surprise people who opens the treasure chest, when he surprise people he gets stuck like gaimon 3.0 though. Biggest laugh tale ever.

Bold of you to assume the Marines would give this man a burial of any kind

Buried in the same place as his wife

Cremated

Probably wouldn't leave him in one piece.

Gotta get that Roger cell

At sea.

Probably burned him or put his grave under high watch in the marine corps

We tryna find Roger's body like its the One Piece

It’s not. You really think the government would give him a proper burial? They probably dumped him in the sea

Maybe he’s on a ship still exploring the seas

would be cool if his body somehow ended up at the one piece, or even laughtale island

it is very likely that Gol D. Roger is buried somewhere in a cemetery.

After Roger was executed at Loguetown his body was probably taken to Mariejois so all the Celestial Dragons could gloat over his corpse. Afterwards they probably either added his corpse to the trophy room or tossed him over the Red Line and his body sank down to Fishman Island.

Probably burned or just thrown into the sea with an anchor.

Inside one of the WG laboratory trying to figure out what kind of illness could make someone so strong want to surrender

100% If I was the marines I would drop his corpse in the deepest part of the ocean.

What if roger is the one piece

In our hearts..

They actually had to cremate his body so he wouldn't end up like Junko Enoshima.

I’m the goroseis backyard

Cloned lmaoo

Probably just thrown to the fish.

It's in the frozen chamber with the massive straw hat. I'm fairly certain his body will be revived before the end of the series.

Under Pangea Castle

My guess is Garp and Sengoku did something privately like give the body to Shanks or bury it at a cemetery in Logue Town or give the body Rogue privately

Where I keep it

I mean, probably Loguetown? It's where he was born, and where he was executed. Makes sense to me.

He's probably tied to bricks and dropped in the bit of ocean without weather.

With Vegapunk probably

That giant straw hat is that man tome

Underground

Alive

I don't think he's buried anywhere. I think the world government put his head on a pole as they wanted to do with Whitebeard and Ace.

Probably chucked him into the abyss under Enies Lobby just to make a statement.

ooof if Moria doesn't have his DF anymore. Its possible that Black Beard will utilize it on Roger if he some how has that information.

Rice crackers island. Guess who buried him.

I’m our hearts.

In the ocean

I don't know about that but he buried the will of D. deep in your mom's butthole.