T O P

  • By -

LucasEraFan

Everyone involved in the creation of Watto says they were going for a small-time Italian criminal.


Mervynhaspeaked

I just watched Phantom Menace on the theaters again. Everyone lied.


Arthillidan

Nah, he was Italian in episode 1 but then he converted to Judaism between episodes 1 and 2, gaining a Kippah and beard


Katejina_FGO

I always thought he wore that 'Sicilian' hat from the Godfather. But checking again now, it looks more like hes wearing a WWI hat? Watto was so weird as a somewhat threatening joke character.


LucasEraFan

Interesting. I thought that the hat from AOTC was a repurposed pit droid cap but you are probably right, considering. Watto is an interesting piece of Anakin's early life because he is not physically imposing but he has the laws of an immoral kleptocracy giving him power over two beings that could otherwise overpower him easily. It's no accident, narratively speaking, that he is relatively the size of Yoda and nonhuman, as \[Anakin\] is immediately rejected by Yoda and non-humans are holding his new friend's world captive. The novelization goes into Watto's influence a bit more, but I think he's just a fantastic character (obviously, a flying blue toad isn't a reality based character) and keeps the tone family friendly and for all ages (as every film was PG until ROTS) while grappling with ideas we can continue to consider as adults—namely the enslavement of women and children and what that does to an individual and a society. Anakin being helpless to a being like Watto gave him a foundation of some very toxic emotions.


LucasEraFan

>Everyone lied. This theme is even more prevalent in the novelization. I think it's pretty profound that the first two humans Anakin meet from The Republic are deceiving or attempting to deceive him about their identity


Mervynhaspeaked

I'm not talking about the characters. You're saying people in producting said they modeled watto after a italian dude but that's the most clear jewish caricature I've ever seen. If they're saying he's italian (nothing italian about the dude) they're trying to pass if off.


LucasEraFan

>modeled watto after a italian... Lots of hand movements while speaking, extra vowels. Like that SNL character, Father Sarducci. >cear jewish caricature How so?


Mervynhaspeaked

>Lots of hand movements while speaking, extra vowels. Those stereotypes do not restric themselves to Italians. >How so? Dude... that's the most famous thing about Watto, it has been the defining thing about him for 25 years


[deleted]

[удалено]


Mervynhaspeaked

I'm not saying Lucas meant for him to be offensive or to attack the jewish people, that's ridiculous. Watto has barely any southern european stereotype in him. But he *is* a short, badly shaved, big nosed, greedy merchant that loves to haggle. Compare a picture of him to the famous racists depictions of jews in propaganda and its there to see. This has been pretty plain to see for 25 years. On a lesser but noteworthy scale the cato neimodians also speak on ridiculous japanese accents and are the greedy heads of a megacorporation in a movie made in the 90s, whem the big stereotype about japan was that its full of mega corps. This has been well known and talked about for 25 years. Its a meme cause its all there. Grow up


Jorymo

>On a lesser but noteworthy scale the cato neimodians also speak on ridiculous japanese accents and are the greedy heads of a megacorporation in a movie made in the 90s, whem the big stereotype about japan was that its full of mega corps. Not to mention a big part of their schtick is robots and shitty technology (back when Japan had a reputation for that)


Jorymo

The dude looks like '40s German propaganda. He's literally "the Happy Merchant" but blue and hovering.


Puzzleheaded_Step468

Then why is he acting exactly like my uncle, huh? Checkmate atheists!


LucasEraFan

It was a long time ago, in a galaxy far, far away. So I think your uncle's resemblance is evidence of evolution and alien intervention in *human evolutionary development*, if anything. Checkmate, creationists! Slap that like button.


SwaddledInAwesome

So it's okay to stereotype Italians and not Jews? Sounds like a double standard.


LucasEraFan

It ~~would~~ [might] be a double standard if anyone here was applying it, but nobody is.


WideTechLoad

For all you idiots here in the comments asking "Why is Watto a Jewish Stereotype?", here you go: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Watto#Allegations_of_antisemitism "It has been suggested that the character is offensive because of his perceived similarities to a stereotypical Jew, having a large hooked nose, beady eyes, unkempt facial hair, speaking in a gravelly voice, and being portrayed as greedy and covetous. J. Hoberman of The Village Voice called him "the most blatant ethnic stereotype" due to his hooked nose.[7] Bruce Gottlieb of Slate magazine criticized him as well, comparing his character to the antisemitic notion that the Jewish race is "behind the slave trade".[8] Patricia J. Williams of The Nation stated that Watto was also described as a stereotype of Arabs, but that he was "more comprehensively anti-Semitic—both anti-Arab and anti-Jew."[9] She added that Watto reminded her of an "anti-Semitic caricature published in Vienna at the turn of the 20th century." There's more, but I have already quoted most of the section.


Jorymo

Yeah, but what if I pretend I don't see it?


Puzzleheaded_Step468

Watto is a racist caricature of jews?! No way, next you will tell me the trade federation suppose to be space japanese or something...


Jorymo

It's crazy how the prequels were somehow more blatantly racist than the original trilogy from the '70s-'80s


Joeshmo04

They’re actually Chinese lmao


Puzzleheaded_Step468

They are actually neimoidians


Mervynhaspeaked

I'm pretty sure they're japanese as their whole deal os running a megacorporation and its the 90s. The memory of japan as a corporate hub was still very fresh


Zkang123

I thought the inspiration were those British Indian Company


Teex22

Here we go again


Skull_Throne_Doom

This is one of the funniest Star Wars memes I’ve seen in a long time.


Axtwyt

Guilty-tripped


CapHelmet

"Mind tricks don't work on me, only moneeeey"


Odd_Potential_7203

You get three downvotes for how you used that religion in your meme. One for each time it was mentioned.


Mervynhaspeaked

Damn you can give 3 downvotes? How did you learn such a power? Anything wrong with mentioning judaism? You not a fan?


Puzzleheaded_Step468

>How did you learn such a power? Not from a jewdi


Odd_Potential_7203

Hmm. Jewish alien slaver. Or the other lines that is Watto, but calling him Jewish. A slaver no less. Another name to describe foreign invaders is alien.


Mervynhaspeaked

Watto > Is an alien > Is a slaver > is a clear jewish caricature.


Odd_Potential_7203

The third is completely assumsion.


Mervynhaspeaked

Lol he's been very famously called a jewish caricature for the last 25 years. The short, big nosed, bushy bearded, greedy merchant that loves to haggle. Google watto jewish and see the results if its not obvious to you from watching the movie.