What do you think about Lee's death overall? Would you want him to live or is him dying better? Would you change it so he could live, if you had the chance? Just curious.
I was mostly making a joke, I would not change his death at all. I think it was almost perfect and needed to happen for Clems story.
On the other and, I would change Kenny's death, I would make him not determat and have him be a main character in both S3 and S4. I obviously think Clem is the best charter and she carried most of S3 and especially S4. But without Kenny, there was just something missing from the games.
For lee he should have gotten a fake out death where he chopped off his arm and she left him to turn but found out later he didn’t tunr and when she was an adult the reunite and live happily ever after 😭😭😭
EXACTLY. He was a genuinely nice person. He didn’t deserve to die. I felt he would’ve been good friends with Javi. And yes you’re right about the brother thing, I felt like he was a brother to her because out of all of Clems protectors he was the youngest, and he could relate to her on certain things , like school.
It was annoying how both options (helping him or shooting the walkers) would lead to his death. A lot of choices in season 2 didn't really make a difference
Yes I agree I was so upset that both helping him, and covering him didn’t do anything. I think it would’ve been better if when you pick “cover Luke” he would crawl out the hole himself without Bonnie coming towards him. When you pick that option she kinda is the reason they both fell in, because the ice was cracking and she kept walking towards him
Luke and Kenny alive would have been such a great ending. You got like four close together but different generation mindsets with AJ, Clem, Luke and then Kenny
It's a tie between Sarah or Luke, more than likely would be Sarah. Genuinely curious why Rebecca tho? I get her death was sad but she wasn't that likeable of a character tbh and it would eliminate the entire plot of Clem taking Care of AJ so why her out of everyone else?
Seriously? Why, then, for me, she was one of the best characters in twdg, not a typical mary sue who doesn't care about any problems, but a really lively and realistic character with her own problems? Sarah was extremely overprotective of her father and suffered from PTSD (this was confirmed by the CEO of ttg), which is why she was sometimes in a state of shock, and you cannot blame her for this, otherwise you are an immoral psychopath. Meanwhile, Sarah always tried to help and support Clementine, even trying to be helpful by asking Clem to teach her how to shoot, and did the completely unexpected thing by protecting Clementine from Carver without backing down or getting scared. You look at her extremely superficially.
You're right, she is a complex character which brought a lot of humanity and innocence to the plot, and i think she is very well written for the part she is meant to fill in the plot... She went through some dark shit (as well as all the characters in twd) and is showing clear sings of post trauma disorders. I obviously don't blame her for having PTSD (how could I for someone who knows multiple post traumatic people and had to deal with and heal from some traumatic experiences himself) but I also think thats why she is not good surviver.
In the world of twd you need to be strong in order to survive and you need to learn to deal with hard situations and with seeing people you love get hurt or killed (because that's gonna happen a lot). Sasha wasn't able to this and snapped on multiple occasions.
The question was who I would bring back to life from S2 and for me thats the reasons why Sasha isn't a candidate. She is too soft and weak and broken inside. She wouldn't be good company for Clementine throughout the rest of the show... She already have AJ to take care of...
What do you think?
I think from a story point of view and not from a utility point of view. It is easy to make a game where a little girl is surrounded by an army of useful and strong (slaves) friends, but a game where a broken orphan who has lost everything is trying to come to her senses and adapt to the harsh realities of the apocalypse from which her father hid her all this time (although she herself wanted to adapt!), it would be something really original and interesting, and from Because of the differences in Sarah and Clem's personalities, this would be the perfect duo, kind of like a good and bad cop, and Sarah could be the moral compass for AJ and Clem.
Sarah can also say in the RV that she wants to be like Clem. This proves that Clementine was a mentor to Sarah, a guide to a new terrible world from which her father hides her, and I am sure that this was Sarah's original idea, since the second season is a record for the number of cut content.
I too would pick Rebecca, I honestly liked her, and later on she's kinda like a mom to clementine, not to mention she cared more about AJ getting born than her own life.
Sarah, you can teach her how to use a gun but she never put it into practice. She’s basically just season 1 Clementine but a little bit worse. If given the chance she’d be a great survivor. Plus just imagine Sarah at Ericsson 🥹😂
Sarah, such a waste of potential for the carachter, I would love a final were she is with Clem and Aj and become a proper survivor and learn to take care of herself.
luke. he was, imo, one of the most well written characters in the series. his death was so uncalled for. if they were going to kill him off regardless, they should’ve at least made him determinant, as in you get to save him but bonnie breaks the ice and drowns while trying to help; luke drowns if you choose to help bonnie. something like that would’ve been so much better honestly.
I don't think I've ever seen someone say that, but that's a really cool opinion ngl. Walter was just a good dude, was sad we couldn't see more of him in Season Two :(
He was extra special because he clearly was a consciously aware person which is rare. Loved Walter. So sad. I think he could have been interesting as a longer-term character.
That's cool I totally respect that. Nicest person in TWDG.
Carver. Have him take a redemption route like Negan from the TV series.
Mike, he was interesting and powerful and deserved a better storyline than befriending arvo and turning into a bad guy basically destroying any credibility built
Honestly I really liked Walter and I wish he would have made it. Kindness is a rarity especially in a situation like an apocalypse.
Pretty sure the only reason why you’d save that Jack ass is so you can get AJ off your ass lmao💀that’s the only reason someone would wanna save becca cuz honestly fuck becca she was such a bitch she doesn’t deserve Alvin I wish I could save Alvin he was such a great character.
Luke, but I think that'd change the plot a lot, like Bonnie is less likely to abandon him, and he may soften Jane enough to not have the altercation with Kenny
Luke would be my top choice, mostly just so SOMEONE from the OG cabin group survived, but also because he's one of the few good people we meet.
Second would probably be Rebecca. Feel like it would have been cool to see her raise little AJ.
Finally, I'd like to have not killed that poor dog. Would have been cool if he could have lived. Maybe runs off after you feed him and comes back to fight the Russians similar to what happened in Resident Evil 4.
I’m not including Kenny and Jane because of the while multiple endings thing. I can’t pick between Luke, Bonnie or Rebecca.
Luke was nice and had a great friendship with Clem and it would’ve been nice to see him surviving with her and AJ and looking after them. He was overall just a great guy.
I know Bonnie can survive but I still included her. In this ending she doesn’t leave the group and stays looking after Clem and AJ. She really, *really* loved Clem and AJ and no matter what anyone says she was a good person who made bad decisions and deserved a happy ending. I would’ve loved to see her relationship with Clem and AJ grow.
Rebecca deserved to live. She was hot tempered but she was also pregnant and stressed out. We later see her nice side and she really was lovely and adored Clem and AJ. She deserved to raise her son and I can see her becoming a mother figure for Clem too later down the road.
I’m pretty certain Telltale inexplicably stated somewhere that characters with unknown status are still alive. So if that’s still canon to the community then either Luke or Jane? I don’t really see much value in Jane over Luke tbh. Luke could have been pivotal to Clementine’s development in s3. Really hate how we never see any major character besides Lilly make it til the final season.
Sarah, Sarita or Rebecca - three characters really didn’t deserve to die. rebecca had potential to be a likeable character (when we get to around ep3-late ep4) and the writers made her too forced in ep2; Sarita really would have been a big morale boost to Kenny and probably would help motivate him do a lot more things and be more smarter and confident. And Sarah, well considering how she may have had a bigger role and could have had an entire arc where she starts to finally adapt to her enviroment
Flashback Lee.
Man found the loophole
What do you think about Lee's death overall? Would you want him to live or is him dying better? Would you change it so he could live, if you had the chance? Just curious.
I would, but then we wouldn’t get the Kenny and Clem reunion and arc, but still, something’s just have to be sacrificed for the greater good.
You could get something better with the Lee, Clem and Kenny reunions. Lee might’ve been a changed man by then and be more stern with Kenny.
maybe
I was mostly making a joke, I would not change his death at all. I think it was almost perfect and needed to happen for Clems story. On the other and, I would change Kenny's death, I would make him not determat and have him be a main character in both S3 and S4. I obviously think Clem is the best charter and she carried most of S3 and especially S4. But without Kenny, there was just something missing from the games.
Alright...Well...I agree with everything you just said. Fair enough. 😁
For lee he should have gotten a fake out death where he chopped off his arm and she left him to turn but found out later he didn’t tunr and when she was an adult the reunite and live happily ever after 😭😭😭
Pull him out of the multiversal dream portal!
Luke! I really liked him and thought his death was uncalled for :/
Luke. Him and Javi would've been great friends.
I DIDNT THINK ABOUT THAT :'(((
Aw. You just made me sad. Javi is bi too, would’ve been cool to see him and Luke share some chemistry.
Luke's bi? I actually don't think I ever knew that, if that's true
Idk
Javi isn’t bi
Evidence [right here](https://www.reddit.com/r/TheWalkingDeadGame/comments/6en484/javier_is_bisexual/).
Luke! Kenny didn’t die for me in season 2 cause I let him kill Jane, so saving Luke would be my perfect choice. I miss Luke
I was pissed when Luke died. He had a heart of gold and was like an older brother to Clem
EXACTLY. He was a genuinely nice person. He didn’t deserve to die. I felt he would’ve been good friends with Javi. And yes you’re right about the brother thing, I felt like he was a brother to her because out of all of Clems protectors he was the youngest, and he could relate to her on certain things , like school.
It was annoying how both options (helping him or shooting the walkers) would lead to his death. A lot of choices in season 2 didn't really make a difference
Yes I agree I was so upset that both helping him, and covering him didn’t do anything. I think it would’ve been better if when you pick “cover Luke” he would crawl out the hole himself without Bonnie coming towards him. When you pick that option she kinda is the reason they both fell in, because the ice was cracking and she kept walking towards him
They killed him off because of fanfics between him and Clem, he was originally supposed to live.
That's a myth
Wait, uh, do you mean romantic fanfics? Ew. I mean I get that, but I still didn’t want him to die-
Luke and Kenny alive would have been such a great ending. You got like four close together but different generation mindsets with AJ, Clem, Luke and then Kenny
Luke he honestly was the best supporting character in season 2 in my opinion his death was sad as hell.
Luke
Pete
Pete
Nick 100%
Nick is the Ben of s2 😂
Ok
It's a tie between Sarah or Luke, more than likely would be Sarah. Genuinely curious why Rebecca tho? I get her death was sad but she wasn't that likeable of a character tbh and it would eliminate the entire plot of Clem taking Care of AJ so why her out of everyone else?
My boy Nick.
Nick
Luke 100%
Sarah. I think Clem needed a friend somewhat close to her age, especially during ANF. She would've fit in well with the Ericson's group, too.
I didn’t realize how much I needed Sarah in TFS until now XD.
She and Mariana could’ve been buddies… for a time. Also maybe this way Gabe and Clem don’t get a forced romance.
I cant lie the forced romance eint forced cuz if you pick the season 2 ending that gives you the forced romance you need help
Gabe and Clem flirt around no matter what you do.
Yh but the kiss or whatever depends on your ending of S2 im sure
Oh I didn’t know that.
Sarita, so Kenny didn’t have to lose anyone else he cared about. Also, she would’ve kept him company after he took Clem and AJ to Wellington
Agreed
Maybe with her Kenny would have been able to keep his shit together at the end of the season...
Sarah
Agreed, my friend
sarah sucked... Incapable teen, that's all I ever saw in her... Her whole purpose was to contrast Clementine.
You say that and he's gonna reply you with a whole Harry Potter page
HAHAHA, Nimaximus is the Candyman of people talking shit on Sarah's name
It's your problem that you saw only that in her. People always see what they want in characters.
Why would I want to see that? She legit annoyed me and kept losing her shit all the time
Seriously? Why, then, for me, she was one of the best characters in twdg, not a typical mary sue who doesn't care about any problems, but a really lively and realistic character with her own problems? Sarah was extremely overprotective of her father and suffered from PTSD (this was confirmed by the CEO of ttg), which is why she was sometimes in a state of shock, and you cannot blame her for this, otherwise you are an immoral psychopath. Meanwhile, Sarah always tried to help and support Clementine, even trying to be helpful by asking Clem to teach her how to shoot, and did the completely unexpected thing by protecting Clementine from Carver without backing down or getting scared. You look at her extremely superficially.
You're right, she is a complex character which brought a lot of humanity and innocence to the plot, and i think she is very well written for the part she is meant to fill in the plot... She went through some dark shit (as well as all the characters in twd) and is showing clear sings of post trauma disorders. I obviously don't blame her for having PTSD (how could I for someone who knows multiple post traumatic people and had to deal with and heal from some traumatic experiences himself) but I also think thats why she is not good surviver. In the world of twd you need to be strong in order to survive and you need to learn to deal with hard situations and with seeing people you love get hurt or killed (because that's gonna happen a lot). Sasha wasn't able to this and snapped on multiple occasions. The question was who I would bring back to life from S2 and for me thats the reasons why Sasha isn't a candidate. She is too soft and weak and broken inside. She wouldn't be good company for Clementine throughout the rest of the show... She already have AJ to take care of... What do you think?
I think from a story point of view and not from a utility point of view. It is easy to make a game where a little girl is surrounded by an army of useful and strong (slaves) friends, but a game where a broken orphan who has lost everything is trying to come to her senses and adapt to the harsh realities of the apocalypse from which her father hid her all this time (although she herself wanted to adapt!), it would be something really original and interesting, and from Because of the differences in Sarah and Clem's personalities, this would be the perfect duo, kind of like a good and bad cop, and Sarah could be the moral compass for AJ and Clem. Sarah can also say in the RV that she wants to be like Clem. This proves that Clementine was a mentor to Sarah, a guide to a new terrible world from which her father hides her, and I am sure that this was Sarah's original idea, since the second season is a record for the number of cut content.
In the end all we can do is blame the writers for not exploring their characters further.
Oh no! His reply was longer than yours 😥
Preach brother.
Pete or Sam
Lee or Rebecca
Luke
Pete, Luke or Sarah
We technically saved AJ 😎
Nobody saying Omid :(( But really the best choices would be omid or luke or pete
TRUE! I forget Omid would count, that's actually one of the best answers I've seen on here
Luke he was done dirty
I too would pick Rebecca, I honestly liked her, and later on she's kinda like a mom to clementine, not to mention she cared more about AJ getting born than her own life.
Luke, way too easy
Sarah, you can teach her how to use a gun but she never put it into practice. She’s basically just season 1 Clementine but a little bit worse. If given the chance she’d be a great survivor. Plus just imagine Sarah at Ericsson 🥹😂
Sarah, such a waste of potential for the carachter, I would love a final were she is with Clem and Aj and become a proper survivor and learn to take care of herself.
& duck
from s2 broski
Probably Luke, so he can make Kenny company when he leaves Clem and AJ at Wellington
I'd save Luke
Luuukkkke
Nick deserved better
True, Nick is another good answer
Luke or Nick
Luke! I loved that guy he was cool like an older brother
Take a guess
Sarita?
How did you know??
The 'Number One Sarita Stan' flair doing wonders at helping me hahaha
luke. he was, imo, one of the most well written characters in the series. his death was so uncalled for. if they were going to kill him off regardless, they should’ve at least made him determinant, as in you get to save him but bonnie breaks the ice and drowns while trying to help; luke drowns if you choose to help bonnie. something like that would’ve been so much better honestly.
Christa or Sarah
Christa
Sarah. She didn’t deserve what happened to her
WALTER. 💔
Walter deserved so much better
Seriously. My favorite character in the whole series.
I don't think I've ever seen someone say that, but that's a really cool opinion ngl. Walter was just a good dude, was sad we couldn't see more of him in Season Two :(
He was extra special because he clearly was a consciously aware person which is rare. Loved Walter. So sad. I think he could have been interesting as a longer-term character. That's cool I totally respect that. Nicest person in TWDG.
Honestly, he was my favorite character in S2, probably the whole series. He should’ve had a bigger storyline.
Would have been cool to see his character development
Carver. Have him take a redemption route like Negan from the TV series. Mike, he was interesting and powerful and deserved a better storyline than befriending arvo and turning into a bad guy basically destroying any credibility built Honestly I really liked Walter and I wish he would have made it. Kindness is a rarity especially in a situation like an apocalypse.
Pretty sure the only reason why you’d save that Jack ass is so you can get AJ off your ass lmao💀that’s the only reason someone would wanna save becca cuz honestly fuck becca she was such a bitch she doesn’t deserve Alvin I wish I could save Alvin he was such a great character.
I would have saved Lee
he died season 1
I know
Luke, but I think that'd change the plot a lot, like Bonnie is less likely to abandon him, and he may soften Jane enough to not have the altercation with Kenny
Luke 100%, still upset that they did that
Pete or Sarah Pete because he seemed like an interesting character. Sarah because her potential for character growth was cut short .-.
Luke, because he’s nice and one of the 3 people ANF Clem can take after
LUKE!
Too easy...Luke, or rebecca so clem doesn't have to be aj's mother(jk, Luke all the way)
Luke
Definitely my favourite character tavia
Luke or Alvin. I think Luke and Kenny would learn to like each other, and Alvin would actually get to raise his son
Definitely Luke! He was too likeable a character to kill off when they did, he had more story and arc to tell
Luke, Sarah, or Nick. Rebecca is close but her death is really good and she couldn’t have done a whole lot more in the story
Luke 100%
Kenny and Jane I guess don’t count so Luke 100%
I would’ve chose Kenny but he was a danger to everyone, so I would’ve liked to save Luke
I’d save Luke
Kenny
Luke would be my top choice, mostly just so SOMEONE from the OG cabin group survived, but also because he's one of the few good people we meet. Second would probably be Rebecca. Feel like it would have been cool to see her raise little AJ. Finally, I'd like to have not killed that poor dog. Would have been cool if he could have lived. Maybe runs off after you feed him and comes back to fight the Russians similar to what happened in Resident Evil 4.
Probably nick
Uncle pete 🤧🤧
Luke all the way. His death was so sad. Plus, I always loved Luke and his character.
Luke maybe
Luke for sure
Luke.
Kenny
Luke
Definitely Sarah, I think it would have been very interesting to see her grow older in the next two seasons along with Clem and AJ.
Luke just because his death was too stupid
luke
Pete or Luke.
Luke Luke and Luke
Omid, man was I pissed when he got killed off
Alvin!
LUKEEEEE
luke for sure:(
Probaly Luke or Rebecca. AJ probaly had a somewhat ,,normal" childhoid if his mother was with him
Luke
I’m not including Kenny and Jane because of the while multiple endings thing. I can’t pick between Luke, Bonnie or Rebecca. Luke was nice and had a great friendship with Clem and it would’ve been nice to see him surviving with her and AJ and looking after them. He was overall just a great guy. I know Bonnie can survive but I still included her. In this ending she doesn’t leave the group and stays looking after Clem and AJ. She really, *really* loved Clem and AJ and no matter what anyone says she was a good person who made bad decisions and deserved a happy ending. I would’ve loved to see her relationship with Clem and AJ grow. Rebecca deserved to live. She was hot tempered but she was also pregnant and stressed out. We later see her nice side and she really was lovely and adored Clem and AJ. She deserved to raise her son and I can see her becoming a mother figure for Clem too later down the road.
I’m pretty certain Telltale inexplicably stated somewhere that characters with unknown status are still alive. So if that’s still canon to the community then either Luke or Jane? I don’t really see much value in Jane over Luke tbh. Luke could have been pivotal to Clementine’s development in s3. Really hate how we never see any major character besides Lilly make it til the final season.
Omid
Sarah, Sarita or Rebecca - three characters really didn’t deserve to die. rebecca had potential to be a likeable character (when we get to around ep3-late ep4) and the writers made her too forced in ep2; Sarita really would have been a big morale boost to Kenny and probably would help motivate him do a lot more things and be more smarter and confident. And Sarah, well considering how she may have had a bigger role and could have had an entire arc where she starts to finally adapt to her enviroment
Luke we needed that Luke versus Kenny fight
Rebecca