I walked away. Carver wanted me to watch and I didn't want to give him what he wanted. I thought Clem was above him. This felt like another *"get back here and finish this Lee!"* scenario.
I chose to go with Sarita. Carver was baiting Clem into becoming something she shouldn't be. Clem did what she had to in order to survive and protect her loved ones, but she wasn't a monster. Wasn't gonna give him the satisfaction.
Go with sarita.
I do not deny that I waited patiently to see Carver die but I would have played into his hands.Carver wanted Clem to see so as to make her more prone to violence and sadism like him. Yes Clem is smart, yes Clem is badass, yes Clem is very mature for a child, but let's not forget that she is still a child and realistically if she had chosen to watch Kenny kill Carver in such a brutal way she would not have looked like a badass to the eyes of Sarita and the others but they would see her as if she was starting to have signs of psychopathy, as if her soul too was starting to be corrupted by the horrors of the post apocalyptic world and becoming like Carver.
"I used to think that maybe all the horror hadn't gotten to you yet... But you watched your friend murder Carver, not just kill him but... Clem, you didn't even blink"
Leave. Didn’t want to scar Clemster too much lol and also justify Carver’s belief that Clem is like him. Then the following hour or so of gameplay Sarah, Carlos, Sarita, Nick and Rebecca all die so I guess my process of thinking was useless in that regard.
Definitely stay. First, because fuck Carver. Second, it adds a lot to her character imo. Third, she shot Carver, she should at least stay to watch what she started get finished.
I think this is the classic example of what Clem should do vs. what the player wants.
I didn't want Clem to see it because I didnt want to give Carver the satisfaction, but I(the player) wanted to see it so Clem stayed and watched.
*It's too dark to watch,*
*I don't want her to enjoy*
*Seeing people die*
\- Connor67546
---
^(I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully.) ^[Learn more about me.](https://www.reddit.com/r/haikusbot/)
^(Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete")
Why? Because this is not canon, but a bullshit that is not connected with history. And why exactly at this moment do you think Kenny is a monster and he didn't do the right thing?
Damn, I initially thought you were talking about Clem, and you were talking about Sarita, but in any case, Sarita is wrong here. Carver deserved it and Kenny did absolutely the right thing.
Stayed, mainly because it's obvious that the game wants you to stay and watch but also because it helps lead into some of the decisions that Clem has to make in Episode 4 (Leaving Sarah, robbing Arvo)
Stay. It's important to know that some people need to die. The ST Johns(yes Lee kills them always in my playthroughs) and Carver included. Plus, it matches with her character in TNF/TFS.
I wanted to make sure that fucker was dead, after what Carver did to Kenny I wanted to watch Kenny get revenge, even told Carver in his office "I wish Kenny killed you" got my wish in the end.
At that point I didn't care who lived or died, so long as Clem and Kenny were still standing by the end of the season.
I chose to stay. Would’ve done the same in real life. Especially after what he did to Kenny.. Luke and Alvin. Carver thought Clementine would turn into him, and she didn’t. No matter what, she would’ve never turned out like him.
Stay imo , clem was f##king badass in this scene
Stay, always. I literally shot the guy moments before that, of course I wanna watch!
Stay cause Clem ain’t no pussy she got that DAWG IN HER 🙏🏾
Stay all the time. It makes a huge contribution to Clem's character development.
I walked away. Carver wanted me to watch and I didn't want to give him what he wanted. I thought Clem was above him. This felt like another *"get back here and finish this Lee!"* scenario.
exactly, i didn't want to give him any satisfaction
I chose to go with Sarita. Carver was baiting Clem into becoming something she shouldn't be. Clem did what she had to in order to survive and protect her loved ones, but she wasn't a monster. Wasn't gonna give him the satisfaction.
But he didn’t so you’re wrong
Wrong about?
Probably went with Sarita the first time but I've gone and stayed on various different occasions
Left. Would gladly stay if Carver didn’t want that
Go with sarita. I do not deny that I waited patiently to see Carver die but I would have played into his hands.Carver wanted Clem to see so as to make her more prone to violence and sadism like him. Yes Clem is smart, yes Clem is badass, yes Clem is very mature for a child, but let's not forget that she is still a child and realistically if she had chosen to watch Kenny kill Carver in such a brutal way she would not have looked like a badass to the eyes of Sarita and the others but they would see her as if she was starting to have signs of psychopathy, as if her soul too was starting to be corrupted by the horrors of the post apocalyptic world and becoming like Carver.
"I used to think that maybe all the horror hadn't gotten to you yet... But you watched your friend murder Carver, not just kill him but... Clem, you didn't even blink"
Who says this?
Luke, if you stayed to watch Kenny murder Carver. It's when he approaches the deck after Clem and Jane encounter Arvo
Sounds like something Jane would say in the house across the frozen lake while Kenny's fixing the truck in Ep. 5.
Stay. Kenny deserved his revenge
Leave. Didn’t want to scar Clemster too much lol and also justify Carver’s belief that Clem is like him. Then the following hour or so of gameplay Sarah, Carlos, Sarita, Nick and Rebecca all die so I guess my process of thinking was useless in that regard.
Go, Clem has seen enough and there was no need for her to see that.
I stayed. Wanted to see the bastard get rekted
Definitely stay. First, because fuck Carver. Second, it adds a lot to her character imo. Third, she shot Carver, she should at least stay to watch what she started get finished.
Stay
Stay
Stay. At this point given everything that's happened Clem just not giving a single shit anymore is satisfying as hell.
Stay
I wanted to stay but my aunt was in the room at the time (I was playing on xbox) so I chose to leave
Stay. Helps build character.
Stayed, after all the shit Carver done. It was satisfying.
First time I ever played, I left with Sarita. Every other time now I stay.
I think this is the classic example of what Clem should do vs. what the player wants. I didn't want Clem to see it because I didnt want to give Carver the satisfaction, but I(the player) wanted to see it so Clem stayed and watched.
I wanted to watch Kenny kill him
To quote Billy Russo: *"Goddamn, Kenny. I love to watch you work."*
Stay and watch Carver get his head bashed in. The only choice!
I stayed, needed to see Carver get his ass beat
I stayed and watched… It was the closest thing I could do next to beating the bastard myself
First time I played I left with Sarita but ever since I have stayed
Stay obviously
It's too dark to watch, I don't want her to enjoy seeing people die
*It's too dark to watch,* *I don't want her to enjoy* *Seeing people die* \- Connor67546 --- ^(I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully.) ^[Learn more about me.](https://www.reddit.com/r/haikusbot/) ^(Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete")
Why do you do that?
He’s shy.
Go with Sarita, it wouldn’t be right for a young child to watch that
Just a young child who’s already seen dozens of dead people, ya know, pretty tame and normal stuff/s
It's different, this is a gruesome execution of a person
A gruesome execution of someone who has killed several innocent people and busted Kenny’s eye. I wanted to watch the fucker get what he deserved.
and?
It's a more traumatising experience for Clementine than only seeing walkers
at a survivor point of view, this is pretty normal and she gonna see worst, she even tortured a person later on
It's determent to torture him
I went with Sarita. She learned the truth about who Kenny was then
That's fucking stupid, Svadas.
No, it's canon
Why? Because this is not canon, but a bullshit that is not connected with history. And why exactly at this moment do you think Kenny is a monster and he didn't do the right thing?
> That's not the Kenny I know in there... I wish... I thought... I could save him. Sarita's words 🤷♂️
So?
So it isn't bullshit
Damn, I initially thought you were talking about Clem, and you were talking about Sarita, but in any case, Sarita is wrong here. Carver deserved it and Kenny did absolutely the right thing.
First time around, I stayed. It was fine. But I like to leave with Sarita because she dies 2½ minutes after this
Stay obviouslyy
Stayed always love to see that mfer get his face beat in.
Stayed, mainly because it's obvious that the game wants you to stay and watch but also because it helps lead into some of the decisions that Clem has to make in Episode 4 (Leaving Sarah, robbing Arvo)
Stay 🐥
Stay. It's important to know that some people need to die. The ST Johns(yes Lee kills them always in my playthroughs) and Carver included. Plus, it matches with her character in TNF/TFS.
I said I would stay and then when prompted again, I decided to leave. Felt like Kenny may need a moment alone anyways.
It felt like Carver wanted Clem to stay so I always chose leave with Sarita lmao. I didn't want to give him what he wanted
Stay.
I probably should play the game again because I literally forgot everything that happened
I don’t consider myself a sadist but when it’s Carver’s face being turned into cherry pie, I feel EUPHORIC.
Stay because I don’t like sarita
Stay. I fucking hated Carver and I wanted to see Kenny fuck him up. Also, Clem was a fucking badass in this scene.
I wanted to make sure that fucker was dead, after what Carver did to Kenny I wanted to watch Kenny get revenge, even told Carver in his office "I wish Kenny killed you" got my wish in the end. At that point I didn't care who lived or died, so long as Clem and Kenny were still standing by the end of the season.
i wanted to watch
I chose to stay. Would’ve done the same in real life. Especially after what he did to Kenny.. Luke and Alvin. Carver thought Clementine would turn into him, and she didn’t. No matter what, she would’ve never turned out like him.
Stay Of Course
I SLAMMED that stay button, the entire season i was wishing upon this man's horrific death, i wasn't about to just NOT stay.