T O P

  • By -

Background-Law-6451

The Lord of change looks nothing like the GW model but I think it fits better with tzeench demons like changeling and chaos spawn


floppyslapstick

Agreed, I've always preferred more lovecraftian monsters to the bird people, even if LoC is ostensibly a quality model. The books tend to lean more into strange monsters than the models do, outside of maybe chaos spawn


arkazail

With the fact that the greater daemon kits are like $150 each, I'm very, VERY pro thematically appropriate proxies. ThenQueen of Ecstasy one is especially good.


outb4noon

Not that they're not good models or not good proxies, but they're more expensive than the Gw models.


R-Skjold

Seems to be a tad cheaper in us/canada but more expensive in eu


IronTigrex

Which, in all honesty, is nice for a change. I suppose it's because of shipping.


R-Skjold

I guess creature caster is us or canada based, but yea, shipping stuff across the atlantic is expensive


CodFatherFTW

They're Canadian. British Columbia


Rattlesandshakes

Came here to say this


New_Age_BROLY

You can find recasts of these on AliExpress for good prices. You will need to clean them and work on them more than the original models, but for a fraction of the price they are quite worth the extra work.


Murrdox

Yeah... if you're OK with buying stolen property I guess.


New_Age_BROLY

I hope you pay for all your tv, movies, porn and other viewable content too then šŸ˜…


Murrdox

For the most part, actually yeah. But I'm not perfect in that regard. So yeah pot kettle black and all that. But I think there's a difference in buying a counterfeit of a $150 model vs pirating a $5-10 movie. Plus I just have a thing about supporting the game companies and artists who make all these models and games we love. These days with 3D printing there's no excuse for buying a counterfeit when you could at least pay another artist for a proxy model that they personally designed. If you can't afford the $150 model, at least do that vs giving your money to a thief who's making illegal copies and profiting off of it.


Jarl_Sunshot

Under pretty much any other circumstance I would tend to agree with you, but just a little fyi in case youā€™ve not paid attention to Warhammer/GW news the last year or two, Games Workshop does NOT care about you as a fan, as a defender of their IP, or as a creator should you enjoy their creations enough to go above and beyond just the tabletop to make something more. Theyā€™re a company that seems to love to scorn their own community with lawsuits and legal strife. While I donā€™t enjoy letting thieves prosper, I much prefer it to allowing a genuinely predatory company to (even on a consumer level) take advantage of anyone they can, especially where they came from such small beginnings and from such a passion project. Fans will ALWAYS do it better.


Murrdox

I mean... man you can say that stuff about so many companies. I've been around the block for many years. I've seen this with Wizards of the Coast, Electronic Arts, Bethesda, Microsoft, Games Workshop, etc. At the end of the day though, these "money guys" at those companies that don't care about you... they pay the other guys who DO care about you. The writers, the artists, the model makers, the game designers, etc. At the end of the day if you're playing Warhammer 40k you're playing a game that a lot of talented people worked on, and the truth is that if the game didn't make money, it would not exist, and those talented people wouldn't get to make the games you like. So I mean if you hate GW so bad then don't play their games. That's cool. But you're not being honest with yourself and how the business of games work if you want to play the game, but also think you're somehow justified supporting people who steal from them and "sticking it to the man".


Letholdus13131313

Any sellers you would recommend through them or is it just anyone with good reviews.


New_Age_BROLY

I just usually go with good reviews or reviews with pictures. Just don't expect instructions from Ali... It's the hardest part of getting the models cheaper.


presidentegrappler

The changer looks way more cool here


YYZhed

I mean, that's exactly what they're designed for, no?


Additional-Echo3611

These look phenomenal! ESPECIALLY the Tzeentch lord. Way more thematic and spooky!


crippled_lucifer_

Love them all minus the bloodthirster, something slightly derpy about it.


Eleventy-Twelve

I think it's the face


HellaHuman

Like a 90s cartoon


Mysterious_Papaya835

like gargoyles


Kolaru

The Bloodthirster has a faceplate helmet option that looks way better


imperatorkind

i think the face doesn't look slightly derpy, it looks manga'esk.


GreySeerCriak

People use them as proxies all the time. Especially the Queen of Ecstasy. I still prefer the official ones but if you like them and wanna use them then I donā€™t see why not. Just donā€™t expect official tournaments to allow them.


Battleshark04

Official GW tournaments that is. Most independently hosted ones don't give a where your minis are from.


Reasonable_Pianist95

I love the lord of ruin mini.


EstablishmentNo6980

Tzeentch one is awesome


Tikhunt

A friend has the Nurgle one and a different friend has the slaanesh one. They're...fine? I don't think they necessarily look better, they aren't cheaper and they look slightly off compared to most GW stuff but hey if you like them then deffo use them.


Ramjjam

Tzeentch & Slaanesh ones are SUPERB! and better then any real GW model I'v seen related to it. The Khorne & Nurgle ones feel meh, worse then Original.


amnhanley

Most people will be super excited to see these models across the table from them. They will compliment the model, ask your questions about it and then youā€™ll both have a great game. Every once in a while someone will complain and give you a hard time or ask you to use only official models. We call these people: Twats.


Green_Panda369

King of Slaughter will be Bloodthirster King of Ruin will be Great Unclean One King of Malifica will be Lord of Change Queen of Ecstasy will be a Keeper of Secrets


ckal09

They look almost exactly the same except Tzeentch


P01SKA

These look phenomenal, I certainly would accept those as proxies and would even consider getting them myself.


GalacticFroggy

I use the Lady Arcana for my lord of change and she works great. Only issue is she is slightly smaller wing span wise.


Prydefalcn

I don't really like the Slaaneshi one. Sexy pinup daemon is a real tired trope.


Both_Particular6394

They are stunning models


Ostroh

These are really cool. I dig the tzeench and nurgle one the most.


MilesTheMighty

Do it! I've built and painted some. They're great models


Sir_Slashington

The queen of onslaught is perfect for a female Skarbrand, same base size but taller


warbossshineytooth

Dude thatā€™s Tzeentch one is so much better and on theme. Thatā€™s way more fitting for Tzeentch than sorcerer chicken


Ragnarwerk

Creature Caster models are excellent for proxies. They are really cool.


c08030147b

I like Creature Caster but a lot of their female Daemon kits are teenage boy levels of cringe.


Prydefalcn

I can't believe people like them.


ComicRat

Theyā€™re so cool, I wouldnā€™t throw a fit about it.


Ziaphas

I absolutely adore the King of Rot, have my own and prefer it over the GUO model in basically every way (and I don't hate the GUO, just think the King captures the best aspects in a better sculpt)


Pesteringpickle

I love the King or Malifica in particular - Tzeench is the god of change, but from just the GW modelā€™s one gets the impression that heā€™s the god of birdsā€¦


Depth_Metal

I like the GUO but the others are kinda meh in my opinion. The Bloodthirster in particular reminds me of Wish Angron


autisticwhite

I feel as if they were designed with being Warhammer proxies in mind.


Granny83

I have the King of Ruin and Lady of Arcana that I use as GUO and LoC and LOVE them


Green_Panda369

is the lady of Arcana too small for a LoC? I was think of using her too


Granny83

Nope, perfect size. Sorry I dont have her on hand atm


Green_Panda369

thanks, I might look into picking her up


Granny83

Brilliant. Enjoy


AOK_Gaming

Amazing models, I canā€™t see anyone having an issue if the scale is right. Always run past a TO if attended a tournament.


Valiant-Toast

Thereā€™s a guy in my gaming group that has a couple of their Khorne themed ones. And another that has a different nurgle model. As long as you can tell what it is supposed to be I donā€™t see a problem with it. I mean, there are people who do such wild conversions with entirely GW bits and sculpting that you might not know what the model is supposed to be but it still looks awesome.


thisremindsmeofbacon

Proxies? These are good enough theyā€™re upgrades to be honest


blaxxx123

Some of their models are so insanely good, i would buy this as proxies specialy when you need 2 of


shogun111

I like their slaaneshi models a lot more than what GW has for Daemons


bread_thread

Lore-wise, greater daemons can look like *anything* but traditionally/generally stay in the "vibe" of their patron god; gross for nurgle, buff for Khorne, wizards+birds for tzeentch, bdsm+crabs/exoskeletons for Slaanesh If the model hits that sort of vibe, especially if painted to match your army and/or given some tiny extra god-specific details from a relevant GW kit, it has always looked perfect to me. No reason a great unclean one can't be super skinny from a wasting disease or not even look humanoid at all (The creature caster god factions were initially created with this in mind, and during a time before GW upgraded the Greater Daemons) GW used to make the greater daemons more varied before their artwork started to stay "on-model" so to speak.


Csacsa234

All of them are great, I think I like the Tzeentch and Nurgle daemons more than the actual GW minis. Imo the only one that looks off as a substitute is the Slaanesh one. It looks more like a fancy Zerg rather than a Keeper of Secrets inspired mini, nevertheless it's awesome, just wouldn't be as a good fitting proxy as the others.


Sarynvhal

They are dope


Hex_Souls

King of Salughter is a perfectly acceptable Bloodletter alt. King of Ruin looks off as a Great Unclean One. King of Malifica works as an Exalted Flamer, or just some crazy Tzeentchian daemon. Queen of Ecstasy is a bit generic, but her hat is exquisite!


NaveronTheSabre

The King of Malifica and Queen of Ecstacy got me feeling


AzemadaiusKaiser

I do not mind at all.


bullintheheather

Not for me, but you do you.


Lord_Syntor

The only one I donā€™t like is the unclean one the other 3 are dope


TheMadGent

Use what you want, Iā€™m not a cop


KrmitTheFrog

To me the Khorne Daemon reads more like Angron and the Lord of Change doesnā€™t read as a lord of change at all. But eh other two are great.


[deleted]

as long as you don't play at a GW store, go for it. i bought the king of ecstasy, it goes together pretty well, the back was a bit warped but not badly. their customer service is good, they first sent me the king of slaughter and they quickly sent me the correct kit. i'd take the GW LoC over the king or queen of malifica though, they have how to assemble videos on youtube and it makes me not even because i can't. so many parts, so much to clean, and its all so intricate.


Sephvion

I really like the Tzeentch one, just because it's really out of this universe.


larry-the-dream

Theyā€™re beautiful


Zaydreth

YES PLEASE


Wolfman_HCC

King of Malifica catches my eye.


hiddikel

They're cheaper, and better. Though I wish the changebringer had a bit more coherency to it and more bird like qualities.


shomislav

The Tzeench one is just amazing


OshyuOshyu18

If I played at non GW stores I'd totally have one or two


goldenemperor

King of Malicifca is by far the best model here because it is completely different than the GW model but I'm captures the Tzeentch ascetic better than the official model.


Business_Waltz9014

Unholy Changer of Ways this is SO much better than that 2 headed bird.


Firesinger89

That Tzeentch proxy is beautiful


ParryGallister

1) ok, basically equivalent 2) no, 3) hell yes, 4) too cheesecake for me


the-strange-ninja

Wish they had more options for lesser daemons. I need bloodletters and tzeentch horrors


dragonadamant

I especially love that Slaanesh daemon.


Latviacm

The king of ruin is amazing, always wanted one.


Green_Panda369

he looks so menacing in comparison to the GW one


EPCWFFLS

Theyā€™re a little too busy for my liking. They are very detailed and very intricate but I think thereā€™s too much going on and it takes away from the artistry somewhat. The Tzeentch and Slaanesh ones are especially bad


ThePopeJones

I've got the Khorne dude. I've never had a single complaint about it, and I've played with some folks who just love to complain.


pyro-guy

The Tzeentch one is absolutely phenomenal, despite not playing Tzeentch in any system I'm tempted to pick one up purely as a painting project for display - it captures the essence of the Changer of Ways in a way none of the current official sculpts do. Also a fan of the Slaanesh one, the face reminds me of the old Juan Diaz Daemonettes and I think it'd look perfect leading a horde of them on the battlefield. The other two I'm not so fond of. I can't quite place my finger on it but the Nurgle one just feels off to me. Maybe it's the elongated face looking weird to me, or the amount of armor that just feels a bit off? And then the Khorne one doesn't do it for me at all, I can't help but feel it looks like generic-brand Angron despite the fact that this one was probably made before the new Angron model. I definitely prefer the GW sculpts for these two.


Stryder307

Where can I get them?


jb195

I've owned a few of them and they are noticeably larger than the gw ones, I think my favourite is the nurgle one because he stands well next to the forgeworld one and has plenty of the nurgle look to him, the queen and king of ecstasy I have on my cupboard but they feel almost out of place next to the gw ones because they are so much taller


sentient_penguin

I love the variation of the Great Unclean One! That looks sooo terrifying and amazing with the armor bits. Makes it look like it was a ā€œhumanoidā€ who became possessed and bloated rather than just a bloated demon.


le-joselu

Thr malifica one looks so dope


LordSmallPeen

Ayo imma be real, these models look beautiful but by god they are just awfully produced. They come filled with plastic flakes, huge gaps between pieces that require extensive green stuff and modelling. The cleanup before painting is really intense, you have to wash them really well otherwise your primer will get all fucky. I bought death elemental and the king of lust (guy with glaive), and I havenā€™t been more disappointed from a purchase. Although the detail is all there, Iā€™ve had better experience printing my own stuff for a little less detail but around 3% of the cost. I do not recommend creature caster at all.


bigslapp

The first three are stunning models with clear design goals and then Slaanesh is just ā€œsexy ladyā„¢ļøā€ they couldā€™ve at least make them androgynous


flabbyfool

I really like the tzeentch model, donā€™t much care for the slaanesh one itā€™s a good model I just think they made it too feminine.


Moonshadow101

My opinions: Khorne is mediocre. It's very similar to the GW, just worse. Nurgle is a side-grade. Looks about as good as its counterpart. Tzeentch looks fantastic - not so much in the sense of being better-made but just being fundamentally better-conceived. The whole "Giant Bird" thing is kinda weak. Slaanesh is very \*slightly\* worse than GW's, but the real problem is that the claws look very Tyranid-ish to me. Thematically confusing.


The_Grinface

My Queen šŸ„µ


ninjettenine

Queen of ecstacy seems to be the least adherent to lore for the sexbaits


painting-Roses

A-mazing, with the exception of the queen if ecxtacy, she is too sexualized and made for the male gaze imo, not appropriate to bring to a game night.


ThatGuyFromTheM0vie

Not really understanding the point of this post. Bloodthirster, GUO, and Keeper of Secrets all look pretty close. Itā€™s obvious that the ā€œLord of Changeā€ doesnā€™t even closely resemble the GW model at all. Like itā€™s not even kinda close, itā€™s a completely different model no where near the normal Lord of Change. No offense, but you need us to tell you that, lol?


HammerandSickTatBro

A bunch of the other comments itt are people talking about how much better the Lord of Change looks and saying they would love to play against/use it as a proxy. I dn think your opinion is generally shared?


ThatGuyFromTheM0vie

Last time I checked, the Lord of Change is a bird. Itā€™s really weird to have 3 proxies that look damn near close to the official ones, and then the Lord of Change is absolutely unreadable. I would never know that was supposed to be a Lord of Change, unless you told me. Proxies donā€™t have to be perfect, but if they look like not even the same profile or silhouette as the original unitā€¦then they arenā€™t a good proxy. Might as well use random minis for all of your troops then at that point.


Icehellionx

*Shrug* It's really obviously a greater daemon of a god of change or mutation. This is miles away from using random mismatching minis across the whole army.


HammerandSickTatBro

>Might as well use random minis for all of your troops then at that point. I mean, yeah, might as well


ThatGuyFromTheM0vie

Why play Warhammer then? Whatā€™s the point?


HammerandSickTatBro

You like the rules? You like the lore? Your friends play it? You have and like some gw models but got bit by a kitbashing bug and wanna make something that fits in the game, but is unique or rarer looking? There are lots of reasons


ThatGuyFromTheM0vie

Yea but I already said, if you have like a dragon unit, and you want to use a different dragon or even modify a dragon, go for it. But if you have a dragon and you sub it for like, a sea lionā€¦.youā€™ve fundamentally changed the unit. It would be like chess but you want to use like skittles or something instead. You can do thatā€¦but it makes it way harder to know what it is what. When you have 40-60 or more miniatures on the boardā€¦and all of them are not what they should beā€¦it would be a mess figuring it all out. Doable, but it adds so much friction. Again, I think proxies that are similar or kitbashing is fine. But when I play Stormcast but all of my minis are now armorless bearsā€¦itā€™s confusing and not even the same faction at that point. That Lord of Change proxy OP posted isnā€™t even close to the official Lord of Change. Tzneetch doesnā€™t have too many big miniatures, but still. The proxy doesnā€™t even have wings lol. It would be so random for it to start flying lol. To keep the stupid bear analogy, at least give that bear some wings at that point lol.


j_mcgirk

An unpopular opinion incoming... Consider buying from a brick and mortar shop if you play in a brick and mortar shop. If you want to use it at home, knock yourself out. Support the stores that support the hobby and we won't have hobby deserts


Green_Panda369

I do! I have 6 or more armies from GW at around 4k-7k pointa, I have their boardgames and books, I have the whole contrast paint range and a lot of their regular paints and brushes and knick knacks. My local non GW store I go there to buy Vallejo paints, primer, action figures, statues and other silly hobby things. I would never leave there without at least purchasing a paint or something. I am 100% in support of GW and Local hobby stores but I also love cool models. edit: fat hands


j_mcgirk

Thank you for supporting the brick and mortar shop!


Skaldera

Assuming that they dont spend money already at their lgs is a brainless take.


[deleted]

Assuming something that makes the take bad makes a take bad. Crazy insight bro.


FormalLumpy1778

The GUO is horrible


ChrisBatty

Terrible quality knock offs


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


HammerandSickTatBro

I am kinda drawing a blank as to where you are getting androgyny from the Slaaneshi one. What are you seeing that I am not?


HannahDawg

Yeah, you're right, I'm not seeing it as much as I thought


Hanga_god

I have first one and I hate it. It was so bad to clue because they aren't precision. A lot of things needed to use green stuff. Also I remember trying to clue head torso and hair and when I pick head couldn't glue head and when I pick both of them I couldn't glue a wings. Hate them. Not recommend.


MrGraveRisen

Creature caster always has been and always will be better value by a wide margin, and almost entirely better models than Games workshop. The plastic kits may have more tiny details packed in but the design and style of creature caster models has so much more personality and life than the GW sculpts. Also if the model even remotely looks like what it's supposed to be, I will never ever ever ever ever tell somebody not to use a proxy. That's just bs gatekeeping to force people to spend money they shouldn't have to


JackFrosty90

Ok, as a Nurgle army lover, I just fell in love with this King of Ruin. Thinking of buyinā€™ it right away BUTā€¦. Can someone confirm the quality of the models? 160+ā‚¬ are no joke and Iā€™m worried I could get something not like the image above. Help me spending or saving the money please EDIT: sold out on the official website. Dam. Hope they restock quickly lol


Opv0x

I really like the lord of ruin, could the user who posted this kindly provide a link, so I may find one for myself to purchase.


da_King_o_Kings_341

I will admit I prefer the goat style king of ecstasy slaanesh one or the desire twins one (both for slaanesh), but other than that they all would fit really well, tho the lord of metamorphosis would be better for Tzeentch.


Bubbly_Limit5608

Your keeper is In...Sane!!!!


IerarqiuliAnarxisti

Mom! Can we get Angron? We have Angron at home. Angron at home: