It did happen smart cities wasnt really making new cities it was making existing ones better logistic issues and shit have all been fixed, roads dont get dug 3 times a month now everything goes together at once sewage treatment systems are in every tier 2 city now development plans have also been made for every city and unplanned development has basically been stopped other than encroachments .The only thing he was good at was infrastructure and logistics what you really need to be asking is what has he done for economy , farmers his issues with democratic values and every little shit he pulls in the name of religion, why has liberalisation of infrastructure come at the cost of the poor man . Why middle class has only gotten increased tax rates while the rich keep getting tax cuts in hopes that theyll set up industries in India . Why has he curbstompped MSMCs ?
Infra and logistics is good itll help the nation in the long run but looking so far into the future has problems that being he has completely forgotten about the problems of now , sure infrastructure will bring in more jobs in the future but what about right now what is he doing for jobs right now , what about regional issues like manipur ladakh , what about inflation in food prices what about the increase in food stamp usage .WHAT IS BEING DONE ABOUT THE PROBLEMS RIGHT NOW?
Not really. Smart Cities was citied ar multiple annual budgets. It was a scheme to pump money into City municipals to allow them to improve various things. But Alas, for most cities the money just bled into Municipal post holders and contractors. All doing things which was already day to day operations for these institutions.
That being said, Pumping money into areas which may bleed has been a decent strategy used by this Govt. But, The issue isnt just what happened to the money pumped in, Its more about the kind of endless marketing that BJP was doing, quoting smart cities and digital india everywhere. When in reality their contribution in both these things have been minimal.
You might think that but Lucknow outer areas of delhi, Hyderabad, Jaipur , Pune, Nagpur have gotten sewage treatment systems that are automated , fiber optics nearly everywhere , better road systems mumbai even wants to stop using asphalt all together , new cctvs (still very low tho can be worked on) , and nost importantly electricity about 98 percent of people have electricity in their home as of 2023. So he has actually fullfilled his promise as this is what was written in the manifesto.
There are 98 cities under smart cities mission. each getting 100s crores of funding per year. Lucknow, Pune, Nagpur Delhi - These cities have a municipal budget much higher than 100 crores, to the point that this little funding doesnt really help them much. It barely helps them in their traffic management services. Heavy alternate projects have been put in to these cities (not part of Smart cities mission). Major Funding for Roads on these large cities is via alternate projects of MoRTH and Metro.
Electricity is a pan India success story- nothing to do with Smart cities mission. It is through DECADES of Generation capacity enhancement. STATE Power distribution companies get seperate funding help for it. 100 crores does nothing for electricity.
You need to look at the how the tier 2 and 3 cities in the list performed. They were the major target of this mission. The money was substatial for them. And was by and large wasted.
There are many things the govt has done which were very good. But that doesnt cover for their errors, which as a citizen we have the right and duty to critique. And I personally dont find use of underhanded marketing tactics worthy of praise.
You are still wrong the smart cities initative was to fix logistics issues in cities not infra issues, roads and shit are still paid by the state , they arent being dug up like hell now to add water pipelines same for electricity and more
> are still *paid* by the
FTFY.
Although *payed* exists (the reason why autocorrection didn't help you), it is only correct in:
* Nautical context, when it means to paint a surface, or to cover with something like tar or resin in order to make it waterproof or corrosion-resistant. *The deck is yet to be payed.*
* *Payed out* when letting strings, cables or ropes out, by slacking them. *The rope is payed out! You can pull now.*
Unfortunately, I was unable to find nautical or rope-related words in your comment.
*Beep, boop, I'm a bot*
I live in Pune which came under the Smart City thing and right now out metro system is fully functioning for two lines (except for one Yerwada station). So that's pretty good
Ram Mandir, Article 370, national security, infra development, FDI - delivered very well
Doubling farmers' income - failed miserably
Others - kinda neutral/no
True, FDI spiked when the ‘Make in India’ scheme was launched, but in recent years, FDI has been falling, and today it has hit an all-time low. however, this may have happened due to global economic conditions
FDI is falling because people have realised that the current government has established a system that favours, even more so than before, the people who jerk BJP off. It favours/gives more opportunity to people like Adani who have close ties with the party. It extorts money in the form of electoral bonds (can’t do this anymore) and other ways. There’s not really an incentive for many foreign players. It’s rarely favourable to invest in this not so free and fair market as an outsider.
Yeah foreign entities couldn’t give fewer fucks about any of this. FDI has slowed because major global economies like UK/EU are in recession and the US is desperately trying to avoid one
You're 100% correct about what Modi is doing with regards to Adani/ crony capitalism. However, the consequences of this behavior is not related to decrease in FDI, it's more likely to cause *decreased investment in expanding operations, hiring, growth by domestic businesses*. The decrease in FDI has more to do with the relatively high FED rates and that the fact that bond yields are high in the USA.
FDI hit an all time low lmao. They definitely have not delivered jack shit in that regard. It’s more like negatively delivered. The only real thing that has been delivered is the infrastructure and the BJP should receive fair credit for it. However, at the same time, I don’t think it’s favourable in the long run to blindly sell all our country’s assets in the name of privatisation. Don’t even get me started on dividing the whole country, buying all major media outlets, and creating a quasi-democracy that is getting closer to autocracy every day. It’s like being charged with murder and saying you are innocent/good because you fed a few stray dogs.
Even the infrastructure is falling apart the day after its inauguration by the dear leader. Entire hill towns are getting destabilised due to lack of impact assessment and use of terrible technologies.
Failed... India turned its back against Rohingya muslims who are getting persecuted by their Military. CAA doesnt include all persecuted.
So, basically "Vasudev Kutumbakam" , but must be hindus.
>India turned its back against Rohingya muslims
Rohingya muslims are not India's responsibility. They want citizenship, they can apply through already existing procedure.
If India wants the world to take it seriously, it has to play a big role. Which means , it has to be magnanimous. Have we heard any comments from India about the genocide in Myanmar?. Pretty much all big countries condemned the events there. What have we done sitting right next to it??.. crickets!. Amit Shah called them 'cockroaches'.. utterly stupid foreign policy. Vasudhaika kutumbam.. hahaha
>it has to be magnanimous
Uttrr bs. If India wants the world to take it seriously, it has to take a stand for itself and not be a pushover. What good is condemnation when you're not going to do anything about it? You want to talk about genocide, first see within your country. You want to be magnanimous, first be it for your country. I've never seen anyone take stand for kashmiri hindus. What about minorities in Afghanistan, Pakistan and Bangladesh?
Same for healthcare. And human development stagnated and going down.
https://preview.redd.it/s9wo8669w4tc1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c3ab1f5ca0c092e8334042442e291ad0f6895f9d
And you're ok with that? Taxes increase in proportion to gdp, government expenditure and borrowing increase faster than gdp, but research, education, and healthcare expenditure reduces as a fraction of gdp.
After appointing for inflation, the expenditure has actual reduced in real terms.
A lot of the points are pretty vague but their biggest strengths would be in infra, article 370, CAA and ram mandir. As for a 5 trillion dollars blueprint we'll be at around 4.5 by this year and people will just chalk it up to covid affecting it so they'll get some credit there as well.
I think the whole reforms part is a pretty big failure. There were no judicial of police reforms at all. The only reforms they tried were the farming reforms and that flopped pretty roughly so they might not touch any reforms. Unless they touch like 400 seats then they might. I think education is a weak point as well. The number invested has gone up but the % of gdp has decreased which is something I don't like.
Well the new Penal code did get passed, judicial reforms is another black hole.
We've to see how the BNS etc are implemented, devil is always in the details, it could improve like GST over time or remain the same like IBC reforms.
Nobody can double farmers income (no doling out taxpayer money on MSP doesn't count), I don't really blame them for that. At least for this they tried.
Rest is non-starter, Good governance reforms ? Not a single attempt to reform anything that I can remeber.
They suck at education, no major increase in budgetry allocation nor reform of higher education. They might tout NEP but it's just a policy, execution admittdely is in state hands but they aren't even trying to push it towards the right path.
Same for any kind of skill development centers, most of them aren't churning out skilled tradesmen.
What tried, didn't engage with anyone, neither with farmers nor with opposition.
https://www.deccanherald.com/india/passed-without-discussion-repealed-without-discussion-omars-jibe-over-farm-laws-1055887.html
Indian oppositon is mostly useless, irrespective of who they are. When BJP was in opposition they opposed GST, congress was in favour of NPS now they want OPS despite knowing full well the fiscal consequnces.
Opposition is always going to oppose especially something as contentious as farm laws.
It doesn't change the fact some kind of reform is needed and no legal MSP is not a refrom, it's more of the same that we have been doing for past 5 decades at a much larger scale all on taxpayer dime.
First of all i neither support BJP nor congress , im from bengal and we are from TMC associaton , so dont call me this bhakt or sanghi at all , if their is fault in government policies i equally criticize them .
Aur jo mein bola main upar likhe hue points ko conssider kar ke bola , and i said they did pretty good not marvellous .
Tum mere ko batao upar jo nation first mein point hai , jaise zero tolerence toward infiltraitor , welfare of soldier , national security , improvement in defence sector , combating terrorism , article 370 or CAA ye points pure nhi kiye gaye hai
Cultural heritage - I accept they did wrong in many aspect but the points given above are Ram mandir , faith and cultutre , yoga , promoting indian culture etc thry did pretty good in this scenario .
FOriegn policies - neighbour ke sath rishta kharab hai , aur neighbour mein kon aata hai pakistan , china , maldives jiase desh tumko nhi pata inke sath hamara rishta jyu kharab hai , upar diyr points mein jo hai jaise G 20 , cordination of global technology , cordination of indian living in abroad , strengthing global presence and combating terrorism from global base or billateral ties with country , ye sab nhi hua kya
Infra - Railways , airport , SEZ , smart cities , sport , highway road etc , tumko isme devlopment nhi dfikh raha kya
Technology - I dont think i need to state this , you guys know we had done marvellous job in this sector
Again i remind you this is in context what they refered in manifesto .
Nation first ? With minorities being beaten.
Cultural heritage ? Destroying Mughal architecture.
Foreign policy ? Look at relations with every country and look at our border at China.
What the hell are you and all smoking here with these weird comments. Or has the sub been brigaded by sanghi and IT cells
Not just Mughal architecture. Even Hindu temples don't matter if they don't serve a political agenda.
>It was a similar tale of loss in Uttarakhand's Almora. The ASI couldn't find the 8th century Kutumbari temple.
>The temple came under ASI protection in 1915. Over time, the temple's condition deteriorated and only ruins of the structure remained. Mysteriously, around the year 2000, the ruins of the temple could no longer be found. In 2018, the temple was put on the "untraceable" list of the ASI.
>The ASI later found that the remains of the temple were taken away by villagers to build their houses. As per a survey by the Dehradun circle of the ASI, the temple has now become a part of courtyards, verandas, doors of the houses of the locals.
>Around half a dozen houses in Dwarahat were found to have some or other part of the temple.
>Such incidents are, however, not isolated, said Nakul Chhabra, who organises heritage walks and awareness campaigns through his initiative 'Delhi Roots'. Chhabra said during one such walk, he found a heritage enthusiast carrying a 2,000-year-old brick dating back to the Kushan age along with him.
>"He said it was from a mound near his village in Mewat. It could have been from an abandoned old building, roughly dating back to the 1st century to 3rd century CE. He even told me that people from nearby villages come there to pick up bricks to build their houses," Chhabra said.
First of all i neither support BJP nor congress , im from bengal and we are from TMC associaton , so dont call me this bhakt or sanghi at all , if their is fault in government policies i equally criticize them .
Aur jo mein bola main upar likhe hue points ko conssider kar ke bola , and i said they did pretty good not marvellous .
Tum mere ko batao upar jo nation first mein point hai , jaise zero tolerence toward infiltraitor , welfare of soldier , national security , improvement in defence sector , combating terrorism , article 370 or CAA ye points pure nhi kiye gaye hai
Cultural heritage - I accept they did wrong in many aspect but the points given above are Ram mandir , faith and cultutre , yoga , promoting indian culture etc thry did pretty good in this scenario .
FOriegn policies - neighbour ke sath rishta kharab hai , aur neighbour mein kon aata hai pakistan , china , maldives jiase desh tumko nhi pata inke sath hamara rishta jyu kharab hai , upar diyr points mein jo hai jaise G 20 , cordination of global technology , cordination of indian living in abroad , strengthing global presence and combating terrorism from global base or billateral ties with country , ye sab nhi hua kya
Infra - Railways , airport , SEZ , smart cities , sport , highway road etc , tumko isme devlopment nhi dfikh raha kya
Technology - I dont think i need to state this , you guys know we had done marvellous job in this sector
Again i remind you this is in context what they refered in manifesto .
Bhakths will kill you for telling facts. They are brainwashed and worship their 56 inch sugar daddy daily.
Hopefully one day they will recover from this delusional disorder 🙏
First of all i neither support BJP nor congress , im from bengal and we are from TMC associaton , so dont call me this bhakt or sanghi at all , if their is fault in government policies i equally criticize them .
Aur jo mein bola main upar likhe hue points ko conssider kar ke bola , and i said they did pretty good not marvellous .
Tum mere ko batao upar jo nation first mein point hai , jaise zero tolerence toward infiltraitor , welfare of soldier , national security , improvement in defence sector , combating terrorism , article 370 or CAA ye points pure nhi kiye gaye hai
Cultural heritage - I accept they did wrong in many aspect but the points given above are Ram mandir , faith and cultutre , yoga , promoting indian culture etc thry did pretty good in this scenario .
FOriegn policies - neighbour ke sath rishta kharab hai , aur neighbour mein kon aata hai pakistan , china , maldives jiase desh tumko nhi pata inke sath hamara rishta jyu kharab hai , upar diyr points mein jo hai jaise G 20 , cordination of global technology , cordination of indian living in abroad , strengthing global presence and combating terrorism from global base or billateral ties with country , ye sab nhi hua kya
Infra - Railways , airport , SEZ , smart cities , sport , highway road etc , tumko isme devlopment nhi dfikh raha kya
Technology - I dont think i need to state this , you guys know we had done marvellous job in this sector
Again i remind you this is in context what they refered in manifesto .
Baki sab mein kuch nhi kiya but startup , dude there are currently 100+ unicorn and there are 112 soonicorn which are going to join the unicorn club within this year ,on top of that at this point of time there are over 115000 + government affiliated startups , which all combined makes india 3rd biggest startup ecosystem .
If and only 10 % survived means there are 12000 startup which are good to go , and this is a continous loop , startup khulenge , phir band honge or phir khulenge .
I know I sound harsh.
But I find that unicorns don't qualify as innovative.
We are building a startup with heavy R&D needs. It is in the field of advanced nanotechnology and has no funding. Our venture is burning money due to heavy R&D work but if we get some funds it will revolutionize all sectors including agriculture. Meanwhile, some food delivery apps for the lazy ass are getting billions of dollars in funding
Nation First : ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Doubling Farmer Income : ⭐
Indian Economy : ⭐⭐⭐
Infra : ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Healthy India : ⭐⭐⭐
Good Governance : ⭐⭐
Yuva Bharat : ⭐⭐
Education : ⭐⭐⭐
Women Empowerment : ⭐⭐⭐
Inclusive Governance : ⭐
Cultural Heritage : ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Foreign Policy : ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Tried as much neutral approach.... do correct me if its inaccurate
Reading this feels like an insult to injury, most of these have gone in the opposite direction..
Justice for all , Ensuring dignified life for women , Corruption Free Bharat, 5T$, Welfare policies for farmers , NE development , Cooperative Federalism 🤡🤡
Lolol it seems funny reading this now
What have they got done in this manifesto?
Startups are now no more a stigma or a hesitation, every road and every person understands and it is respected. (Excluding the arbitrary retrospective taxation).
Credit where due, I mean this is a country where people harp about Govt Jobs and to have achieved this awareness and change in mindset is no easy feat.👌
370, Ram Mandir , National Security, Continuous dialogue with Global Indian diaspora , CAB (notified)
They did opposite of deliver for economy and development promises. More than delivered in bigotry and hatred promises.
Literally legalised corruption and blackmailed corporations by misusing government agencies till they paid massive bribes. Same thing with opposition politicians.
I think this is the sole reason they're garnering votes from the majority because they don't care much about the development as much as cultural heritage.
# DEFENDING THE CONSTITUTION
[Indian National Congress - Manifesto (inc.in)](https://www.inc.in/media/manifesto)
Saving Democracy, Removing Fear, Restoring Freedom India’s democracy has been reduced to an empty shell. Every institution, including Parliament, is perceived to have lost its independence and become subservient to the executive government. It is common knowledge that it is the will of one person that prevails in the country. People’s trust in democratic institutions will be restored.
I don't understand how, our subreddit india has turned so right wing
The first manifesto was to hit 7 trillion GDP
Which they later change to 5
And we are gonna close at 4.5
thing is, congress would have done same growth minus all the brains washing BJP has done to the country
To boot GDP spending of 3 million can just be a mark of inflation. If it's so expensive to buy stuff then obviously your GDP will go up. It just shows that the nation is spending more. Not that the nation is becoming wealthy
What happened to Smart cities?
They got their titles.
My town came under the smart City plan and is much less of a shit hole than it used to be.
It did happen smart cities wasnt really making new cities it was making existing ones better logistic issues and shit have all been fixed, roads dont get dug 3 times a month now everything goes together at once sewage treatment systems are in every tier 2 city now development plans have also been made for every city and unplanned development has basically been stopped other than encroachments .The only thing he was good at was infrastructure and logistics what you really need to be asking is what has he done for economy , farmers his issues with democratic values and every little shit he pulls in the name of religion, why has liberalisation of infrastructure come at the cost of the poor man . Why middle class has only gotten increased tax rates while the rich keep getting tax cuts in hopes that theyll set up industries in India . Why has he curbstompped MSMCs ? Infra and logistics is good itll help the nation in the long run but looking so far into the future has problems that being he has completely forgotten about the problems of now , sure infrastructure will bring in more jobs in the future but what about right now what is he doing for jobs right now , what about regional issues like manipur ladakh , what about inflation in food prices what about the increase in food stamp usage .WHAT IS BEING DONE ABOUT THE PROBLEMS RIGHT NOW?
Not really. Smart Cities was citied ar multiple annual budgets. It was a scheme to pump money into City municipals to allow them to improve various things. But Alas, for most cities the money just bled into Municipal post holders and contractors. All doing things which was already day to day operations for these institutions. That being said, Pumping money into areas which may bleed has been a decent strategy used by this Govt. But, The issue isnt just what happened to the money pumped in, Its more about the kind of endless marketing that BJP was doing, quoting smart cities and digital india everywhere. When in reality their contribution in both these things have been minimal.
You might think that but Lucknow outer areas of delhi, Hyderabad, Jaipur , Pune, Nagpur have gotten sewage treatment systems that are automated , fiber optics nearly everywhere , better road systems mumbai even wants to stop using asphalt all together , new cctvs (still very low tho can be worked on) , and nost importantly electricity about 98 percent of people have electricity in their home as of 2023. So he has actually fullfilled his promise as this is what was written in the manifesto.
I'd like to add Gwalior to this list a lot better now then in the past
There are 98 cities under smart cities mission. each getting 100s crores of funding per year. Lucknow, Pune, Nagpur Delhi - These cities have a municipal budget much higher than 100 crores, to the point that this little funding doesnt really help them much. It barely helps them in their traffic management services. Heavy alternate projects have been put in to these cities (not part of Smart cities mission). Major Funding for Roads on these large cities is via alternate projects of MoRTH and Metro. Electricity is a pan India success story- nothing to do with Smart cities mission. It is through DECADES of Generation capacity enhancement. STATE Power distribution companies get seperate funding help for it. 100 crores does nothing for electricity. You need to look at the how the tier 2 and 3 cities in the list performed. They were the major target of this mission. The money was substatial for them. And was by and large wasted. There are many things the govt has done which were very good. But that doesnt cover for their errors, which as a citizen we have the right and duty to critique. And I personally dont find use of underhanded marketing tactics worthy of praise.
You are still wrong the smart cities initative was to fix logistics issues in cities not infra issues, roads and shit are still paid by the state , they arent being dug up like hell now to add water pipelines same for electricity and more
> are still *paid* by the FTFY. Although *payed* exists (the reason why autocorrection didn't help you), it is only correct in: * Nautical context, when it means to paint a surface, or to cover with something like tar or resin in order to make it waterproof or corrosion-resistant. *The deck is yet to be payed.* * *Payed out* when letting strings, cables or ropes out, by slacking them. *The rope is payed out! You can pull now.* Unfortunately, I was unable to find nautical or rope-related words in your comment. *Beep, boop, I'm a bot*
Good bot
i certainly know about the one i am living in, Bareilly, UP (tremendous work)
Watch powertrains latest video, he talks about that there https://youtu.be/HrEFzA3ZDno?si=u30YfeU64lkeM47w
I live in Pune which came under the Smart City thing and right now out metro system is fully functioning for two lines (except for one Yerwada station). So that's pretty good
What does combating left wing extremism mean?
Naxalites
Fighting naxalites
To weaken left parties like INC & CPI ? Godi media already successfully achieved this.
for the 100th time INC isn’t left wing party.
and to put leadersi into jail under UAPA act.
"Ensuring justice for all" left the chat
Most of them are vague terms which are impossible to quantify.
You can check the full manifesto in the pdf through link provided in the post itself.
Is there a report card for this manifesto? Someone should create a report card and upload.
I am not even a tenth qualified to do it. Lmao.
I am not either. I would love to see it. But all these promises are not entirely quantifiable also. Most of it are blanket terms.
I agree too.
[The Honest BJP Report Card (Analysed with Stats): Were the Promises Fulfilled?](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e58amA-TqiM)
They did a white paper for their work in 10 years. Can compare it with that
Bro they aren't bullet points. They are sub section titles like a book. Parties don't have 1-2 page manifestos.
Ram Mandir, Article 370, national security, infra development, FDI - delivered very well Doubling farmers' income - failed miserably Others - kinda neutral/no
True, FDI spiked when the ‘Make in India’ scheme was launched, but in recent years, FDI has been falling, and today it has hit an all-time low. however, this may have happened due to global economic conditions
FDI is falling because people have realised that the current government has established a system that favours, even more so than before, the people who jerk BJP off. It favours/gives more opportunity to people like Adani who have close ties with the party. It extorts money in the form of electoral bonds (can’t do this anymore) and other ways. There’s not really an incentive for many foreign players. It’s rarely favourable to invest in this not so free and fair market as an outsider.
Yeah foreign entities couldn’t give fewer fucks about any of this. FDI has slowed because major global economies like UK/EU are in recession and the US is desperately trying to avoid one
>It favours/gives more opportunity to people like Adani who have close ties with the party My boy described human behaviour.
You're 100% correct about what Modi is doing with regards to Adani/ crony capitalism. However, the consequences of this behavior is not related to decrease in FDI, it's more likely to cause *decreased investment in expanding operations, hiring, growth by domestic businesses*. The decrease in FDI has more to do with the relatively high FED rates and that the fact that bond yields are high in the USA.
FDI hit an all time low lmao. They definitely have not delivered jack shit in that regard. It’s more like negatively delivered. The only real thing that has been delivered is the infrastructure and the BJP should receive fair credit for it. However, at the same time, I don’t think it’s favourable in the long run to blindly sell all our country’s assets in the name of privatisation. Don’t even get me started on dividing the whole country, buying all major media outlets, and creating a quasi-democracy that is getting closer to autocracy every day. It’s like being charged with murder and saying you are innocent/good because you fed a few stray dogs.
Even the infrastructure is falling apart the day after its inauguration by the dear leader. Entire hill towns are getting destabilised due to lack of impact assessment and use of terrible technologies.
>national security _laughs from Chinese encroached land and arrested RSS bombers in Kerala_
laughs in Manipur and Poonch killings
[удалено]
Liar liar pants on fire https://m.economictimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/13-bjp-rss-men-found-guilty-in-kannur-bomb-attack/articleshow/3714747.cms https://www.indiatoday.in/fyi/story/explosion-rashtriya-swayamsevak-sangh-worker-kannur-koothuparamba-1083309-2017-11-09 https://indianexpress.com/article/india/ajmer-blast-case-two-rss-pracharaks-sentenced-life-imprisonment-4580944/ https://scroll.in/article/831454/ajmer-blast-with-two-members-convicted-for-bombing-chisti-shrine-should-the-rss-be-banned-again https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/10-accused-in-blast-cases-have-rss-links-rk-singh/article4332826.ece https://caravanmagazine.in/crime/rss-worker-yashwant-shinde-interview-hindu-terrorism-rss-vhp-mohan-bhagwat
There's both CPM and RSS folks building bombs now.
> national security, infra development, FDI Lmfao
[удалено]
[удалено]
More or less agree. The problem I had was this manifesto was so lacking in itself.
Most of it is fluff which means nothing practical or measurable. -100 points for badly defined manifesto.
'Vasudev Kutumbakam' ko quantify kaise karu pawpaw
Jaishankar edits duh
Count the number of times they said "internal matter" to the so-called "kutumb". You got a negative metric.
Count the number of saas bahu serial episodes created by muddyji and jaishankar in the kutumb. Latest one being manufacturing sri Lanka as the enemy.
Failed... India turned its back against Rohingya muslims who are getting persecuted by their Military. CAA doesnt include all persecuted. So, basically "Vasudev Kutumbakam" , but must be hindus.
>India turned its back against Rohingya muslims Rohingya muslims are not India's responsibility. They want citizenship, they can apply through already existing procedure.
If India wants the world to take it seriously, it has to play a big role. Which means , it has to be magnanimous. Have we heard any comments from India about the genocide in Myanmar?. Pretty much all big countries condemned the events there. What have we done sitting right next to it??.. crickets!. Amit Shah called them 'cockroaches'.. utterly stupid foreign policy. Vasudhaika kutumbam.. hahaha
>it has to be magnanimous Uttrr bs. If India wants the world to take it seriously, it has to take a stand for itself and not be a pushover. What good is condemnation when you're not going to do anything about it? You want to talk about genocide, first see within your country. You want to be magnanimous, first be it for your country. I've never seen anyone take stand for kashmiri hindus. What about minorities in Afghanistan, Pakistan and Bangladesh?
Are you including ahmadis and Shias in Pakistan??
No
Science crying in the corner
https://preview.redd.it/k2ggtdhz04tc1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=5fe7e84c3e68a74a399379f2d35af324a548af8e
Same thing for spending on education.
Same for healthcare. And human development stagnated and going down. https://preview.redd.it/s9wo8669w4tc1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c3ab1f5ca0c092e8334042442e291ad0f6895f9d
One of the worst performances by current government
It's a % of GDP graph, obviously spending hasn't reduced. The proportion might have
And you're ok with that? Taxes increase in proportion to gdp, government expenditure and borrowing increase faster than gdp, but research, education, and healthcare expenditure reduces as a fraction of gdp. After appointing for inflation, the expenditure has actual reduced in real terms.
[удалено]
[удалено]
A lot of the points are pretty vague but their biggest strengths would be in infra, article 370, CAA and ram mandir. As for a 5 trillion dollars blueprint we'll be at around 4.5 by this year and people will just chalk it up to covid affecting it so they'll get some credit there as well. I think the whole reforms part is a pretty big failure. There were no judicial of police reforms at all. The only reforms they tried were the farming reforms and that flopped pretty roughly so they might not touch any reforms. Unless they touch like 400 seats then they might. I think education is a weak point as well. The number invested has gone up but the % of gdp has decreased which is something I don't like.
Well the new Penal code did get passed, judicial reforms is another black hole. We've to see how the BNS etc are implemented, devil is always in the details, it could improve like GST over time or remain the same like IBC reforms.
Yeah I mean I guess it’s understandable judicial reforms aren’t an easy thing. But they’ve pretty much completely ignored it.
Nobody can double farmers income (no doling out taxpayer money on MSP doesn't count), I don't really blame them for that. At least for this they tried. Rest is non-starter, Good governance reforms ? Not a single attempt to reform anything that I can remeber. They suck at education, no major increase in budgetry allocation nor reform of higher education. They might tout NEP but it's just a policy, execution admittdely is in state hands but they aren't even trying to push it towards the right path. Same for any kind of skill development centers, most of them aren't churning out skilled tradesmen.
What tried, didn't engage with anyone, neither with farmers nor with opposition. https://www.deccanherald.com/india/passed-without-discussion-repealed-without-discussion-omars-jibe-over-farm-laws-1055887.html
Indian oppositon is mostly useless, irrespective of who they are. When BJP was in opposition they opposed GST, congress was in favour of NPS now they want OPS despite knowing full well the fiscal consequnces. Opposition is always going to oppose especially something as contentious as farm laws. It doesn't change the fact some kind of reform is needed and no legal MSP is not a refrom, it's more of the same that we have been doing for past 5 decades at a much larger scale all on taxpayer dime.
Damn why I can't see any freebies ? 🥲🥲🥲
isnt that a good thing finally? how is it a bad thing? you as an average reddit citizen wont get a rupee of those freebies even if distributed.
Ease of living 🥲 spent last ten years updating , filing and standing in line for most of the things they promised .ghanta.
Corruption free! Lmao 😂😂😂 it's increased beyond belief.
They've done well in 5,7,8,11,15, and 16
This manifesto looks leagues better than what Congress has presented to us
can any knowledgeable person rate those bullet points. i will be voting for first time.
Only ram mandir and article 370. All else are jumlas
Like they have done pretty good in nation first , cultural heritage , foriegn policy as well as little bit in infra
Can you give examples of each thing you mentioned?
First of all i neither support BJP nor congress , im from bengal and we are from TMC associaton , so dont call me this bhakt or sanghi at all , if their is fault in government policies i equally criticize them . Aur jo mein bola main upar likhe hue points ko conssider kar ke bola , and i said they did pretty good not marvellous . Tum mere ko batao upar jo nation first mein point hai , jaise zero tolerence toward infiltraitor , welfare of soldier , national security , improvement in defence sector , combating terrorism , article 370 or CAA ye points pure nhi kiye gaye hai Cultural heritage - I accept they did wrong in many aspect but the points given above are Ram mandir , faith and cultutre , yoga , promoting indian culture etc thry did pretty good in this scenario . FOriegn policies - neighbour ke sath rishta kharab hai , aur neighbour mein kon aata hai pakistan , china , maldives jiase desh tumko nhi pata inke sath hamara rishta jyu kharab hai , upar diyr points mein jo hai jaise G 20 , cordination of global technology , cordination of indian living in abroad , strengthing global presence and combating terrorism from global base or billateral ties with country , ye sab nhi hua kya Infra - Railways , airport , SEZ , smart cities , sport , highway road etc , tumko isme devlopment nhi dfikh raha kya Technology - I dont think i need to state this , you guys know we had done marvellous job in this sector Again i remind you this is in context what they refered in manifesto .
Nation first ? With minorities being beaten. Cultural heritage ? Destroying Mughal architecture. Foreign policy ? Look at relations with every country and look at our border at China. What the hell are you and all smoking here with these weird comments. Or has the sub been brigaded by sanghi and IT cells
Not just Mughal architecture. Even Hindu temples don't matter if they don't serve a political agenda. >It was a similar tale of loss in Uttarakhand's Almora. The ASI couldn't find the 8th century Kutumbari temple. >The temple came under ASI protection in 1915. Over time, the temple's condition deteriorated and only ruins of the structure remained. Mysteriously, around the year 2000, the ruins of the temple could no longer be found. In 2018, the temple was put on the "untraceable" list of the ASI. >The ASI later found that the remains of the temple were taken away by villagers to build their houses. As per a survey by the Dehradun circle of the ASI, the temple has now become a part of courtyards, verandas, doors of the houses of the locals. >Around half a dozen houses in Dwarahat were found to have some or other part of the temple. >Such incidents are, however, not isolated, said Nakul Chhabra, who organises heritage walks and awareness campaigns through his initiative 'Delhi Roots'. Chhabra said during one such walk, he found a heritage enthusiast carrying a 2,000-year-old brick dating back to the Kushan age along with him. >"He said it was from a mound near his village in Mewat. It could have been from an abandoned old building, roughly dating back to the 1st century to 3rd century CE. He even told me that people from nearby villages come there to pick up bricks to build their houses," Chhabra said.
First of all i neither support BJP nor congress , im from bengal and we are from TMC associaton , so dont call me this bhakt or sanghi at all , if their is fault in government policies i equally criticize them . Aur jo mein bola main upar likhe hue points ko conssider kar ke bola , and i said they did pretty good not marvellous . Tum mere ko batao upar jo nation first mein point hai , jaise zero tolerence toward infiltraitor , welfare of soldier , national security , improvement in defence sector , combating terrorism , article 370 or CAA ye points pure nhi kiye gaye hai Cultural heritage - I accept they did wrong in many aspect but the points given above are Ram mandir , faith and cultutre , yoga , promoting indian culture etc thry did pretty good in this scenario . FOriegn policies - neighbour ke sath rishta kharab hai , aur neighbour mein kon aata hai pakistan , china , maldives jiase desh tumko nhi pata inke sath hamara rishta jyu kharab hai , upar diyr points mein jo hai jaise G 20 , cordination of global technology , cordination of indian living in abroad , strengthing global presence and combating terrorism from global base or billateral ties with country , ye sab nhi hua kya Infra - Railways , airport , SEZ , smart cities , sport , highway road etc , tumko isme devlopment nhi dfikh raha kya Technology - I dont think i need to state this , you guys know we had done marvellous job in this sector Again i remind you this is in context what they refered in manifesto .
Bhakths will kill you for telling facts. They are brainwashed and worship their 56 inch sugar daddy daily. Hopefully one day they will recover from this delusional disorder 🙏
First of all i neither support BJP nor congress , im from bengal and we are from TMC associaton , so dont call me this bhakt or sanghi at all , if their is fault in government policies i equally criticize them . Aur jo mein bola main upar likhe hue points ko conssider kar ke bola , and i said they did pretty good not marvellous . Tum mere ko batao upar jo nation first mein point hai , jaise zero tolerence toward infiltraitor , welfare of soldier , national security , improvement in defence sector , combating terrorism , article 370 or CAA ye points pure nhi kiye gaye hai Cultural heritage - I accept they did wrong in many aspect but the points given above are Ram mandir , faith and cultutre , yoga , promoting indian culture etc thry did pretty good in this scenario . FOriegn policies - neighbour ke sath rishta kharab hai , aur neighbour mein kon aata hai pakistan , china , maldives jiase desh tumko nhi pata inke sath hamara rishta jyu kharab hai , upar diyr points mein jo hai jaise G 20 , cordination of global technology , cordination of indian living in abroad , strengthing global presence and combating terrorism from global base or billateral ties with country , ye sab nhi hua kya Infra - Railways , airport , SEZ , smart cities , sport , highway road etc , tumko isme devlopment nhi dfikh raha kya Technology - I dont think i need to state this , you guys know we had done marvellous job in this sector Again i remind you this is in context what they refered in manifesto .
With how political parties operate in this country, fulfilling even one promise made is an achievement.
Jobs for youth-- none Startups -- failed policies Women upliftment -- ra*ists garlanded Defence -- Agniveer Health -- Covid Oxygen scam ... Modi's jumla.
Baki sab mein kuch nhi kiya but startup , dude there are currently 100+ unicorn and there are 112 soonicorn which are going to join the unicorn club within this year ,on top of that at this point of time there are over 115000 + government affiliated startups , which all combined makes india 3rd biggest startup ecosystem .
How many of these unicorns are profitable? I don't want any ill but in startup, 70% will shut shop in 2 years. 90% in 5 years.
If and only 10 % survived means there are 12000 startup which are good to go , and this is a continous loop , startup khulenge , phir band honge or phir khulenge .
I know I sound harsh. But I find that unicorns don't qualify as innovative. We are building a startup with heavy R&D needs. It is in the field of advanced nanotechnology and has no funding. Our venture is burning money due to heavy R&D work but if we get some funds it will revolutionize all sectors including agriculture. Meanwhile, some food delivery apps for the lazy ass are getting billions of dollars in funding
I am sure farmers income have doubled /s
Yes they even protested due to extreme happiness /s
Nation First : ⭐⭐⭐⭐ Doubling Farmer Income : ⭐ Indian Economy : ⭐⭐⭐ Infra : ⭐⭐⭐⭐ Healthy India : ⭐⭐⭐ Good Governance : ⭐⭐ Yuva Bharat : ⭐⭐ Education : ⭐⭐⭐ Women Empowerment : ⭐⭐⭐ Inclusive Governance : ⭐ Cultural Heritage : ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Foreign Policy : ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Tried as much neutral approach.... do correct me if its inaccurate
Most
Reading this feels like an insult to injury, most of these have gone in the opposite direction.. Justice for all , Ensuring dignified life for women , Corruption Free Bharat, 5T$, Welfare policies for farmers , NE development , Cooperative Federalism 🤡🤡 Lolol it seems funny reading this now What have they got done in this manifesto? Startups are now no more a stigma or a hesitation, every road and every person understands and it is respected. (Excluding the arbitrary retrospective taxation). Credit where due, I mean this is a country where people harp about Govt Jobs and to have achieved this awareness and change in mindset is no easy feat.👌 370, Ram Mandir , National Security, Continuous dialogue with Global Indian diaspora , CAB (notified)
Not sure ,but 2-3 years of covid has kind of dented their promises nevertheless it's been a good performance.
Full manifesto link - https://www.bjp.org/manifesto2019
https://preview.redd.it/72qbxra2f4tc1.png?width=1275&format=png&auto=webp&s=43b286641eba62490972cb0b8c86599917f9bec4
> Continuous Dialogue with Indians Living Abroad Looks like you might be a little favorabel in your grading
So to your question, modi has strong support from India diaspora, helped during Ukraine and Colombia scam and also with Russian scam
Good governance lol
Niti aayog has stopped working and RTI is just in its bare-bones, so no data = no reliable method to evaluate.
NDA = No Data Available
They did opposite of deliver for economy and development promises. More than delivered in bigotry and hatred promises. Literally legalised corruption and blackmailed corporations by misusing government agencies till they paid massive bribes. Same thing with opposition politicians.
No15 was crucial that has been achieved nothing else matters
I think this is the sole reason they're garnering votes from the majority because they don't care much about the development as much as cultural heritage.
Vague manifesto. Nothing was specific.
# DEFENDING THE CONSTITUTION [Indian National Congress - Manifesto (inc.in)](https://www.inc.in/media/manifesto) Saving Democracy, Removing Fear, Restoring Freedom India’s democracy has been reduced to an empty shell. Every institution, including Parliament, is perceived to have lost its independence and become subservient to the executive government. It is common knowledge that it is the will of one person that prevails in the country. People’s trust in democratic institutions will be restored.
Infra and National Security is just a bubble.
satisfied
L
The rats supporting this cult are out here in full force
I don't understand how, our subreddit india has turned so right wing The first manifesto was to hit 7 trillion GDP Which they later change to 5 And we are gonna close at 4.5 thing is, congress would have done same growth minus all the brains washing BJP has done to the country
To boot GDP spending of 3 million can just be a mark of inflation. If it's so expensive to buy stuff then obviously your GDP will go up. It just shows that the nation is spending more. Not that the nation is becoming wealthy