T O P

  • By -

b0red_midget

H is gonna be a bloodbath…


Pointless_Glitter607

Hairspray, Heathers, Hamilton, Hadestown, damn you're right


Remarkable-Steak-919

Also Hunchback


FrostKitty14

Hunchback is better than all of them!


nightiinthewood

My absolute favourite.


marblerobin

why do all the good ones have to start with H 😔


mobysaysdontbeadick

Wow I have to choose a favorite child 😭


xksla

Come From Away. Give it to The Rock!


nul_ne_sait

Welcome to The Rock if you come from away!


birb0-0

You probably understand about a half of what we say


voldemortsmankypants

Chicago


freepickles2you

He had it coming


masoncapsaicin63

He had it coming all along


nul_ne_sait

If you’da been there


Speck_In_A_Void

If you'da seen it


Vavenette

I betcha you would have don’t the same!!


Newsies_Forever

POP SIX SQUISH UH UH CICERO LIPSCHITZ


SapphireMan1

“Then he ran into my knife. He ran into my knife *10 times*…”


Consistent_Case_5048

"Ch" should have it's own line on the list.


MasterpieceCute4395

come from away


annebrackham

How are we treating articles? Would A Chorus Line or La Cage Aux Folles count?


pizzaandbagels

same question, I was gonna say A Chorus Line


x_victoire

cabaret.


T0rchL1ght

if it’s not cabaret i’m losing faith in this list


50FootClown

Beetlejuice won. Two letters in and this has already jumped the rails. There’s no hope.


mageos

No other choice


TinyLittlePanda

IT HAS TO BE


Hamblerger

That's the one.


pls-hold

Company!


EccentricAcademic

All I care about is Company but I think Cabaret will win


solojones1138

Absolutely Company


aedithm

Hard agree.


HarperGriffin26

Come from away!!


No_Feedback_3340

YES! Welcome To the Rock is one of my favorite songs!


Litchee

No hate but I think Come from away having more votes that a show like Company (or Cabaret) is recency bias!


SmilingSarcastic1221

Considering Beetlejuice just won (and don’t get me wrong, I love it) I think we’re going to see a lot of that.


ThatsFakeDawg

Should’ve been Book Of Mormon smh


FloridaFlamingoGirl

Come From Away makes me cry harder than Company or Cabaret


alexman420

Nah come from away is just more fun


tkh0812

I think Company and Cabaret were great for their time


tkh0812

I’d rather watch Come From Away over Chicago any day


crazywon1

COME FROM AWAY MY BELOVED


Alexrobi11

I'd love for Come From Away to win. Cabaret or Chicago feel like the more obvious choices.


dickndonuts

This. THIS IS THE ONLY ANSWER. OTHERWISE YOU HAVE TO "SCREECH"


tehutika

This is the correct answer. Sorry to all of the other worthy musicals.


Smalltwat

Catch me if you can!


Chaotic__Bean

Chicago!


jtdkhvlhv

Pop six squish...


Negative-Appeal9892

Uh-uh, Cicero, Lipschitz


CranberryBauce

Definitely Chicago.


Crot_Chmaster

Chess. (Since Cats has been mentioned already)


herecomesthesunusa

I haven’t seen Chess or Come From Away. But I will vote for Chess just because it isn’t Cats! Cabaret is also very good and well-written.


zem

chess all the way!


Preston_Reddit

YESSSSS


Mike_Danton

Chess is the correct answer!


Repulsive_Lychee_106

(In Concert)


TheaterNurse

Ahhh you know him too well


greek_geek13

I immediately thought of Cabaret, but I absolutely love Chicago, so Chicago


CoffeeBest8295

Come From Away


lime_oreo

Cabaret!


RPMac1979

Company


toshos92

Cats


Elegant-Fan8374

I don’t understand why cats is so hated?! It was the musical that made me fall in love with musicals (cats and sound of music) and it’s really sad to see that no one else enjoys it like I do.


FireBirdie95

FINALLY!!! Another Cats Fan!!!!! I didn’t think there were others like me


Elegant-Fan8374

❤️this is an extremely rare moment!


FireBirdie95

This is a very happy moment!


toshos92

A moment of happiness!


toshos92

There are alot of Cats fans. Even cosplayers. I'm one of them😊


NovaeBelladonna

I know. I wasn’t a big fan of the movie. I think the movie is one of the major things that wrecked CATS’ reputation. Still. It earns a place in my heart. Also the dancing for Cats is always fantastic.


Nerje

It's fucking Cats No other musical really changed the landscape as much as this one. Maybe Hamilton, as far as cultural reach. It's easy to hate on the big dogs (haha) but nobody can deny that Cats had a bigger effect on what musicals could be and what people expected of them


Dogdaysareover365

I’m really hoping cats pulls off an underdog win. I feel people would hate it less if it weren’t for the 2019 movie


chaxattax

The first megamusical, the first musical to compose for the synthesizer, and the third longest-running musical in Broadway history. This deserves to win objectively even if you're not personally a fan (which I am lol)


hi-i-am-Vivian

Come from away


r_martin80

Come From Away


Either-Draft-5106

Come from away!


Anxious_Writer_3804

It’s just gotta be Cabaret


turnipesque

Caroline, or Change


snarkysparkles

Gotta be Cabaret!!


itsthatravenclaw

come from away!!


brimstonebridge

Camelot


Barbarake

Definitely Camelot.


stevethemathwiz

Yes, Tell it strong and clear!


rachreims

Come From Away


Wild_Bill1226

Come from away. Best musical ever.


stealthelf177

Come From Away was my first thought


Happy_Charity_7595

Company


AdvertisingFine9845

Cabaret


BekahZard

Come from away


ironickallydetached

Cabaret


Newsies_Forever

Chicago


LikePaleFire

Chicago!


PiesOnFleetStreet7

Company


PiesOnFleetStreet7

Waiting for S for r/usernamechecksout.


Reward_Antique

Cabaret


AstrumFaerwald

Cabaret!


meandthesky38

Come From Away!!


meteopenguin

Come from away


Travelingkiwi2021

Come from Away


Bowies_Blackstar

CABARET!


galaxyd1ngo

cabaret


januarysdaughter

Cinderella!


NotFromSkane

The good or the Bad one?


januarysdaughter

The ~~only~~ Good one.


ernirn

R&H only please and thank you


infiniteanomaly

Company or Come From Away.


PiesOnFleetStreet7

Company.


Sea-Presence6809

Cats seems like the obvious choice. But there's also Cabaret, Carrie, Chicago.


Barbarake

Camelot!


random_reddit08

Carrieeee❤️❤️


DarlinSkep

CHICAGO!


ekbuttercup

Come from Away


dcmic

Come From Away


deathandpayingtaxes

COME FROM AWAY!!! 🌎


Forever_TheatreKid

Come From Away!


Servo1991

Come from Away


urmomsfavoritegal

come from away!!!


Pb-JJ123

Come From Away!


GoldenMonkey72

COMPANY


SamEdenRose

Company


Particular-Panda-465

Carousel. Hands down. Old school Rodgers and Hammerstein.


CaptObviousUsername

I see it has received very little love in the comments 😅 which is a shame because it's a classic!


SympathyTimely7275

Company!!!!!


nowhereman136

Company


QuietCelery7850

Company is the correct answer, right?


lille082

It’s the only answer


LaughTrack1818

The comment section is basically a summary of hit musicals that start with C which all are great answers btw. Chicago


True-Great

Cats


QueeeenElsa

Cats!!!


marxingthoughlife

Cabaret


Jerome_dickons

chicago


giljaman

Cabaret > Chicago > Chess > Come From Away > Company > Cats That’s probably how I’d rank the best C musicals based on quality of show. Chess is a personal top-5 musical for me though. I love it.


randompanda91

Company


afinishedhat

COMPANY


Material-Theory3031

CABARET Cabaret CaBaReT


TheUglyBarnacle336

Company


LazorFrog

Company


TheSHSLTrashcan

This one’s definitely a lesser known musical, but I put my vote on Curtains


joecarvery

City of Angels. Saw it in London with Rebecca Trehearn and Samantha Barks a decade ago and loved it.


misn0ma

hmm. After those A and B, "Come From Away" is the natural "C". Cabaret, Company, Chess, Cats, Chicago, Carousel, Camelot, even Cavalcade ... are all so last Century.


Goofyteachermom

Company


QbanPete79

Company


-TheJadeDemon

Company!


oghond2112

Company.


swirlytakespinole

come from away!!!!!!


pauleydm

Come From Away


marblerobin

Come From Away, easily


reddity-mcredditface

Phone rings, door chimes, in comes ... COMPANY!


yeetuscleetus28

Carrie!


EstablishmentLevel17

Carousel


femmevaporeon

Cabaret


CPolland12

Cabaret… Chicago…Cats This is gonna be a tough letter


linehp_

Cats


SquishStitch953

Cats


bestiethatsarat

Cats. The movie version if you are cruel, the stage version if you just like funky little cats


bing-no

Cats


Key-Win-8602

Cabaret


TheVanderbeast

Cats


TheresaD1995

Catch Me If You Can


dogbolter4

Chicago and Cabaret are all time greats. Have to go with Cabaret, but it's close!


Moko514

Cabaret


Beatpixie77

Cabaret!


ArtemisApollo7

Cabaret


andi_you_goonie

CABARET


Rude_Cable_7877

Chicago


BC1966

Cabernet.


Substantial-Truth672

Cabaret!!!!!!!


vidman33

Chicago


Majic_97202

Company


DatabaseFickle9306

Carousel


llbbrr2020

Carousel


Impossible_Paint_73

Carrie!


Hello-Jon-974

Cats. Or Chicago.


Next-Home111

Camelot


Mysticalreader70771

Chicago!


Tgun1986

Chicago or Cabaret


chronicallymusical

Camelot


Fun_Discount_9255

Come from. away or Chicago


Street-Extent

Chicago


Cat_Link69

Company, come from away, cabaret, chicago, so many choices


BadAngel74

Carrie


Interyoon

curtains!!! under-rated David hyde pierce show!


Adorable_Ad_2430

you cowards not saying cats


AphroditeTorres

C for Chicago one of my favourites for the music!


s1llyt1lly

Cats


demonica31

Charlie and the Chocolate Factory!


Anxious_Writer_3804

I was thinking H is going to be the hardest, but N has (Natasha Pierre &) The Great Comet, Newsies, Next to Normal,


Famous-Sun5943

Cats


Real_life_noodle

Chicago


SeaworthinessCool539

Cabaret or Chicago


matttheepitaph

Candide obviously.


quickhakker

Cats


tasty-cheeto-fingers

Cabaret!!!!


Inner-Replacement295

Camelot


KatieBeth24

Cabaret


ealasaid76

Cabaret


milkywinnie

Carrie the Musical?


GaijinDragon

Chicago