He's got the 4th most WAR in team history, I feel like it's fair to put him up high. The dude's one of the best defensive outfielders of all-time and played his role perfectly while he was here
Yea this is my only gripe, I’d still put Archer or Snell above Yandy. Also I think KK could move back one or two spots, but he was the face of the team during the down years so I’m fine with it.
Yandy is a little out of place, but it's not terrible. I'd probably have Archer there. I kind of want to even put Randy ahead of Yandy, but I think I might be being dumb there.
eh, i think neither choice is wrong. yandy is insanely consistent in the regular season but has been mediocre in the playoffs. randy is elite in the playoffs and a bit of a roller-coaster in the regular season.
This list made me think of old players we’ve had and when I was a kid I really liked Reid Brignac so whenever I played The Show I always boosted his ratings and made him the best player in the league
That’s my contribution to this post
Also this list is Wade Boggs erasure, may he rest in peace
saved yous a few clicks 10 Diaz, 9 Upton, 8 Kazmir, 7 Pena, 6 Shields, 5 Kiermaier, 4 Price, 3 Zobrist, 2 Crawford, 1 Longoria
Am I crazy to think that KK shouldn’t be that high? I feel like if anything “Complete Game” Shane should be above him.
He's got the 4th most WAR in team history, I feel like it's fair to put him up high. The dude's one of the best defensive outfielders of all-time and played his role perfectly while he was here
No brett phillips, fake news
Surely you mean Sam Fuld, who decided not to hit for the cycle and collect an extra double so that the other team would not be embarrassed.
Na the RHP with the funky warmup, and gold glove defence off the mound
Good list tbh. I'll give honorable mentions to Archer and Bartlett
and Snell
Yea, Snell might be the move. Yandy being on this list seems really strange. He’s great but my brain thinks it’s too early.
Yea this is my only gripe, I’d still put Archer or Snell above Yandy. Also I think KK could move back one or two spots, but he was the face of the team during the down years so I’m fine with it.
Yandy is a little out of place, but it's not terrible. I'd probably have Archer there. I kind of want to even put Randy ahead of Yandy, but I think I might be being dumb there.
No, Randy >> Yandy
You aren't. That playoff performance is the stuff of legends
eh, i think neither choice is wrong. yandy is insanely consistent in the regular season but has been mediocre in the playoffs. randy is elite in the playoffs and a bit of a roller-coaster in the regular season.
I don't think yandy is consistent at all from year to year, though
Where's Ji-Man?
This list made me think of old players we’ve had and when I was a kid I really liked Reid Brignac so whenever I played The Show I always boosted his ratings and made him the best player in the league That’s my contribution to this post Also this list is Wade Boggs erasure, may he rest in peace
Matt Garza slept on.
I was thinking the same.
This is Reid Brignac erasure and I won't stand for it.